Learn more Shop now Shop now Shop now Shop now Shop now Shop now Learn More Shop now Learn more Click Here Shop Kindle Amazon Music Unlimited for Family Shop now Shop Women's Shop Men's

There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.

on 29 April 2013
As most Moz fans know, 1991's "Kill Uncle" usually along with 1997's underwhelming "Maladjusted" are frequently described as the runt of the litter by most reviewers and fans alike. While "Maldjusted" is flawed and seems to be Moz going through the motions, with little creativity, lyrical greatness or the wit in which he is usually associated. After "Maladjusted" Moz took a 7 year break, something had to give and the break rejuvinated him. But "Kill Uncle" has none of these complaints. Moz isn't going through the motions, he was trying something new, a sort of mixture of 'Super-Pop' Morrissey with a splash of Rockabilly (though this would be fully realised later). Morrissey was working with new songwriting partners in ex-Fairground Attraction's axe man and musician Mark E. Nevin and Madness producer and "Kill Uncle's" producer Clive Langer. So quite why this album has been derided through the years is a mystery to me. Yes there are some fey tracks (King Leer, The Harsh Truth...) and yes it's a little on the short side (Original release is 33:06, this version is 37:56). But the album is brimming full of hidden gems and has Moz in overall, buoyent mood and singing very well. It also has a handful of underrated Moz gems (Driving Your Girlfriend Home, Asian Rut, Found Found Found and Sing Your Life, which curiously, even though it was a single, has never featured on any Moz compilation except the US only realease "Best of"). While after the album's release the backing band of "Rockabilly" players, Boz Boorer, Alain Whyte, Gary Day and Spencer Cobrin gave some of the light tracks added weight and a live zest, for the most part this album has been shunned. Crucially also by Moz at live dates rarely plays anything from the album.

Jump forward to now and from the previous paragraph you are asking, why only 3 stars then? The reason is simple, the album was never a 5 star classic to begin with and like all the rest of his re-releases ("Southpaw Grammar", "Maladjusted", "Bona Drag" and "Viva Hate") this album has been tampered with. The track listing has been re-jigged, which we can live with, but extra tracks have been added to the album, and as with the previous releases, not added to the end as bonus tracks (Only "Bona Drag" did this) but they have been placed in the running order of the album. The grating thing about this is, like the other releases ("Southpaw Grammar", "Bona Drag") the songs that have been added don't even come from the same sessions and feature different players. The first extra song, 'Pashernate Love' was recorded months later with the "Your Arsenal" band and was written by Morrissey/Whyte/Day and was the B-side to the 2nd single from "Your Arsenal", 'You're The One For Me, Fatty' (In the US it was the B-side to "Tomorrow"). Quite why it finds it's way onto this album and crash landed right into the middle after a re-jigged 'Asian Rut' is a mystery only Moz can answer? Again, even more puzzling the second extra song (a cover of Herman's Hermits) "East West" pre-dates the album and was recorded in 1989 as the B-side for the "Ouija Board, Ouija Board" single (These sessions were from the aborted "Bona Drag" album before it was made into a celebratory singles/b-sides compilation album). And features on the recording Kevin Armstrong, Matthew Seligman and Andrew Paresi, who was the only one to actually feature on "Kill Uncle". The other extra track, isn't really an extra track at all but a live version recorded for radio of "There Is A Place In Hell For Me And My Friends" which is a faithful facsimilie of how the track was played at live dates, misses the beauty and poignancy of the Mark Nevin piano demo on the original album, which closed the album on a very beautiful note. Other than that the re-mastering work has been fine, though not as good as the standard of the previously released "Viva Hate". Though another sticking point is that the songs now all run into one another which the didn't on the original version. The cover art has been changed, and while i actually like the new cover and enjoy the 1960's Parlophone records look of it. The original "Kill Uncle" album had my favourite of all of Morrissey's solo album covers. And i really loved the look Moz had on that original cover.

