Learn more Download now Shop now Shop now Shop now Shop now Shop now Shop now Shop now Shop now Learn More Shop now Learn more Shop Fire Shop Kindle Learn More Shop now Shop now Learn more

on 3 August 2017
A book which takes a different slant and in doing so illuminates a different way of seeing the gospels. I recommend this to anyone Christian or non Christian, so long as you have an open mind and are willing to consider new evidence and different possibilities.
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you? Report abuse
on 5 August 2013
Cynthia Bourgeault is undoubtedly a scholar of the Wisdom tradition and a walker of the spiritual path. Her breadth of vision and reference material is very impressive and although scholarly in her approach, her work is accessible and rich with meaning. This book provides tools to assist in the transformation of consciousness and as such the wisdom and gems it offers are priceless.
0Comment| 11 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you? Report abuse
on 29 September 2012
The writer has a transformative view of christianity and one that understands the teachings of Christ in a way that makes them meaningful in our present age. i recommend this book to anyone who is spiritual but not drawn to the dogma of churches.
0Comment| 5 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you? Report abuse
on 8 December 2011
I have been enormously inspired by this book. It challenges and affirms and sends me out again into a changed world where there is a God - bigger than the one I had previously perceived. Are you serious about knowing God in yourself and in others? Read this.
0Comment| 22 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you? Report abuse
on 18 June 2011
Recommended as a must read to look at this subject in a new way and not from a 'conventionally religious' point of view.
0Comment| 10 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you? Report abuse
on 13 November 2012
What is wrong with modern Christianity? Did Christianity get off on the wrong foot almost from its inception? That is the thesis of this thought provoking and challenging book, a fascinating new take on the Jesus Christ we thought we were familiar with.

The starting point of the book is the Gospel of Thomas, restored to us when it was found among the Nag Hammadi scrolls in the Egyptian desert in 1945. These scrolls date back to early Christianity, being at least as old as the four canonical gospels, now widely regarded as the authentic teachings of Jesus, and give us a radical new take on Jesus and the metaphysics of his teaching.
Referring also to the 1960s Syriac studies, the Qumran Dead Sea Scrolls, Celtic poetry, Chinese Jesus Sutras, the African desert fathers, and so on, the author convincingly argues that the familiar Christian creeds and doctrines put together in the fourth century get in the way of understanding Jesus as a master in ancient spiritual wisdom, who was teaching the meltdown and recasting, the transformation, of human consciousness. This is the Eastern-like wisdom path of Jesus the life giver, a Jesus who is like us, calling us to put on the mind of Christ, telling us that the Kingdom of Heaven is a metaphor for a state of consciousness, a transformed awareness, a nondual or unitive consciousness, of divine abundance. There is then no separation between God and human, between human and human, all dwelling together in mutual loving reciprocity. The Kingdom of Heaven is within us and at hand, here and now, something we awaken into, not die into. This contrasts with the Pauline image of Jesus as Savior, who died for our sins, who is different from us, and has come to atone for mankind's depravity.

Today in Western Christian tradition we rely too much on logic, and doctrine and dogma. The author challenges these Western assumptions about Christianity and Christ, as she reminds us that whilst Christians take the events surrounding the resurrection as basic to their faith, the apostles who chose to follow Jesus knew nothing of what the future held. They had to see something else in this man, and we are long overdue, she writes, for a re-evaluation of how we understand the Jesus events and our religion based thereon, and of us understanding Christianity as a spiritual contemplative tradition. Indeed we see the first hopeful signs of this transformation.

The author examines our familiar Christian stories in this new light, as radical calls for the transformation of our consciousness; indeed shows how some of them become more readily understood within this new context. Jesus came to transform our brain led egoic operating system into a non-dual unitive system that is led by the heart, an organ of spiritual perception. In this light "repent" means to "go beyond the mind", or "into the larger mind", which is somewhat different from our classic understanding of repentance.

The book's thesis is lucidly explained step by step through Parts 1 and 2, respectively the Teachings of Jesus, and the Mysteries (Incarnation, Passion, Crucifixion, and the Great Easter Fast (not a spelling error!). It concludes in Part Three with core Christian wisdom practices available to us all; Centering Prayer Meditation, Lectio Divina, Chanting and Psalmody, and the Welcoming Prayer, the last being a pathway of vibrant spiritual strength and creativity connecting us to our energetic fields. The author takes us through these practices in detail, step by step. If we are diligent with these practices she tells us that we will find, as Jesus promised for ears who could hear, that the spirit lies within each one if us, connecting with reality and with each other.

