Learn more Shop now Learn more Shop now Shop now Shop now Shop now Learn More Shop now Shop now Learn more Shop Fire Shop Kindle Amazon Music Unlimited for Family Shop now Fitbit

Customer reviews

4.6 out of 5 stars
38
4.6 out of 5 stars
Format: DVD|Change
Price:£24.99+ Free shipping with Amazon Prime


There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.

on 15 April 2017
Two great films on blu ray not to be missed. Seeing Gladiator in HD form is something else, must say. Thats one title not to be missed, if you happened to have a big enough HD screen and are into your HD movie viewing and sound system experience. This and Braveheart as well within that regard. Far out totally.
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 17 February 2017
A nice double bill. I don't think the blu ray version holds much more gravitas than dvd to be honest....
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 15 March 2011
Firstly I will review the Robin Hood film which I found to be a good all round film with plenty of entertainment and yes a few Hollywood add-ons. For the history buffs the film actually feels like the period it is supposed to portray, as opposed to most "men in tights "Robin Hood films. The cloths, locations, scenery and set layouts all look like you are in the correct period. Also there is no real evidence that Robin Hood actually existing only in wandering minstrel tales where the legend emanated from. As with most legends this was undoubtedly built on over the years and represents the moral of good triumphing over evil. Ok the lost boys bit was a bit OTT as was the French ships with Normandy style landing craft, but this did not spoil my enjoyment as I just went with the flow.
Star of the Film Cate Blanchett without doubt, although Russell Crowe gives an impressive performance. The accents are incidental, due the fact if the film was made with authentic accents of the period (apart from not knowing how accurate they would be) most people would not be able to understand them.
As for Gladiator this new re-mastered version corrects all the previous faults with the original blu-ray version and just raises the films Kudos even higher. There is little point reiterating all the plaudits for this film just buy it and enjoy watching it again and again especially when Sunday afternoon TV is so boring as it usually is.
All in all this box set is well worth the money buy it and you will not be disappointed. Remember first and foremost these are entertainment movies not lessons in history.
0Comment| 13 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 1 January 2011
both of these films are the directors cut and both are fantastic, especially Gladiator which is the 2010 re-release of the blu-ray and rectifies all of the mistakes in the transfer of the 2009 version.
0Comment| 23 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
It may have revived the big screen epic - and particularly the Roman epic, which had laid dormant since the disastrous failure of 1964's The Fall of the Roman Empire, which this film often copies to less effect - but Gladiator was never really in the top rank of big screen epics.

The script problems that plagued the production are also apparent in a lack of focus that is always a problem when people start building the sets before they have scenes to play in them. There's so much attention to detail in creating the world of the Roman Empire that the supporting characters sometimes get leftovers in this theatrical cut (the extended version corrects that to some degree). Even Russell Crowe's personal journey seems at times poorly developed, reducing the film from a story that affects an empire to a simple revenge story, and a somewhat disappointing one at that. The climactic fight with Commodus is still a major disappointment not just because it's so underwhelmingly staged but because, unlike The Fall of the Roman Empire, the film it relentlessly plagiarises, Commodus is never a credible threat: where Anthony Mann gave him foolhardy courage, Ridley Scott has implied he's a coward throughout until even a wounded hero can't even the odds.

That said, the dialogue never descends to the banalities of 1492: Conquest of Paradise, although the visuals never reach its heights (indeed, John Mathieson's frequently muted photography is often less than impressive). Some of the less vaunted CGI shots are not all that they could be either - the tiger was fine, but the flames in one shot in the battle scene weren't moving in synch with the panning shot while the CGI of the procession into Rome looked less than convincing.

Caveats aside, it's certainly enjoyable (Marcus Aurelius' death scene aside, an ineffectual lift from Blade Runner), and both the character and the film's attitude to death - a reward, reuniting him with his family in Elysium - makes it almost unique in the genre. Despite a handful of strong scenes, it's not great, never reaching the highs of The Fall of the Roman Empire or even its own opening battle sequence (too many of the arena scenes are so over-edited they feel like they've been hacked at with a gladius at times), but it is good and the two-disc DVD set boasts a very impressive array of extras - audio commentary by Ridley Scott, John Mathieson and Pietro Scalia, 11 deleted scenes and montage of deleted footage, featurettes on the making of the film and the history of gladiatorial combat, storyboard comparisons and conceptual art, TV spots and trailers and even an Easter egg of CGI test footage for a deleted rhino fight.

