I have tried many different ear cleaning products on my Golden Retrievers and Petkin Jumbo Ear wipes come out tops every time. My male Retiever Josh has problems with his ears which often results in many costly vets visits. Since I have been using the Petkins Jumbo ER wipes I haven't had to take him to the vets once . I now use them on my cat Lily who after a lot of fussing will ow line up with the dogs to have her ears cleaned, & if given the chance she often jumps the que . I won't be using any other product on my Pets Ears only the Petkin Jumbo Ear wipes.