I bought this tray mainly for the colour! It's strong and sturdy and doesn't move about. The high back lid is very good for preventing litter from being kicked all over the floor by my kitten. It's a good size and is plenty big enough for an adult-sized cat. The scoop is also very sturdy. If I had to criticise this product it would be that the high back lid never feels particularly secure. I wish it would 'click' into place so that I know it's securely fitted but it feels like it's just balancing on top of the tray.