Learn more Shop now Shop now Shop now Shop now Shop now Shop now Shop now Learn More Shop now Shop now Learn more Shop Fire Shop Kindle Kesha Learn more Fitbit

Customer reviews

5.0 out of 5 stars
5.0 out of 5 stars
5 star
4 star
3 star
2 star
1 star
Price:£26.63+ Free shipping with Amazon Prime

There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.

TOP 500 REVIEWERon 4 August 2014
This set was scheduled for release before the sudden rapid deterioration in health of Maestro Maazel, and was not intended as a tribute, but as the first posthumous release it will be seen as such by many.
It's origin is strange-the various divisions of Universal in different countries seem to be operating unilaterally-Germany has re-mastered the Bohm Ring and Sinopoli Mahler not originally intended for UK release, Australia has released recordings on the Eloquence Label not actually available in Europe, and as for Japan, there is a whole plethora of remastered discs from the Decca and DG catalogue which they advertise as being at 24Bits/100kHZ and which are only available from Japan at great expense -as I can testify!

This set emanates from Universal Italy, with the perfunctory notes a translation from Italian, for example. The set does not state that it is re-mastered at 24Bits, but Decca's promotional material does, and the sonic results confirm this!
The Italian source is perhaps not so strange, as Maazel was revered in Italy perhaps as nowhere else-he could do no wrong in La Scala Milan for example.
This brings me to my next point.
The rush of obituaries even in the UK have emphasised his direction of 3 great American Orchestras-but to my mind his greatest achievements were in Europe with orchestras with which he worked here, none more so than the VPO featured on this set and the BRSO which he led for nigh on 10 years.

This set is not even a smattering of the recordings he made in Vienna, and Decca have even omitted some glorious recordings contemporary to the featured performances, but the Tchaikovsky and Sibelius sets-the only complete sets ever made by the VPO of these composers-have always enjoyed legendary status, and it is easy to hear why.

Recorded between 1963 and 1972 by Decca's crack recording team in "studio conditions" in the famed Sofiensaal acoustic, these performances show the young Maazel at his most dynamic.
It is worth noting that during this period, he had already recorded Zarathustra with the Philharmonia of which he was Principal Guest Conductor, Schubert, Schumann and Prokofiev with the BPO, various sets including a sensational Firebird Suite with the Berlin Radio Symphony of which he was Director as well as of the German State Opera Berlin, French Music with French National Orchestra of which he was also Director-and had conducted Mozart in Salzburg and Lohengrin and The Ring in Bayreuth, all before Age 40- and this is but a few of his accomplishments.

This meant that he came to the works in this set as a fully rounded artist-they may be a younger man's performances but they have an assuredness about them which is palpable-and thrilling.

There is not time and space to analyse each performance, but all are at least worthy, many are just fabulous. I will single out the full version Manfred for particular praise, and the first two Sibelius Symphonies are "reference "performances-they have never been bettered.
The Fifth of Sibelius splits opinions-some find it too fast and thrusting, lacking the sense of suspended animation that they believe the work such embody, but others find it revelatory in the glorious and joyful sonorities that Maazel and the players-unfamiliar with the work in this period-conjure up. I love it.

The Strauss pieces were held as sensational on their release, particularly the " Tod und Verklarung"-and remain so today, though why they were included over the Karelia Suite and Tapiola is a mystery.

You don't have to find every work on this set totally convincing, and you probably won't-but it is never less than fascinating, certainly not dull and overall brilliant.
There is another appealing factor-the sound quality. These were all recorded under the "Culshaw Doctrine"-indeed one of the discs was produced by John Culshaw himself, and all were engineered by Gordon Parry, the High Priest of Culshaw Doctrine! The conviction was that full frequency stereo was a medium in itself, not a means of replicating concert conditions, and balances were manipulated to provide what they deemed as ideal sonics only otherwise possible in the composer's mind!

When Decca still existed and had its own technical team under the late James Locke, in re-mastering recordings of the Culshaw period they carefully reversed much of this process as the taste and expectations of the listening pubic have changed, not least as a result of the move to live performance recording. Perspectives and balances were altered to a more natural state, not always to the delight of those who treasured the original LP releases, but in this release the original intentions of Erik Smith, Culshaw and Parry have been left unaltered.