The core Christian practice of the Eucharist can then be seen as more than a cultic ritual, experienced within the lower mythic or rational ranges of consciousness (as per Ken Wilber). It can instead be recognized as being at heart a wisdom practice originating from a non dual level of consciousness, when the celebration comes into its own.

I loved this book. I have already read it twice! As a Christian who has thought much and written something myself about the possible interface between new ideas on consciousness and the spirituality within religion, especially Christianity, this book is a breath of fresh air. Mainstream Christianity is losing ground, losing sight of the real gospel message of Jesus, the Jesus who came first and foremost as a teacher of the path of inner transformation, the deep level of consciousness he was trying to tell us about, a spiritual path that is found through self-emptying kenosis.
Christianity is either destined to change and grow into a proper form to match the consciousness of the twenty first century: or it will disappear as an institution and we shall then be left face to face with the naked presence of Christ.
11 Comment| 42 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you? Report abuse
on 10 April 2017
Making Jesus in Her Image

If some of the words in this review seem harsh, please keep in mind that Jesus reserved some of his strongest criticisms for the religious teachers of his time. This is because their errors had negative consequences far greater than the minor, moral failings of ordinary humans.
Cynthia Bourgeault (CB) portrays Jesus as a wisdom teacher in probably the same way that she views herself as a great wisdom teacher. But her words expose her as one who lacks the mystical understanding of the parables that were explained only by Jesus to his closest disciples or later to those inspired by the Holy Spirit. So if you follow CB it will be like the “blind leading the blind.” Her dazzling intellect blinds the reader and then CB leads him or her by the hand unintentionally into the ditch.
Nonetheless, she does make a valuable contribution in the Chapter 3 when discussing the difference between the dualistic, egotistical brain-mind and the nondual spiritual heart-mind. However, it would have been helpful if she had mentioned, if she knows, that the dualistic brain-mind is referred to in the Bible as the “tree of the knowledge of good and evil” and the nondual heart-mind is symbolized as the “tree of life.”
However, CB falls down when she is unable to apply her insights related to brain and sacred heart to the wisdom teachings of Jesus contained in his parables. She demonstrates very little contemplative insight into the Jesus parables. This is unfortunate since the parables are the core of Christ’s contemplative prayer teachings and his instruction for actually experiencing and living from nondual consciouness - not just talking or writing about it.
This reviewer contends that the Jesus parables contain symbolic instruction in contemplative prayer for his closest and most spiritually mature disciples. Someday when CB discovers this it may radically change her prayer life and instruction to others. She may even declare as Saint Thomas Aquinas did after his mystical awakening toward the end of his life: All I have written till now is just straw. It is only fit for burning.
The following is a discussion of CB’s parable interpretation shortcomings.
On pages 51-52 she discusses the parable of the “five wise and five foolish bridesmaids.” The wise have oil in their lamps and the foolish do not. Furthermore, the wise refuse to share their oil with the foolish. CB is correct in recognizing that in this, as in all of Jesus’ parables, he is not giving a lesson in “nice” or moral behavior. Unfortunately, this is where her understanding of the parable wisdom apparently ends. These teachings are deeply mystical and only accessible to those with “eyes to see and ears to hear.” That is why Jesus only explained his parables in secret to his closest, most spiritually mature followers.
The first mistake CB makes is to forget the advice of Saint Augustine to look for the mystical significance of numbers that occur in Scripture. Thus CB did not consider that 5 “bridesmaids” were not meant to be interpreted literally as humans but were actually “symbols” and thus CB did not consider the following: There are 5 senses and there is a wise and a foolish way to use the senses. The wise use of the senses does not waste lamp oil (life energy) but conserves and even accumulates more. But a foolish use of the senses wastes life energy. When we are tempted to “squander” energy on foolish, sensual pursuits Jesus is teaching us to “just say no” to sense temptations – as is done in the parable. Perhaps in this parable Jesus is even giving us one of the signs of a wise person.
CB proposes that the “oil” in this parable “stands for the quality of your transformed consciousness.” However, in the parable it is the quantity, not the quality, of the oil that is the issue. There is a big difference between having no oil in a lamp and having a lower quality of oil. The same would be true of the oil in your automobile. CB is changing the parable to suit her agenda. This is known as intellectual dishonesty if done intentionally.
