Since reviews are being mingled together, this review is specific to this offering.
I was expecting a Signed Version to contain signatures of the band, but this isn't what I got. What you get is four "doodles", with nothing to indicate which band member did what. It really does look amateurish and pathetic. If you want a CD with scrawled doodles, then this item is for you. However, I am deeply disappointed at it, it's certainly not worthy of any signed album collection.