7 of 29 people found the following review helpful
From the Sublime to the Ridiculous,
This review is from: Borderline (Audio CD)
Ry Cooder is a superb guitarist, major catalyst (eg Buena Vista) and is most generous in bringing the attention of the world to many different types of music and musicians
Unfortunately he can't sing
You will rarely hear an album where the gap beween the quality of the the backing track and the lead vocals is so great. And that's why he has never personally achieved mainstream success for his own work
I wouldn't normally write such a negative review but someone somewhere needs to say this to aid potential purchasers
Sort: Oldest first | Newest first
Showing 1-9 of 9 posts in this discussion
Initial post: 12 Jul 2009, 08:09:24 BST
S. D. Crawshaw says:
I suppose its all about personal choice, but his voice is okay, and his music is sublime
Posted on 29 Mar 2011, 13:53:58 BST
S. J. Blackwood says:
I couldn't disagree more with "roy"
Have a listen again to "thats the way love turned out for me"
"Across the Borderline(far better than Freddy Fenders version)
"Get Rhythm (better than johnny Cash)
"Little Sister(way better than the Elvis version)"
"Lets have a ball"
The list is not exhaustive.Ry Cooder definatley has a great blues rock voice - very authentic in places.A very unique style for sure,but nothing wrong with that.His voice has a great quality of not knowing if it is a black guy or a white guy singing,and thats really cool.
I always get disapointed when his albums don't have much of his singing on it.It takes away so much from the Cooder experience.
In reply to an earlier post on 10 Jun 2011, 16:40:10 BST
I respect your view - fortunately we don't all like the same things
You only have to compare his lack of mainstream success with that of (say) Eric Clapton who IMHO is a journeyman guitarist with no clear style of his own, but who has got an expressive voice and is able to pen a few good tunes plus classics like Layla and Bell Bottom Blues
I think at this stage that Ry is never going to make it big - I think if you compare him with the top African-American guitar slingers I think there's only Albert Collins who wasn't a first rate singer but he managed to develop a style which suited his voice which didn't just sound like he was just singing a song
Thanks for reading my review though
Posted on 7 Jun 2012, 00:10:30 BST
Mr. S. M. Rowell says:
So what, it's all in the delivery mate. Would you call Dylan a great singer!!!. I rest my case.
In reply to an earlier post on 22 Nov 2012, 00:01:54 GMT
I agree that Dylan is a great singer
Look at people he influenced - like Jimi Hendrix, even Levi Stubbs (Listen to Reach Out I'll be there)
In any case, all music criticism is just a matter of opinion
I really tried to like Ry's singing ...
Posted on 8 Jan 2013, 16:50:08 GMT
Last edited by the author on 8 Jan 2013, 16:51:40 GMT
Ry Cooder's never "made it big"?!! How many albums? How many movie scores?
How many guitarists rate him as one of the best? Just coz he ain't on Top of the Pops doesn't make him a failure for God's sake! The man is a legend in his own lifetime, and although he may not be a great singer, he is a superb musician & guitarist highly regarded by his peers, of which you are sadly not one.
Posted on 3 May 2013, 12:43:57 BST
[Deleted by the author on 3 May 2013, 12:46:27 BST]
In reply to an earlier post on 3 May 2013, 12:46:15 BST
S. J. Blackwood says:
I would say Ry has been very succesful. The only reason he has not been as succesful as Clapton - who I also like, is because of the material he has chosen to do over the years. He has never sold out to make a quick buck - but stayed true to his muse. Eric despite claims to the opposite sadly has in my opinion.
I believe Ry to be as good a singer as Eric no problem. I also think he is vastly superior to the likes of Dylan - (who incidently totally disproves the myth that you need a good voice to make it big ! - the list is not exhaustive!)
Ry's voice is almost as important as his guitar for me on a recording. I accept and respect that you don't "like" his voice (personal taste) but as a decent vocalist myself, I don't understand how you can call him a "bad " singer...
P.s . - check out Ry's vocals on "Cold Cold Feeling" on his new album - great blues vocals!
Posted on 29 Jan 2017, 18:03:51 GMT
James A. Campbell says:
This reviewer reveals a complete lack of knowledge of Ry Cooder & his vast array of work for himself & especially others.
‹ Previous 1 Next ›