However, the Blu-ray includes both the original theatrical version and the extended , complete with all the extras from both DVD sets (deleted scenes, comprehensive documentary, featurettes, trailers, etc) but more importantly doesn't feel as disjointed or quite so disappointing as the theatrical version. It's not just that it has more room to breathe, more that the additional footage, particularly the scenes away from Maximus where the future of Rome takes center-stage, raise the stakes beyond the simplistic revenge tale the theatrical version all too often settled for. It's still no Fall of the Roman Empire, but it is a more satisfying film than the one released in cinemas. While the first standalone pressing was so poor it had to be recalled and remastered, the problems have been thankfully addressed on subsequent copies, including this double-bill set with Robin Hood.

Despite a convoluted and tortuous pre-production history and the participation of two of the more oafish bigheads in the business, Ridley and Russell's Robin Hood is a surprisingly impressive and enjoyable medieval epic that manages to find a new string for the old longbow by placing a prequel to the Hooded Man's outlaw days in a relatively accurately drawn Middle Ages with some contemporary relevance. Admittedly it's going to mean a lot more to British and European audiences, but it's hard not to notice that in its unloving royal siblings Richard (a gruff and bluff Danny Huston) and John (an impressive Oscar Isaac) there's more than a little Tony Blair - vain, bankrupting his abandoned country in unnecessary foreign wars and delusionally regarding himself as a pretty straight kind of guy yet quick to punish anyone who tells him the truth - and Gordon Brown - a petty and spiteful ruler who briefly wins over his people with promises he promptly drops as soon as his throne is secure and is woefully inadequate at turning the economy around. The film even uses the infamous political kiss-of-death phrase 'resigning to spend more time with his family' when honest chancellor William Marshall (William Hurt, looking surprisingly like the director) finds himself out of a job.

There are more nods to James Goldman than Errol Flynn here: Eleanor of Aquitaine gets a few bits of Lion in Winterish sniping without the barbed wit (though John's retort "Spare me your farmyard memories, mother: they're not real and I don't understand them" comes close) while the film begins, like Robin and Marion, with Robin and Little John in the King's bad books for being a bit too honest as the Lionheart loots his way back from the Crusades. There's an even stronger element of Martin Guerre to the tale as well as it finds a plausible explanation for Robin's twin origins as the peasant Robin Longstrides and the dispossessed noble Robin of Locksley, doing a neat job of tying in the origins of the Magna Carta and civil disobedience to the legend in the process.

There's plenty of action too, ending with not one but two big battles, though the grand finale is a bit too Saving Private Robin at times and Cate Blanchet's presence leading a small band of feral children in the climax seems a clumsy contrivance to put her in jeopardy merely so she can be rescued (she's far more convincingly placed heroically centre stage in a raid on her village). Throughout, the money's on the screen, with little apparent CGI - the sets, while not extravagant, have weight to them - and if it could use a few more extreme long shots at times, it makes good use of the British landscape for once. Thankfully Scott doesn't overdo the stylistics or the MTV editing here, settling for good old-fashioned storytelling and even throwing in that long-absent favorite, the burning map montage sequence. As for Crowe, while his accent briefly makes a detour to Newcastle before settling in Barnsley for an initially ill-advised Michael Parkinson impersonation (so much so you almost expect him to say "So, Richard - this Crusades business. Bit of a lark or is there a more serious side to it?"), but luckily he grows in stature alongside the character. And satisfyingly, this film is a real journey, not just from France to England but from opportunist to idealist to legend as Robin's progress mirrors that of the character's evolution from the thug of the early ballads to the champion of the oppressed of modern lore.

