Top critical review
One person found this helpful
"Simply solve the mystery of Farpoint Station."
on 17 March 2008
Titan Books start their Star Trek The Next Generation series with the adaptation of the pilot episode Encounter At Farpoint written by Trek scribe David Gerrold.
The main problem with episode based novels is that the episode is always much better. Writers tend to delve into what they believe the character is thinking at a certain time and this can lead to monotonous exposition and dull story writing.
While Encounter At Farpoint was a very formulaic sci-fi story and a rather straightforward Trek adventure, Gerrold unfortunately does nothing to enhance the plot with his writing at all.
The beginning of the book where Picard sets foot on the Enterprise is now completely at odds with the scenes from All Good Things - although that hadn't aired at the time so you can give some leeway there.
There is also a major change concerning Data. In this book, Data was created by aliens who lived inside a planet which had been colonised by humans. When a natural catastrophe killed the colonists the aliens created Data in the human image and downloaded the memories of the people into him. Of course, this entire story is at odds with the events of season one's `Datalore'. Besides, why didn't the aliens help the humans instead of this ridiculous idea of preserving their memories in a machine?
There are also musings from Picard early on about a woman called Celeste. Whether this was an idea dropped in the series creation or just the writers fancy I'm not sure but it all seems rather irrelevant to the story.
For those that haven't seen Encounter At Farpoint (there may be a few out there!) the story centres around Jean-Luc Picard as he takes command of the U.S.S. Enterprise-D. On the way to Deneb 4, home of the Bandi and their Farpoint Station, the ship encounters Q, a powerful alien entity who accuses them of being a grievously savage child race. Picard challenges Q to test that assumption of humanity now and Q agrees, asking Picard to simply solve the mystery of the station.
The Enterprise arrives and Picard meets with the rest of his crew who are awaiting transfer, namely Commander Riker, Doctor Crusher and Lt. LaForge. The three explain the rather strange events that have happened to them on the station, magical events that defy explanation. When an alien ship arrives and attacks the Bandi they begin to uncover clues that link all these unexplainable events together.
There aren't really any surprises in the plot and if the show had been made today then I doubt STTNG would've made it past a first season. The book isn't that bad, it's just that the story isn't particularly good. Best thing you can do is watch the pilot and a few episodes and then move straight onto novel #1 Ghost Ship.