Top critical review
2 people found this helpful
Ebay prices are consistently lower than values in this guide.
on 24 January 2015
Does not appear to reflect the market changes that have ebay has caused. I contacted the author and they do not appear to have any intention of using ebay market prices as a source of information, but intend to simply stick with dealer prices based on catalogues and trade shows.
My understanding is that the reason for this is that it is believed cheap ebay prices reflect much lower quality items, however I have found that not to be true and that the majority of ebay sellers offer good quality on the basis that they want repeat custom and that ebay has a feedback system. In addition to this, most of the ebay sellers are dealers on the non-ebay secondary market too.
Therefore in my opinion, the basis for not pursuing to incorporate ebay as a source of market data is ill-informed and reduces the value of the guide.
Other than that, the publication is good in every other way.