This book is a hit with my 8-month-old daughter (and my 3-year-old son). My reservation with it is that all the tigers in the book look pretty much the same, so this format doesn't work that well with a tiger. We've read the "That's not my Bear" and "Puppy" books which have very different looking bears and dogs throughout, so it just reads better and is more interesting. Maybe I'm overanalysing a very basic children's book. And let's be honest - the real judges in my house think it's great!