As i've said, like the previous re-releases this album has been butchered, out of all recognition of the original albums. I can see why Moz would feel the need to put something new on there to urge Moz fans and owners of the original album to part their cash again. But he could have not added them onto the end of the re-mastered album? And why the extra track choices? Like "Southpaw Grammar" that had tracks from "Your Arsenal" sessions and "Bona Drag" with tracks from the "Viva Hate" sessions and "Your Arsenal" sessions, these tracks don't belong here! Why not put as bonus tracks songs that were recorded during the sessions? Or B-sides of the albums singles? Such as the excellent "The Loop" which was the B-side to "Sing Your Life" is a fans favourite and obviously a Morrissey favourite as he still plays it Live in his setlists? Or even the sublime "Pregnant For The Last Time" single, which while technically was recorded at different sessions, employs the feel and sound template of some of the tracks and the Live concerts of the tour afterwards. Hell, even "Tony The Pony" which was the B-side to "Our Frank", while not a great song, was on the original US release and makes more sense here than "Pashernate Love" or "East West". The most irritating thing about all this is that from what is believed the original versions will be deleted from the catalogue and be replaced by only these ones. Which is a mockery and a total re-writing of history by Morrissey. While this album wasn't perfect, it was a very enjoyable Morrissey album and taken in the context of it's recording and the point where Morrissey was at during his early solo career it is important historically as well as musically. While Morrissey may not be completely happy with some of his original back catalogue and wants to, in his mind, make the albums better. He is tampering with his legacy and the fondness with which fans have for his original work. While most of us long term Morrissey fans will all have the original and can listen to it anytime. For those who are coming to Morrissey afresh, i feel it's a shame that they will think this is the album that was released and recorded (As nowhere in the sleeve notes, does it describe, where the tracks have come from, when they were recorded and by whom, It also removes the lyric sheet from the original). And will most have to hunt around to find a second hand copy of the original, while flawed, still the best. And better than this.

Sing your life Morrissey, don't re-write it like this sham.
0Comment| 20 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 2 May 2017
OK, maybe not one of morrissey best albums... But still an interesting and important stepping stone to better ones... (I'm) The End of the family line is always very touching.
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
If you are into Morrissey then you don't need a reviewer to tell you to buy this. All I would say, however, is that it's a bargain at this price - a Morrissey album, for a fiver, what's not to like?
0Comment| One person found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 24 June 2017
quick delivery, another Morrissey cd to add to my collection :)
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 11 June 2017
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 5 August 2014
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 29 June 2011
kill uncle is the album i most revisit...Morrissey at his saddest, mournful, self aware and introspective- it may not be the smiths, but its theatrical sound is bizarrely underrated.

My favourite ones would be-
asian rut- camp and theatrical telling of a bullied asian boy who turns up for revenge
king leer- morrissey's suggestion that 'tizer' might not be the best choice to woo a girlll
driving your girlfriend home- noone would write a song like this, its so resigned to loneliness its painful how he accepts it
harsh truth of the camera eye- one of my favourites just for the line- 'Churchillian legs, hair barely there...'

Ignore the haters they havent gorra clue. Its morrissey when he enjoyed subtlety rather than power chords and chest beating.
0Comment| 13 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 1 May 2015
Well for some reason this album gets a bad press, I think probably because it wasn't commercially that successful and perhaps because Morrissey hasn't really bigged it up since.

The truth is that there's some very good songs on this album and they're lively, fast, not too long and pleasant to listen too. Particularly the singles Our Frank and Sing your life would make it to most "best of morrissey' playlists. I also have a lot of time for King Leer, which I admit might not be to everyone's tastes, but has some great lines in it.

I think the re-ordering of the tracks and the additional tracks added or original song versions change actually take away from the album. Having arguably the best 2 songs start the album makes it too top heavy. The should be separated. Pashernate love seems out of place (unsurprisingly because it's from a different session and Morrissey's vocals are in a different style - more direct and powerful). The recorded live for radio version of There's a place in hell... is not only misplaced (as it's a live version in the middle of a recorded album), but it's also a much inferior version of the song than the original piano version. So why anybody would pick the live version over the original when it's worse and won't sound right is pretty baffling.

