Learn more Download now Shop now Learn more Shop now Shop now Shop now Shop now Shop now Learn More Shop now Shop now Learn more Shop Fire Shop Kindle The Grand Tour Prize Draw Learn more Shop Women's Shop Men's

Customer reviews

4.8 out of 5 stars
6
4.8 out of 5 stars
Cluny Brown
Format: Hardcover|Change

on 25 January 2016
I am so very glad I tracked down a modestly priced old copy of Cluny Brown. Some of Sharp’s books are now so rare that they are offered for four figure sums! I can only say that I hope Sharp’s dedicated champions can persuade a publishing house to re-issue her books, so more of us have a chance to read more of them. She is a delightful, nicely sharp, well-crafted, light-touch writer of wit. I have seen her described as a kind of ‘early chick-lit’ All I can say is there is an irony, a kind of delicate and barbed mockery of the class system, that is a million miles away from the (admittedly few) chick-lit books I have read.

Published in 1944, but set a good 6 or more years earlier, when the idea of war was beginning to rumble away in people’s minds, but war had not been declared, this must have been some kind of much-needed temporary escape from the darkness of the world at war.

Clover (Cluny) Brown is a young, working class woman, only just out of her teens. She is an orphan, presently living with her Uncle, Mr Porritt, a plumber. Cluny is Porritt’s secretary/clerk/message taker. She is, everyone around her insists, remarkably plain. ‘Plain As A Boot’ And very tall. Except, she is really what the French call ‘Jolie Laide’ and certainly her vitality, intelligence and forthrightness are much more alluring and attractive than might be imagined at first glance. One of the major problems with Cluny, at least from the perspective of the more conventionally minded in her world, is that she just doesn’t seem to ‘know her place’. She acts unconventionally, out of class and out of gender – taking herself for tea at the Ritz, having far too much confidence and lack of becoming deference, so that those far above her in class occasionally think she is one of them, making friends with a colonel who doesn’t realise she is only ‘a tall parlourmaid’ The despairing cry from all around is ‘Cluny Brown – Who Does She Think She Is?’ The answer is, alive, enchanting, exhilarating. Following an event where she decides to pick up one of her Uncle’s plumbing jobs, and discovers the attractions of a dry martini, her Uncle decides the safest thing is to make sure she fits in to her proper and expected station in life. And goes into service. She becomes The Tall Parlourmaid for an Aristocratic Devonshire Family.

Margery Sharp assembles a cast of strong and quirky characters, all of whom might seem to be examples of ‘types’ – the stunningly beautiful vamp, the scion of the aristocratic house who espouses radical socialist ideas, a louche Polish literary hero, the lady of the manor, all gardening and good works – but Sharp renders them all much more interesting, much more contradictory, and, all of them, much more likeable. Her pen is sharp, but it is also fizzy, joyous, expansive. There is no spitefulness, no meanness of spirit in her writing.

What I most appreciated is that Cluny gets the journey the reader wants her to have – the journey she deserves. There is, I’m sure, a destination which we might discover we are fearing. Perhaps another author would have given her a different outcome. I’m so pleased that Sharp is not a punitive author. Neither is she saccharine, but she views humanity with warmth, I feel.

4 1/2 stars, rounded up to 5
0Comment| 5 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
TOP 500 REVIEWERon 14 April 2016
Cluny Brown is no ordinary parlour maid. Sent into service by her well-meaning aunt and uncle “for her own good” so that she can at last learn to “know her place”, the experience, as might be expected from the moment the reader meets Cluny, is doomed to failure. A smart and funny social comedy, a clever and astute comedy of manners, the book is a delight, witty, observant, with a keen eye for social nuances, it is nonetheless never bland or frothy. After all the year is 1938 and World war looms. Far worse disasters than Cluny’s ill-fated attempt to be a parlour maid are on the horizon. A thoroughly enjoyable read and a great joy to see Margery Sharp’s novels once more widely available.
0Comment| 2 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
TOP 1000 REVIEWERon 12 April 2016
I received an e-ARC of this novel through NetGalley and Open Road Integrated Media.

