Learn more Download now Shop now Browse your favorite restaurants Shop now Shop now Shop now Shop now Shop now Learn More Shop now Learn more Shop Fire Shop Kindle Learn More Shop now Shop now Learn more

Customer reviews

4.5 out of 5 stars
Napoleonic Uniforms: v. 1 & 2
Format: Hardcover|Change
Price:£150.00+ Free shipping with Amazon Prime

on 2 March 2018
very good
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you? Report abuse
on 2 May 2014
Colonel Elting's books on the Napoleonic era are of the highest order. Whether it is "Napoleonic Uniforms", "Swords around a throne", or "The Atlas of the Napoleonic wars", they greatly enhance one's understanding of the exploits of Napoleon and the French.

This specific set makes one understand how the various soldiers described in texts looked like. The accompanying description below each drawing is also very helpful.
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you? Report abuse
on 25 October 2007
Beautifully produced these 2 books covers the French alone and not the opponents (as an earlier reviewer seems to think). These are the sort of books that should last generations.

I am eager for them to bring out books 3 and 4 in the same manner.
0Comment| 2 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you? Report abuse
on 12 March 2013
Bardzo dobra książka o umundurowaniu wojsk w dobie wojen napoleońskich z licznymi rysunkami przedstawiającymi umundrowanie wszystkich formacji wojsk napoleońskich .
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you? Report abuse
on 19 September 2013
For a full description, see [...] As you can see from the number of plates (Volume I: 426 pages and 459 color plates; Volume II: 423 pages and 458 color plates.), very little text looks to be included.

Now that I have the books in hand, I have the Greenhill 2007 version. I do not know that much about cloth, but my cover appears to be normal. The case also appears to be normal thick stock, not flimsy thin cardboard. The box is what is shown in the picture with the sticker; the books have a painting plate and gold lettering on the front and gold lettering on the spine. The pages are heavy glossy stock.

There are 14 sections in vol I, each with about half a page introduction explaining what these units were. The illustrations can be seen at the site given above. They are not all of the same quality. Some are fairly sharp, others are more impressionistic. I did not see more than 2 illustrations per page. The descriptions run about 5-15 lines each. They do not give a comprehensive description but do give comments on how these uniforms differ either from other units or for different ranks. This includes the correct technical terminology in French and English some of the time. Other times it is just general terminology like a 'short jacket' or 'high-waisted troussers'. The index is less than two pages and covers the types of soldiers, i.e. officers, grenadiers, etc, not the uniform elements or key words in the descriptions.

So if you are looking to create artwork (figurines, paintings) with proper uniforms, this book is fantastic for the variety it gives. If you are looking for the correct terminology, it probably is in the books, but finding it might be a real bugbear. You would need to go through and write your own glossary based on the entries.
0Comment| One person found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you? Report abuse
on 17 April 2015
There are a plethora of uniform collections throughout the world, both public and private. Many are highly reliable, some of these not the most artistic in nature, but cold, hard, and accurate representations of the men, and women, who have fought wars down through the ages. Not the least of these collections are those which depict the fighting men of many nations who followed the rolling drums and thundering guns through twenty-five years of unimaginable hardship, horror, and bloodshed that was the French Revolutionary and Napoleonic Wars.

The Otto Manuscript, the Luneberg Manuscript, the Manuscripts of the Bourgeois of Hamburg, the Rivotti and Freiberg Manuscripts, were followed by the works of later researchers and artists as displayed in the Martinet Prints, the Vernet collection, the famous Bucquoy cards, the works of Lucien Rousselot and Eugene Leliepvre. These artists have brought these soldiers to life for the generations who have studied those who marched and fought across the length and breadth of Europe, the West Indies, Russia, and the Middle East from 1792 to 1815. Not the least of these collections is the work of Herbert Knötel (son of Richard Knötel, the noted uniform authority), an acknowledged authority on uniforms in his own right. Herbert Knötel was an expert on the way armies looked both in the field and on the parade ground.

The work of Herbert Knötel on the Grande Armée and its allies and enemies has now been presented to us in four magnificent volumes; assembled, annotated, and commented on by the noted authority on the Napoleonic Epoch and the Grande Armée, Colonel John R. Elting. Herbert Knötel's watercolor prints in these four volumes are 'all...products of [his] extensive, post World War II research that cleared away many errors common to earlier collections-including his father's famous Grosse Uniformkunde.' Herbert, carefully trained by his father, and a veteran cavalryman on the Eastern Front in World War I, 'worked almost exclusively from manuscript pictorial collections assembled by actual eyewitnesses during or shortly after the Napoleonic era, having an unequaled knowledge of such sources.'

Colonel Elting, while teaching at the United States Military Academy at West Point, was put in touch with Herbert Knötel in Germany, wishing to commission accurate renderings of Napoleonic soldiers to enhance his instruction to the cadets in the history of the military art. This developed into a long-term friendship and a definitive uniform collection, a collection that I would consider one of the best private collections in the world today. With Herbert Knötel's untimely death in 1963, the production of the watercolors came, sadly, to a halt. I have had the privilege of viewing some of the collection with Col. Elting, and it is truly impressive. Equally impressive is Col. Elting's knowledge and understanding of the period, as well as his personal expertise in the uniforms of the epoch.

The first two volumes of the series cover the Grande Armée, its antecedents, the foreign units who fought with it, and its worthless Bourbon successor. Volume I includes sections on the Royal Army, the Armies of the French Revolution, l'Armée d'Egypte, command and staff, line and light infantry, special infantry units, and the line cavalry, both heavy and light, and the dragoons. Volume II covers the foreign troops, the artillery, the Imperial Navy, engineers and the incomparable Imperial Guard. Both of these volumes were published in 1993.