This really is the legendary Decca sound of the 60's and 70's with all that this entails-a massive organ sound in the Manfred finale, cellos at least 3 metres tall surely, etc.
It is glorious, not as extreme as Phase 4, but not the rather homogenised results of the modern era.
The set is worth it to experience this alone!

If you are looking for a complete set of either works by the same artists, there are few if any better overall. Together in this bargain box they make a compelling choice and will thus appeal not just to admirers of Maazel, the VPO or Decca recording techniques.
The Tchaikovsky and Sibelius are superior in every respect to later versions by the Maestro, the Strauss the equal at least.
Hopefully more of Maazel's enormous recorded legacy will reappear sonically revitalised, and at time of writing we still await the release of his final Mahler recordings, including Das Lied Von Der Erde which I had to the privilege to hear live at the concert in London.
Strongly recommended-5 Stars. Stewart Crowe.
55 Comments| 28 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 7 October 2015
I have many full sets of the Tchaikovsky symphonies, many containing individual favourites, but as a full set (including a wonderful Manfred symphony) I consider this V.P.O. set with Lorin Maazel to be one of the best and the only one I would keep if I had to make a choice. I have owned Maazel's Tchaikovsky and Sibelius symphonies on individual L.P's, (still do) in previous CD incarnations which seemed to have lost some of the terrific bite and fizz of the original L.P's. After sifting through a number of reviews I decided to purchase this latest boxed set of Lorin Maazel in Vienna - Tchaikovsky - Sibelius - R. Strauss: all superb performances and at a remarkable price, newly remastered and in the process restoring the recorded sound to its original intended state - vintage Decca. No more to say! Brilliant!!!
0Comment| 2 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 24 July 2014
There was a Tapiola too... it seems to have sunk without trace.

Well, I have received the set now, and, as far as I can tell the Sibelius symphonies are exactly as in the current box 430 778-2. The mastering seems to be the same (4, 7 and Tapiola were remastered for the Decca Legends series) as the complete box. This has been my preferred set of the complete Sibelius since they first appeared, with the VPO summoning playing of great clarity and icy expression. They must have been far out of their comfort zone, but the result is elemental and profound. Maazel's tendency to over-control proceedings is not really apparent here (as it is in the Sony Mahler cycle), and the result is extraordinary.

The Tchaikovsky items have been re-ordered, helpfully, so that the Fourth Symphony is not split over two cds. In addition to the contents of the Tchaikovsky symphony box (430 787-2) you get another CD with the 'Manfred' Symphony and 'Hamlet' as a filler. Richard Strauss's Don Juan and Tod und Verklärung have been added to the now separate discs of Tchaikovsky Symphonies 3 and 4.

My grumble about Tapiola remains, and I would draw your attention to the comments here which list other Sibelius items that could have been included - enough for a separate disc, perhaps?

I am listening to the 'new' Sibelius 4 through Sennheiser HD800 headphones, and pretty marvelous it does sound. That magic word 'Sofiensaal' is listed against every recording. While noting the missed opportunities, I am raising my rating to *****. Thank you so much for those who have taken the trouble to comment.

I made an amendment to this post to say that I had ordered a second-hand copy or Symphonies 4, 7 and Tapiola in a 24/96 remastering. It never appeared. I hope these notes don't suffer the same fate. Anyway, I have compared the 'Maazel in Vienna' box version with the 'remastered' version and I must say that I find them both fine. There is greater clarity and separation in the remastered version, but the version in the box under question is quite satisfactory - slightly more 'analogue' sounding, privileging warmth over the last word in clarity. Both are a joy. In short, echoing other comments, you should buy this box at its present bargain price and not worry about what marvels of completeness and remastering await us.

Wishing you all joy in the music.
1414 Comments| 24 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 31 August 2014
Hard to understand why Decca left off Tapiola & Karelia Suite, when the two would fit perfectly on the CD that has only the Tchaikovsky 5th on it (about 45:00 - those added to it would made it about 75:00 or so. Still, Maazel's Tchaikovsky and Sibelius with the Vienna P.O. stand the test of time very well, not only in performance, but also in sound. Naturally, with warhorses like these, there are no number ones, but those who know Decca and like the younger Maazel (1960s) shouldn't be disappointed.
0Comment| 4 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 5 March 2015
I ordered it and got it on time and am impressed with it
0Comment| One person found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 30 August 2014
Delivered as promised.
0Comment| One person found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse

Need customer service? Click here

Sponsored Links

  (What is this?)