This edition comes in a large but easy to handle volume. John walker who took over from Halliwell does an excellent job. There is a noticable discrepency in the rating of films by Halliwell and Walker. Many have been re-thought. In my opinion this reflects modern tastes and updates Halliwells preference for the early days of cinema. A must for the discerning film watcher. A crown deducted for the somewhat hard to navigate film indexing.