7 of 7 people found the following review helpful
A superfluous live record... but feel the power!,
Verified Purchase(What is this?)
This review is from: Live In NYC (Audio CD)
Again, after many years eschewing the live album, Jane's Addiction - who have only released five proper records in thirty years - return with their third full length live release in four years (after 2009's "Live Voodoo" DVD, and 2011's "Live From Vive Latino" which came with special editions of the most recent album), this time, a 2011 concert from New York City at Terminal 5, on 25 July 2011 - not 2012, no matter what you may have read anywhere else. Sure, the music is amazing, transcendental, a combination of aspirational, zen visionary preaching and a deeply broken form of post-metal rock, but sometime between 1991 and 2003, Jane's Addiction stopped being artists who rocked, and became rockers who sometimes did art : here though, the set is taken from a tour called the "Theatre Of Escapists" - a better title for the record than the prosaically dull - "Live Insert Name of City", but only one song, "Irresistable Force", comes from the album : here, Jane's are a nostalgia act, bestrewn to 22 year old glories, always looking down and back, not up or forward to the future. Almost all of the night is given to old material ; only 2 songs are less than 20 years old, and lots of this record is also represented by the same lineup on "The Great Escape Artist"s deluxe edition live bonus CD : making this record a sort of exercise in redundancy, even if this lineup has not been represented with a live DVD before - only four songs are not on the "Vive Latino" CD. In the meantime, "Whores," "Ain't No Right", "Ted", "Three Days", "Mountain Song", "Been Caught Stealing", "Ocean Size" and "Jane Says" make their fourth live appearances (including the exhaustive "A Cabinet of Curiousities" box set which has a 1990 live show). But if you like Jane's Addiction, then you could, and should, love this ; as a record of one night of, a reminder, a glimpse of Jane's Addiction's immense power as a live act that still stand in the top ten bands - out of over a thousand - I have ever seen.
Sort: Oldest first | Newest first
Showing 1-2 of 2 posts in this discussion
Initial post: 29 Aug 2013, 03:02:44 BST
Mr. Martin Beard says:
i can see where your coming from but apart from the triplexxx 1st lp the others ive heard are trully awful in sound quality so shouldnt really be compared to this album the production is the best ive ever heard JA and if you were lucky enough to see this tour this is about as good a memory as you could want and lastly a thousand bands , you must be stuck in to much get out abit more ,martin 2013
In reply to an earlier post on 31 Aug 2013, 11:12:41 BST
Mr. M. A. Reed says:
I relistened to the 2011 Viva Latino live CD that came with "The Great Escape Artist" and it is a bit flat compared to this, yes.
‹ Previous 1 Next ›