Learn more Shop now Shop now Shop now Shop now Shop now Shop now Shop now Learn More Shop now Shop now Learn more Shop Fire Shop Kindle Martine McCutcheon Shop now Fitbit

Customer reviews

4.1 out of 5 stars
4.1 out of 5 stars
Format: DVD|Change
Price:£2.97+ Free shipping with Amazon Prime

There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.

on 2 April 2017
Everyone by now should have heard of the story of king kong so I won't go into detail about that. Peter Jackson delivers a cgi masterpiece, as all the creatures and effects are better than most films nowadays. Parts of this do suffer such as how long it takes to get to the island, and how two side characters (hayes and jimmy) are more developed than jack and anne (the main characters). The extended scenes offer more creature destruction and carnage. Overall if you're a fan of king kong this is a must see old classic brought splendidly to the 21st century.
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
NB: As is Amazon's wont, they've unhelpfully lumped all the reviews for various different editions of this title together - the two-disc DVD theatrical cut, the three-disc extended director's cut and both Bluray releases.

Viewed on the small screen, the theatrical cut of Peter Jackson's epic labor of love is a bit more of a problematic experience than it was on the big screen, being at once a mixture of the best and worst of Peter Jackson. His love of and sheer joy in film-making is manifestly obvious right from the delirious opening montage of Depression era New York that gives the background detail a modern audience wouldn't bring into the theatre with them as they did in 1933 with a wonderful visual economy so much of the rest of the film lacks. Unfortunately he then spends a couple of reels detailing the death of Vaudeville and Carl Denham's problems with studio execs. And then a couple of reels on getting under way. And then far too many reels sailing to Skull Island - when Denham promised Ann a long ocean voyage, he wasn't kidding. It's not so much that they're bad scenes (though some are quite weak), more that there's no reason for all of them to be there. Most could have easily been thrown over the side with the rest of the ship's fittings, but instead they tend to bury the more portentous moments under trivia. Indeed, it's interesting to note that a draft of Jackson's aborted attempt to film it in 1998 included none of this section whatever, kicking off with the Venture piercing the fog in search of Skull Island.

But once it literally crashes into Skull Island, the film really takes off - the natives this time really are savage, almost Neolithic, the action scenes well-handled and the pace relentless. Jackson even manages to top several sequences from the original - the Bride of Kong sacrifice, Kong escaping from the Broadway theatre, the Empire State Building finale, here a breathtakingly dizzying piece of filmmaking - as well as throwing in some good additions of his own, such as a truly charming scene on the ice in Central Park or a couple of convincing storm sequences on the perilous shores of Skull Island. There are plenty of fun injokes that don't seem awkwardly forced on the picture either - Denham tries to get Fay Wray for the lead in his picture, but she's making a film for Merian C. Cooper at RKO; the scene they shoot on the boat is one from the 1933 film; Rick Baker, the man inside the suit in 1976, is one of the pilots gunning down Kong; and the interpolation of much of Max Steiner's score offers some nice musical nods even if the "Walla Walla Kong Kong!" lyrics are omitted.

There's more that's good than bad about the film by a long way, but the bad is bad enough to keep this from becoming an all-time classic in its own right

There's some striking miscasting. Much as he looks like Orson Welles in certain shots, Jack Black really isn't up to Carl Denham, a part Oliver Platt or Vincent D'Onfrio could have done in their sleep: too often he looks like he's telling a joke that's fallen flat rather than delivering dramatic dialog, and there's that air of trying too hard that follows him around like a bad smell. Naomi Watts is surprisingly anodyne and not terribly flatteringly photographed (to put it mildly), reminding me why, despite some good work in the past, she often remains so resolutely unmemorable an actress. Kyle Chandler hams it up fairly charmlessly as her nominal leading man, telegraphing the jokes to such a degree that they're more irritating distractions than genuine comic relief. Adrien Brody's unlikely hero fares better despite having nothing much to do in the last act, while the smaller roles fare better, with Thomas Kretschmann's Engelhorn, Evan Parke's Hayes and Jamie Bell's cabin boy all making their mark before being unceremoniously discarded.

But the acting honors easily belong to Andy Serkis' Kong, a triumph not just of CGI (and far more convincing than he appeared in the trailers) but also performance. It's not merely that this Kong is more facially expressive - he's caught the body language perfectly, convincing us that it's a great ape rather than a human being dictating the moves. It makes the same mistake as the 1976 version in having Ann feel empathy with Kong which, while better executed here, lessens the tragedy of Kong - the fact his devotion was unrequited was one of the things that made his last stand so much more touching and pitiful.

Elsewhere, the effects are variable and too often Jackson throws in an FX shot just because he likes the idea - not so much a problem with the beasties but definitely tiresome when we get to yet another CGI shot of the ship at sea. Nor are all of the effects quite state of the art. The problem is the old one with CGI - poor integration of the live action and computer generated footage, both of which all too often seem to be shot at visibly different resolutions (particularly noticeable in the stampede sequence). Yet compared to the two previous remakes, Jackson's genuine love of the material still carries the day and certainly delivers the best of 2005's blockbusters.

Although being too short certainly wasn't one of the problems with the theatrical cut,, surprisingly the extended director's cut really does seem much of an improvement over the theatrical version. The new action scenes - a triceratops attack and an excellent lake sequence with a prehistoric giant fish taking the place of the original's brontosaurus - are superb and the film seems to flow better: even Jack Black's miscasting doesn't seem quite such an obstacle as it did in the previous version. One thing that does become much more apparent is what is missing from the first hour: Kong. Where in the previous versions the shadow and mystery of Kong hung over the voyage from the very beginning, here Kong is not even on the radar until moments before they arrive at the Island. It divorces this section from the film itself, feeling at times more like a 30s programmer or even the padded-out quickly run off sequel to the original, Son of Kong, that spent more time bumming around the Indies than it did on Skull Island. But once it finally reaches its destination it takes off and rarely lets go, with Jackson's love for the original evident in almost every frame. The original Kong is still King, but it's not hard to imagine Merian C. Cooper and Ernest B. Schoedsack heartily approving of this remake. Good extras, too.

The theatrical cut and Director's cut are available separately on DVD with plentiful extras unique to each edition, while the Blu-ray release brings both cuts together, but sadly loses nearly all the extras - you just get an audio commentary by Jackson and co-writer Phillippa Boyens, art galleries and picture-in-picture cast and crew interviews. The original Bluray release contained both cuts but dropped almost all of the extras, though the 2017 special edition release tying in with Skull Island added a second disc with all the extras from the various releases.
0Comment| 2 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 30 March 2017
Reasonably solid watch - though after you watch it one time you don't really want to sample even the bonus content. It actually looks very dated now which kind of surprised me when you consider films that were made at the same time.
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 30 April 2017
quite possibly the best ever creature feature. why do they always have to kill king kong? i'd have one as a pet.
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 15 August 2017
Not bad but the DVD could be better a lot of scratches on it but I can't complain it play OK
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 23 April 2017
Thoroughly enjoyed this up to date extended edition bluray movie.
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 12 August 2017
Peter Jackson made a good film BETTER .if you are a fan of his hobbit and Lord of the rings you will enjoy this film.
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 3 June 2017
Great DVD, ready to watch as soon as I have the time.
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 3 March 2017
great extras and good film
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 11 May 2017
Really great film
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse

Need customer service? Click here