My low rating has got nothing to do with music. The remastered version of this superb album sounds great and the outtakes cd proves how good Smashing Pumpkins were at their peak. My rating has to do with the fact that the remastered disc does not play properly. I returned the first one I received because there was a strange scratchy sounding noise when the disc was spinning. The replacement cd was even worse so now I am going to have to return it for a refund. The other cd in the box set plays perfectly, as does the original version of Siamese Dream I bought 20 years ago. I also bought the remastered gish box set and it has the same problem. I have a high quality red book cd player so I know the problem isn't with it.