What an utterly charming reading experience this novel was for me. Not having read anything previously by Margery Sharp I had no idea of what I might find. The result was a true delight. This was light and sweet and humorous in bringing the spotlight on the English class system and what happens when someone doesn't fit into their "place". Yet there was no malice or cruelty involved, just warm feelings for a world which might have only existed to this extent in the pages of novels anyway.

It seems that this and other novels by Margery Sharp are being reissued in electronic book format. I can only hope that will tempt more people to read Cluny Brown and then move on to read more of Ms. Sharp's novels just as I will be doing. In this book Cluny can't help but feel that she wants things to happen to her so she steps out of her social position and makes them happen. Unfortunately this leads her Uncle to feel that the young woman needs some serious taking in hand. Finding that Cluny had gone out to unblock a sink when the call came in for her plumber uncle on a Sunday afternoon, Uncle Arn is beside himself when he finds Cluny alone with a bachelor in his home and she's been in the bathroom. Put those words in italics, and underline them because that's how much of a serious social infraction Cluny is guilty of. Yet she is genuinely oblivious to any damage to her reputation which might have come about by exploring this very opulent room, the likes of which she has never seen. Something simply has to be done about Cluny before she gets herself into more trouble. Uncle Arn didn't think it could get worse than Cluny going to tea at the Ritz alone, but this proves him wrong.

Once Cluny makes her way into service at Friars Carmel in Devonshire and becomes a Tall Parlour-maid in training, the people living in the house and the neighborhood have varied, but positive, reactions to her. Cluny, however, takes on the work and the people in her own inimitable way - with absolutely no idea of how she changes the lives of those she meets. There are wonderfully developed characters in this book from all the many layers of the social scale represented with the specter of the possibility of another war hanging over the novel. Set in 1938 in what was once a lavish lifestyle setting the changes to the entire population are about to change dramatically again, but the novel doesn't dwell on what is to happen in the future. Cluny isn't beautiful, in fact she's plain, so she doesn't cause problems from that aspect. She is intelligent, but from a common sense standpoint so that doesn't cause problems. She just doesn't know her place so she keeps finding herself being treated as if she belongs everyplace. It makes some people nervous while others are delighted.

I laughed out loud at some of the really insightful zingers delivered by Ms. Sharp, but she never made me uncomfortable by being mean-spirited about the great country house and those who live in it. I was reminded a little bit of the writing of P. G. Wodehouse describing all the misunderstandings that lead to laughable tangles. It was all great fun and a relaxing, enjoyable, comfortable reading experience.
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 17 September 2016
Social history, manners, knowing your place and being expected to stay there.

I enjoyed the characterisation of Cluny, from humble beginnings with some tragedy, having been raised by extended family to her acknowledging and somewhat conforming to her expected position in life but having the inner spirit to try expand her world and experience life beyond.

A most enjoyable and positive story - would like to have followed more of Cluny's adventures.
0Comment| One person found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 17 February 2007
Margery Sharp's particular gift is for making heroines and heroes out of ordinary people. All her characters are shockingly normal, not particularly beautiful (except for Elizabeth Cream in this story), not even amazingly clever, but people that one can relate to and have hope that extraordinary things can happen in our lives too. Cluny Brown is tall and angular, but to some she is beautiful and this gives hope to readers. She has dreams and dares to put them into reality - very Chestertonian! Her romantic life starts off with a sense of resignation but she takes the glorious opportunity when it comes and is catapulted into a new life, tantalisingly sketched out and wisely not fleshed out by Margery Sharp. This author has a wise and sensitive touch.
0Comment| 4 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 16 February 2015
1 have this book for as long as i remember. Real comfort reading! I also loved the film and I'm still waiting for it to be replayed on television. The

main parts were played by Wendy Hillier and Charles Boyer. 5 STARS
0Comment| 2 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse


Need customer service? Click here