Neither does CB tell the reader about the significant remainder of the parable. Perhaps at least in this instance she was being wise not to discuss what she does not understand. But there may be another reason. It contradicts her Centering Prayer contemplative practice and indicates an alternative way of contemplative prayer that Jesus taught to his disciples.
Jesus goes on to state in the parable that the foolish bridesmaids could not enter into the marriage ceremony with the bridegroom but the wise could. A Holy-Spirit-initiated, Christian mystic would look at this and recognize that the marriage chamber represents the “cave of the heart” in the center of the soul where the mystical marriage with the inner Christ occurs. One can only withdraw attention into this interior heart center if one has sufficient accumulated life energy and thus alertness and subtle, focused attention to thread the “eye of a needle.” The reader can verify this by trying to meditate inwardly when sleepy or if exhausted after over-indulgence in sensual stimulation.
Also, relevant to contemplative meditation in this parable, but not mentioned by CB, is that both the wise and the foolish in this parable are asleep when the bridegroom arrives. This may be surprising to the reader since the parable ends with Jesus telling us to be watchful for his coming. One would think that in the parable the wise bridesmaids would have been awake and the foolish ones would have been foolishly asleep.
But Jesus is using the word “sleep” as a metaphor. He is also speaking in this parable about his inner coming and not his external appearance to the five outwardly-directed senses. Sleep is a metaphor for the stilling of the senses. There is a wise way to still the senses and there is a foolish way. The wise way is by the withdrawal and concentration of attention and life energy inward to the center of the soul where the “’star of Christ’ rises in the heart” in the interior state of heightened alertness and expectancy. The foolish way to put the senses to sleep is to “squander” one’s life energy and enter a state of debilitating exhaustion.
In this reviewer’s opinion the way in which the author CB interpreted the above parable reveals her ego’s blind spot related to her understanding of life energy and contemplative meditation as well as her ignorance of the contemplative instruction present in the parables.
The word “squandering” by definition refers to the wasteful and unfruitful use of resources. CB has a keen and dazzling intellect and is eloquent and precise in verbal expression. We can be sure CB knows precisely the meaning of the word “squander” and definitely how virtually all readers will interpret that word.
Her ego’s blind spot can be seen again in her discussion of the prodigal son parable on page 49. Clearly, Jesus is telling us another parable about the negative consequences of squandering the life energy that God gives us. Jesus even uses the word “squander” to describe the wasteful behavior of the reckless sensuality of the younger, wandering son. This prodigal son suffered greatly until he finally “came to his senses” and turned around and headed homeward to God. A mystical contemplative would say the son finally exercised discipline over his senses and withdrew his attention inward to the center of his being where God dwellings eternally waiting for us to return.
But CB fails to discuss, and apparently misses altogether, the deep mystical, contemplative wisdom of the prodigal son parable – how it represents all of our journeys away from wasteful distractions and back to the center of our being. Instead she just discusses the unexpected embrace by God-the-“Father” of the returning younger son while the older son was left out of the celebration by his own resentment.
However, CB does later on page 68 make a passing reference again to this parable to support her own contemplative agenda and bias which differs from the wisdom Jesus apparently intended to impart with his parables. There she quotes Karl Rahner, who by some twisted, serpentine exercise of theological mis-logic, states in apparent reference to the above prodigal son parable: “God is the prodigal who squanders himself.”
CB’s view that the word “squander” describes God’s creative expression is very unfortunate. It may be used by some readers to justify human energy squandering that inevitably leads to suffering and estrangement from God as it did for the “prodigal son.” Maybe the subconscious intention of those authors who play such word games is to justify their own lifestyles of squandering and egotistical, intellectual journeys away from the feeling of God’s interior, central, loving presence. God’s creative expression comes from a source of infinite supply and divine wisdom. To equate it in the mind of a reader with human, self-indulgent “squandering” is deceptively misleading. This is what CB has done in this instance.
The parable of the laborers in the vineyard (p 38) is another example of how CB misses the mark by failing to take Saint Augustine’s guidance regarding the mystical significance of numbers in Scripture.
