17 of 20 people found the following review helpful
A great memoir, but also a missed opportunity,
This review is from: The Living Years (Kindle Edition)
For dyed-in-the-wool Genesis fans this book is a must-read: the first memoir by one of only two of the band's members who've been there since the very beginning. However, for the casual Genesis or Mike + The Mechanics fan, there really isn't much which hasn't been dealt with in more depth in other biographies. As a genre, the autobiography tends to succeed depending on how controversial it is. While there is the occasional surprising revelation in The Living Years, there are very few indiscretions.
The most entertaining aspect is of course the first-person immediacy; reading about events in Genesis's history from someone who was there, whereas until now Genesis fans have had to make do with third-person biographies (the most thorough being 2007's Chapter and Verse). But Rutherford's life is not only about the music. His father was a captain in the Royal Navy who saw action during World War Two. Interestingly, Rutherford junior draws parallels between his own career and his father's, so at the beginning of the book we get excerpts from Rutherford senior's unpublished memoirs as well.
This is a highly enjoyable literary device which, unfortunately, only lasts for around the first third of the book. Once Rutherford junior has joined Genesis, the emphasis is very much on the band, and the author proceeds chronologically through the Genesis discography until his father passes away in 1986, when Rutherford was in the middle of the Invisible Touch tour. Afterwards, he goes through Mike + The Mechanics very quickly, and 2007's Turn It On Again tour is also not dealt with in any depth.
I can't help feeling that this memoir should have been substantially longer. The literary device of using excerpts from his late father's unpublished memoirs was excellent, and should have been kept up throughout the whole book. In addition, I think Rutherford could have said a great deal more on how he created his music: we do get descriptions, especially of songs like The Living Years and Land of Confusion, but I finished this book wishing he'd spent several thousand more words going into a lot more depth. On the one hand, perhaps he feels there's not that much more to be said, but on the other I think a lot of people are very interested and would have appreciated a greater creative analysis. Certainly a missed opportunity.
Also, on my Kindle version there were around fifteen significant typographical issues: a few repeated words, a number of words which ran together, and - unforgivably for a traditionally published book - two instances of "less" which should have been "fewer". However, these mistakes did not spoil my enjoyment of the book, and I point them out only because, as a traditionally published book, potential readers are being asked to pay top money for it.
In summary: absolutely a must-read for serious Genesis fans, it's like having a private interview with Rutherford; some parts are surprisingly personal and more revealing than information in previous Genesis biographies. It is a joy to read about events in Genesis's history from Rutherford's own perspective. For the casual fan, there is still much to enjoy, and this is a wonderful insight into the evolution of the greatest rock band in the world. The only drawback is the book's brevity - it could have, and really should have, been quite a bit longer than it is.
Sort: Oldest first | Newest first
Showing 1-2 of 2 posts in this discussion
Initial post: 28 Jan 2014 12:11:30 GMT
I have had the feeling that the publisher was leaning on Rutherford to push the relationship with his father angle more, a bit like in the fictional 'I, Partridge' where Alan alleges Harper Collins pushed him to tell about troubles he had with his father! Only the mistakes were deliberate.
Posted on 3 Mar 2014 15:39:06 GMT
I smiled as I read this review, when I got to the bit about wishing that the memoir had been "substantially longer" - exactly the comment I made to my wife, having read, and generally enjoyed the book. I'm a Genesis fan (obviously) but not a massive fan, so I was not aware of much of the information that was divulged. However, I expected, as Christopher Wells and others also mention, much more detail about their approach to recordings, how albums were recorded, how they arrived at the lyrics - it may sound dull but to dyed-in-the wool fans, it's of genuine interest. Being an old square myself, I was surprised that he (and the others for that matter) did so much marijuana smoking. As for the large joint in the bag episode, how stupid and careless was that? I digress. Being also, a huge Wishbone Ash fan, I couldn't help but make comparisons with the Martin Turner (original lead singer and bass player) autobiography. To those (myself included) who felt that 'Living Years' was too short, take a look at Martin Turner's account of his time with Wishbone. It's a whopping 420-odd pages, but I simply couldn't put it down - it was a terrific read, and full of exactly the sort of information that I felt (and clearly others too) was missing from MR's autobiography. Too many historical aspects were simply skimmed over. If MR was concerned that the people reading the book wouldn't be interested in that sort of detail, then I think he was probably mistaken. Only people with an interest in him/Genesis would probably read it anyway. An enjoyable read, but a slightly wasted opportunity. Messrs Banks, Collins, Hackett, Gabriel - please take note!
‹ Previous 1 Next ›