Learn more Shop now Learn more Shop now Shop now Shop now Shop now Learn More Shop now Shop now Learn more Shop Fire Shop Kindle Learn More Shop now Fitbit

Customer reviews

4.8 out of 5 stars
4.8 out of 5 stars
5 star
4 star
3 star
2 star
1 star
Format: Audio CD|Change
Price:£7.54+ Free shipping with Amazon Prime

There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.

HALL OF FAMEon 7 February 2007
This CD is a grab bag, but a very special one. It contains five choral works, garnered from fairly recent recordings on the Koch and MusicMasters labels, sung and played by exceedingly sensitive musicians and led by surely the best Stravinsky conductor we have, Robert Craft. These are among the best recordings I've ever heard of these works.

Probably the most important, and certainly the best known, work here is placed last: the Symphony of Psalms, with the Simon Joly Chorale and the Philharmonia Orchestra. This performance very much emphasizes that the work is for chorus with orchestra, not an orchestral work with incidental chorus, and it is generally gentler than most performances one hears. The Simon Joly Chorale is simply sensational here, with subtle inflections and dynamics, clear diction and impeccable intonation. Craft wisely lets the music unfold without any special rhetorical flourishes and in this respect it resembles Stravinsky's own classic recording. The very slow opening ('Alleluia. Laudate.') of the final movement, Psalm 150, is ecstatic, making the irruption of the agitato section all the more effective. This is a superior Symphony of Psalms.

The disc opens with a cappella works, Three Russian Sacred Choruses, sung in Slavonic versions of the Pater Noster, Ave Maria and Credo. Texts with translations for these and the other works here are not in the Naxos booklet but can be found at [...] . Craft conducts them slightly faster than Stravinsky does in his classic recording but they actually gain from that. The Gregg Smith Singers are the chorus.

Mass (1944-48) was written in New York but there is absolutely no new world influence in the work, unlike other things he was writing at the time. It is sung by The Gregg Smith Singers, the group who also recorded the work in 1960 and who have sung it innumerable times since. This is glorious performance that I prefer by a slight margin to Stravinsky's own version, not only because it is in much better sound but also because the choral soloists are better. They are given superb support by members of the Orchestra of St. Luke's. The orchestration is especially inventive, consisting as it does of two quintets, one of oboes and bassoons and one of trumpets and trombones.

Cantata (1951-52) is based on early English verses including the Elizabethan bridal song, 'The Maidens Came' and the traditional 'Tomorrow Shall Be My Dancing Day.' Written hard on the heels of Stravinsky finishing 'The Rake's Progress', the solos were written for two of the singers in that opera's premiere, Hugues Cuénod and Jennie Tourel. The musical forces, in addition to the tenor and mezzo soloists, are a female chorus (from The Gregg Smith Singers) and an instrumental quintet of two flutes, two oboes and cello. The excellent vocal soloists are Mary Ann Hart and Thomas Bogdan. The redoubtable Fred Sherry is the cellist.

Finally, there is the brief 'Babel' that recounts the Genesis story of the building and destruction of the Tower of Babel. The piece was originally part of a suite of works by several composers (including Schoenberg) that retold Genesis texts. The work has a narrator who reads from Genesis, Chapter 11, verses 11-19, with one chorus sung (by the Simon Joly Chorale) to 'Behold the people is one, and they all have one language.' The orchestra, quite prominent in the work, is the Philharmonia at the top of their form. I had not listened to my old recording of Stravinsky conducting the work in many years, but on comparison with it I find that narrator David Wilson-Johnson is much superior to John Calicos on the old recording, largely because he is less overtly, how shall I say, hammy.

This issue is impeccably presented and recorded. I would urge Stravinsky fans, even those who have earlier recordings, including those of the composer himself, to grab it.

Scott Morrison
0Comment| 18 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 8 July 2010
You really can't fault Craft's performances here, or the orchestra. The performances are superior to those made by Stravinsky himself but that is not to say that they are definitive or the best available.

The selection is a mixed bag, but none the worse for that. The Russian Choruses are slight but enjoyable nonetheless. Babel is a curiosity being Stravinsky's contribution to a larger work, Genesis, including work by a range of disparate composers. The subject itself illustrates the weakness of the project - disparate voices unable to build a coherent work. The story of God scattering the peoples across the globe with numerous unintellible languages because, as a team they were proving far too successful, is hardly the best moral tale either. Still it's an interesting curiosity to have in your collection.

The beautiful and refined "Mass" is very well performed but I preferred Bernstein's with the Bath Festival Choir on DG. The setting for male voices and wind instruments represents one of Stravinsky's most polished later neo classical works.

The Cantata is an extremely underrated work and receives a marvellous performance. Set for two soloists, small choir an dchamber ensemble it followed The Rake's Progress but is one of his first works to include elements of a tone row. It still retains his mainly neo classical voice with an english text. His music also relfects the antiquity of the text. There is a fly in the ointment here though, because Thomas Bogdan's voice in the central Lyke Wake Dirge is thin, breathless and reedy. This work cries out for a strong, clear ringing tenor - his voice is too weak to carry the weighiest part of the work.

The Symphony of Psalms is the most well known work on the disc and gets an all round excellent performance. So, whilst his recording isn't perfect, it is still a steal at this price and Robert Craft doesn't put a foot wrong throughout.
22 Comments| 5 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 2 June 2008
This is a well put together CD that leads you through the sacred works of Stravinsky. The recording are fabulous and the sleave notes are interesting and well written.

If you are interested in Stravinsky, (I personally was interested after studying his music for A level music) then this CD will give you a great introduction to his works.
0Comment| 5 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 10 August 2016
Excellent introduction to Stravinsny's choral works directed by a Stravinsny expert
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 18 February 2016
Wonderful music, nice recording
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse

Need customer service? Click here