1 of 15 people found the following review helpful
This review is from: Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows (Book 7) [Adult Edition] (Hardcover)
A lot of questioning has been given over the deaths in this book but i would just like to give my views before we go anywhere else.
Madeye i think was write to die as it was just fitting. Snape the same but he should of been given more of an envolment and greater send off in some way. Harry and him shouldn have made peace before the end. Dobby was the saddest for me (dnt no y)and that was probably the best laid out death in the book. now moving on to tonks AND Lupin. Now this was a bit unessasary. Lupin, maybe was write to go, it would be fitting to finish off the famous 4. (btw y the hell did lupin and harry have to argue) but to kill tonks aswell was just silly and pointless in my view.
I no lots think fred shouldn't have died and i agree although it would have been highly unrealistic for all the weasleys to survive you might agree. It would have been better if maybe Percy or Charlie died...maybe Bill.
Well thats the deaths covered, sorry if i missed any lol. Now to peops who should have die. Lucius (by hermione), one of the teachers probably should have gone, i know i know but it seems unrealistic.
now the book. I think the main reason this book wasnt like by some is not all to do with the camping. I think it was to do with the lack of hogwarts which to some (not me im too bigger fan) which made it feel weird.
I thought the book was generally amazing, ok maybe Voldemorts death was weird. The only thing i will say is that i would have liked to know what happened to more people. The weasleys, hagrid (even though we know he is still game keeper), did harry becmoe an AUROR!!! who is head of hogwarts!
I dont think this series should be knockd in anyway as its great! thnx JK
Sort: Oldest first | Newest first
Showing 1-1 of 1 posts in this discussion
Initial post: 3 Dec 2007 15:35:00 GMT
Elizabeth Trigg says:
I can't believe that someone would sit there and list all the deaths in the book like that! Don't you think that other people might want to enjoy the plot for themselves? People read reviews in order to decide whether to read the book or not. if you want to talk about the plot - join a book club.
‹ Previous 1 Next ›