While it isn't as good or as ambitious as Kingdom of Heaven, this Robin Hood is still surprisingly damn good entertainment. Unfortunately Universal have decided to treat DVD buyers as second-class citizens again in an attempt to get them to upgrade to BluRay, giving them only the extended (by 16 minutes) cut, which gives more time to the feral children and adds a brief action scene and a comic scene between Robin and Marion but offers no major structural changes as per the Kingdom of Heaven director's cut, and leaving the original theatrical version and the choice extras for the BluRay. Just to rub salt in the wounds, aside from the picture-in-picture featurettes on the theatrical version, the extras disc on the BD release is actually a DVD disc, meaning they could have easily included the 10 deleted scenes with introduction by editor Pietro Scalia, one-hour documentary Rise and Rise Again, 6 TV spots, teaser trailer and full theatrical trailer on a two-disc release. The BD also has a picture-in-picture series of featurettes and interviews running sporadically throughout the theatrical version of the movie.
0Comment| One person found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 28 December 2010
Both these films were outstanding to watch, the picture quality was crisp and clear and the sound was loud as hell, at one point of Robin Hood i thought my speaker was going to blow, i had a picture on my sub woofer and the sound went that loud it fell off! Dont expect Robin Hood to be the same as the Kevin Costner version as they are completly different, but at the end it leaves it so it is ready for a sequel and the start of the robbing from the rich giving to the poor.
Gladiator was another great movie in this boxset. It is not like the other version which was not very good on the picture, it has been redone. Russell crowe is a great actor and plays the part of Robin Hood very well.
0Comment| 6 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 7 August 2012
Got this for my birthday, being a fan of Russell Crowe and Gladiator, but not having seen Robin Hood before.

Both come with the Theatrical and Extended versions of the film on one disc and there is a special menu which allows you to select which one you want to watch before you get to the "main" menu, which is a nice touch.

I did find that the initial menus seem to take a while to load up, particularly on Robin Hood, but some of that is the usual BD-Live gubbins which you can probably turn off on your player if it annoys.
Interesting that Ridley Scott makes a point of coming on and telling you that the extended edition of Gladiator is NOT the director's cut... No axe to grind there then!

There is the usual set of extras on a second disc for each movie, although I don't tend to get round to watching all that stuff (but nice to know it is there).

The movies themselves:
Gladiator is awesome as always. Transfer to Blu-ray is excellent to my untrained eye and is a definite improvement in picture and sound over the DVD.

Robin Hood is a fun little movie, with a very different take on the old legend. It's fun trying to pick out all the well known characters and work out who's who.

There seem to be some odd choices made in this film with certain characters and situations where you almost expect a twist which never materialises, or it's not clear why certain characters are motivated to do what they do, or times where the film can't make up its mind if it's meant to be funny or serious.

It seemed to take a little while to get going, but there was enough mystery, etc to reel us in and make us want to keep watching.

Without giving too much away, it's almost a "prequel" and I wonder if Ridley Scott's original intention was to make some follow ups to it...?

Don't expect too much of it (perhaps think of it as "Gladiator lite"?) and I think most people will enjoy it too.

To put it bluntly, Robin Hood is just not in the same league as Gladiator, but it's still a nice film to have in your collection IMO + it's nice to get two blu-rays for the price of one.
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 25 January 2014
This review is just about the Bluray quality.

I'm very pleased with both films, in terms of picture and sound quality. They look great on my 50" plasma and surround sound.
0Comment| One person found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 25 January 2012
Great quality pictures and has extended versions too.
Other than English, you have the audio of both films in French, Italian, German and Spanish.
0Comment| One person found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 23 July 2014
Gladiator.....the word classic is banded about a lot these days, but this movie certainly fits the bill, Ridley scott is now right up there with the very best of Hollywood, and Russell Crowe gives a towering performance, albeit a slight Austrailian accent seeping through in the dialogue......Robin Hood, pleasantly surprised, mainly because its not just another rehash of the robin hood legend, but a reimagining, and a good one, though it is not going to be a classic, very enjoyable and at a great price!!
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse

Sponsored Links

  (What is this?)