Volumes III and IV of the set were published in April 2000. Volume III covers the Confederation of the Rhine, Denmark, the Republic and Kingdom of Italy, Naples, and Joseph's Kingdom of Spain. Volume IV covers the Republic and Kingdom of Holland, the Grand Duchy of Warsaw, and the myriad allies who were the Grande Armée's enemies, including major sections on the Prussians, Austrians, Russians, and Great Britain.

There are a total of 1,461 watercolor plates, including those on the dust covers, in the four volumes: 920 in Volumes I and II, and 541 in Volumes III and IV. Cuirassiers, hussars, jagers zu pferd, lancers (or uhlans), irregulars, free corps, legions, chasseurs, both horse and foot, grenadiers, light infantrymen --be they légère, jagers, chasseurs, or riflemen-- carabiniers, and the various Guard contingents grace these pages and remind us that the Napoleonic period was truly 'the golden age of the military tailor.'

Here are the generals, officers and men who fought the Napoleonic Wars, and they leap out of the pages at you. The worn-out drummer of the 3e Etranger, formerly the Irish Legion, holding his musket at the ready just one more time, with his drum slung on his back. The artillery general in his full dress finery à la hussard, bellowing 'En Avant!' to his massed companies. The field officer of the Artillerie à Pied of the Imperial Guard having an argument with his horse. The Prussian hussar officer, his saber dangling elegantly by its sword knot from his wrist, speaking to his trumpeter. The infantry sapper with a '1000 yard stare.' The Würtemberger Garde du Corps trotting past on a magnificent black horse. Infantrymen of many nations trudging along God knows what roads to their next bivouac. Also depicted are the deadly specialists, the 'veteran marchers and killers,' such as the Corsicans of the Tirailleurs Corses or the infantry of the Old Guard. All these soldiers await us within these four volumes.

Errors in the prints are few, and Col. Elting points these out quite readily. If there is a doubt on the accuracy or probability of a print, the author rates it a 'probable'; when primary sources differ on a uniform, the alternate renderings are given in the captions; when a uniform item is missing, the details are filled in so the reader can be assured of accuracy. Instead of lessening the impact of the print in question, this raises the validity of the study as it tells us of Col. Elting's endless search for veracity and accuracy.

One thing that has been left out of the books, and is in Col. Elting's collection, are the group prints by Knötel which are breathtaking with all the color and sweep of the period. These have been left out because of the parameters of the book, which is understandable, yet it would have been ideal to have these reproduced in their own section. Having personally viewed these prints, oozing character and the gregariousness of military men, I can assure you that these are undoubtedly Knötel's best work.

The watercolors are painstakingly accurate, lively, and portray the combat soldier as few artists have done. The horses are particularly well done, and one can tell that Knötel was completely familiar, and at home with, the loyal, hardworking companions of the fighting man. Additionally, having Col. Elting's wry and witty insight into uniforms and personalities is definitely a bonus, each print having a caption by the author, and each section having an appropriate introduction.

With these two volumes, Col. Elting has completed his planned trilogy on the Napoleonic Wars and the Grande Armée. This has taken over 40 years of study, painstaking research, and writing. No other author I can think of, past or present, has had the expertise to contribute to the growing library of credible Napoleonic scholarship in three distinct areas: the operational study that is A Military History and Atlas of the Napoleonic Wars, the organizational history of the Grande Armée in Swords Around A Throne, and this four volume uniform study. We as students are extremely lucky to have him in our midst.

These four volumes are a must for any historian, uniformologist, collector, and painter of military miniatures of the Napoleonic period. Nowhere else can we find today a collection of uniform prints with the accuracy, detail, color, sang froid, and realism of combat soldiers as they are depicted within this collectio. These four volumes, and the work they contain, are simply masterpieces and belong on all of our bookshelves. They are worth the price asked. In fact they are a bargain for what you get, and have been definitely worth the wait. This is the definitive uniform study of the Napoleonic Wars.

Col Elting's collection of Herbert Knotel's work is now in the West Point Museum, except for the large group watercolors which are in private collections.
22 Comments| One person found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you? Report abuse
on 18 December 2007
(make a note, that this review applies to Greenhill 2007 volumes 1-2 edition). Everyone knows what the book is about. The set is intended for serious collectors, and it was quite disappointing to find such a poor shell for such an excellent material inside. It looks like the Publisher wanted to have deluxe-like binding but at low cost. As a result you will get thin cardboard slip case covered with light cloth of inferior quality and books covered with the same cloth with no protective dust-jackets. I have no idea - why the Publisher did not use thick cardboard laminated box and laminated dust-jackets. I wonder how long will this cloth stand intensive reading and skipping over. It was very bad idea, in particular, to cover the case with cloth of such quality - if you put the case on bookshelf and intend to use books often, the lower part will wear out quite soon. As mentioned before slip case is made of thin cardboard, offers very little protection to books and may cause transport damage if carelessly packed (like mine, obtained from Amazon, later replased by Amazon). Apart from crease and bump to the box (what caused ugly bump to book corner - due to the poor material of the box) one volume has some awful dark stain on cloth cover (books are delivered sealed!). This will not increase the value of the set, which is not coffee table. It looks like binding company employees have some problems with washing hands and cleaning work place. So, if you are serious collector and have extra money - order "heavy duty" slip case to replace this example of cost cut-minded publishing and underpaid Chinese printing / binding industry.
11 Comment| 12 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you? Report abuse

Sponsored Links

  (What is this?)