In her interpretation CB totally ignored that there are specifically 5 groups of laborers that are sequentially hired throughout the day in the parable. CB then goes on to give an economic interpretation of the parable that states that in nondual reality there is unlimited abundance and that is why all groups were paid the same amount. She again failed to recognize the mystical significance of the occurrence of five in that parable and thus could not access the intended contemplative prayer instruction of Jesus. She also conveniently ignored and did not interpret that the groups were paid in the reverse order of hiring.
To a mystic who moves into and out of the sacred heart center during contemplative meditation there is another interpretation to this puzzling parable that comes to mind. During the inward movement of attention toward the sacred center of the soul, layers of decreasing density are engaged and traversed in the body-soul from the outermost to the innermost layer. These layers are called kelipot (shells), koshas, and “coats of skin” in Hebrew mysticism, yoga and the Bible’s Book of Genesis respectively.
The early Christian Church father Bishop Origen interpreted the “coats of skin” that God put on Adam and Eve as the physical and psychic layers that surround the essential self of a person and not animal skins as is the usual literal interpretation. In some metaphysical systems there are five such layers including the physical body. These are, from outer to inner, the physical, etheric, emotional, mental and causal (memory) layer.
In this true centering each layer is relaxed of the constricting tension that blocks the Divine Radiance at the center. This explains what Jesus meant by “harden not your heart.” In such a meditation one essentially homes in with attention on the feeling of radiant love coming from God at the center. This also explains what Jesus meant by “don’t hide your light under a bushel basket.” To be centered is to be surrendered to and guided by the Divine Will emanating from the Center. This is very different from the so-called “Centering” Prayer taught by CB and the other which has no attentive orientation to the Center at all.
When it is time to pay the laborers at the end of the day, the groups are paid sequentially in the reverse order of hiring – starting with the last group first. Even more surprising is that all the groups were paid the same amount including those who worked the whole day and those or worked only for a short time at the end of the day.
In this parable the sequentially hiring of the five groups of laborers corresponds to the inner meditative movement through the layers. The payment represents the Grace that is received by the layers from the Central Sun of God. Each layer receives the same Light (same “payment”) but in the reverse order – from inner to outer from the Divine source.
Please feel free to reply to this review with your comments – pro or con.
Also, please read the reviewer's one star review of CB's "The Heart of Centering Prayer" which adds to this discussion.
May the “star of Christ rise in your heart.”
11 Comment| 7 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you? Report abuse
on 21 February 2009
This is an amazing perspective on Jesus from the context of Wisdom, which wonderfully brings out how his message is about a transformation of consciousness. Radical, yet aligned with the heart of tradition, this is one of the best books - perhaps the best - I have read on mystic Christianity.
0Comment| 36 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you? Report abuse
on 3 October 2013
Cynthia Bourgeault's book 'The Wisdom Jesus' is the most refreshing spiritual book I have read in years. Bourgeault takes our traditional understanding of the life and teaching of Jesus and turns that traditional teaching on its head by interpreting the teaching of Jesus through the wisdom tradition. In doing so, this author has opened my mind to some amazing insights and encouraged me to reconsider some major aspects of the teaching of Jesus and what it means to us in our lives today. The book was recommended to me by a friend who is a theologian - I am very grateful to her!

B. Daly
0Comment| 10 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you? Report abuse
on 17 June 2012
This is a truly inspiring read. It gets right to the heart of what Jesus was all about without the trappings of dogma and ritual. After all Jesus was not a Christian himself but brought up a Jew. The early church followers seemed to be more in tune with what he was really trying to say in his zen-like parables than we are today. We have lost something of the original essence in the West. After reading this book I would think anyone would desire to follow him.

The author gives a set of exercises at the back of the book to help the reader to tune into what Jesus was really saying. There is the activity of centering prayer and also the discipline of lectio divina amongst others. The reader is asked to experience the presence of God through surrender and letting go. It is all about taming the ego and moving away from the little self to understand the higher consciousness - a quantum leap of faith. It asks us to look at life from a perspective of non-duality.

Excellent. May this book grace the hands and bookshelves of many seekers and inspire them. There is much to be learnt from this book that looks at Jesus and his teachings in a new light. I am inspired.
0Comment| 11 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you? Report abuse

Sponsored Links

  (What is this?)