The only inclusion that does work reasonably well is East West cover. This was done in the Bona Drag sessions and I think that the songs like Lucky Lisp, Interesting Drug, and Picadilly Palare are most similar to Kill Uncle. I think cherry picking the best of (the new songs recorded for) the Bona Dray sessions and King Leer sessions would probably result in Morrissey's best album. I guess it was never to happen though given the different players.

So while the changes to the album don't work you're only really missing the original There's a place in hell... to have the full album and the bonus tracks you can remove as you wish. I would also resequence the album as well. Not a 5 star classic and not great changes but you have the kill uncle album there if you trim the fat and that's a very good 4 star album. I'd give the repackaging 2 starts.

P.S. I've noticed (at the time of this review) if you buy the Original 10-track CD album version on Amazon for £5.99 you get the remastered version as a download, so you can get both versions and decide for yourself which you like! (It's cheaper than getting the digital album on it's own too!).

Link: http://www.amazon.co.uk/Kill-Uncle-Morrissey/dp/B000024KBK/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1430487259&sr=8-1&keywords=kill+uncle
11 Comment| 2 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 8 April 2013
I got hold of this on the day of release and have been listening in the car. Much has been said of this album since its orignal release, so I won't add to that too much. This album was much criticised upon its original release over 20 years ago. Following his triumphant debut solo, Viva Hate and the amazing compilation, Bona Drag this must have seemed somewhat disappointing; running at just over half an hour and taking on board Fairground Attraction's Mark Nevin as co-writer and guitarist. It's also the only album in his canon to use Madness producers Langer/Winstanley. (Even Bedders & Woody are in Moz's band for this one). When I first heard the original in the early '90s I instantly loved it. I couldn't see what everyone was moaning about. A particular favourite of mine was "Sing Your Life" which is still high on my list of favourite songs of all time. I've seen Mozzer live many times and have still yet to year him play it in concert which is a shame. Anyway, on to the reissue... Over last few years he's been gradually reissuing and remastering his solo albums. First we had Southpaw Grammar and Maladjusted. Then came Viva Hate and Bona Drag. Each reissue has rejigged the artwork AND the track listing. Some have even removed original tracks altogether. And some have altered songs, replacing them with shorter or longer versions. This reissue maintains the tradition. He's kept all of the original tracks (although replaced There's a Place in Hell... with a live alternative). And he's added two (Pashernate Love and East West). Unusually the two Mark Nevin collaboration singles released during this period haven't been added (My Love Life and Pregnant for the Last Time). I do enjoy the way Morrissey reissues his old albums, he always throws up the odd surprise! However, with this one I am slightly disappointed. The track list is fine, the new artwork is fine (although I prefer the original image) ... the only thing that annoys me slightly is that there is no booklet. I was hoping for some rare photos, sleeve notes and even the lyrics but we have nowt. So I'll listen to this but look at the original packaging from the early '90s. Looking forward to Your Arsenal... Mx
0Comment| 3 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 3 March 2007
after reading plenty of negative reviews about Kill Uncle, i was a little reluctant to buy it.. but i'm very glad i did.

i recognise that this is down to personal preference but i love the whole atmosphere and production of this morrissey album in particular. The lyrics are sometimes unusual, which again whether you like or not is your preference.

Our Frank sets the mood. Mute Witness is a highlight with the great lyric 'your mute witness... oh well she's only trying to tell you what it was that she saw.' The End Of The Family Line and There is a Place.. wouldn't be too far out of place in later Smiths work, and provide a strong end to the album.

In my opinion Kill Uncle offers extremely underrated Morrissey songs but it's.. different.. style does NOT appeal to everyone.
0Comment| 10 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse

Customers also viewed these items

Need customer service? Click here

Sponsored Links

  (What is this?)