Learn more Download now Browse your favorite restaurants Shop now Shop now Shop now Shop now Shop now Learn more Shop now Shop now Learn more Learn more Shop Kindle Learn More Shop now Shop now Learn more

on 23 May 2014
Surviving a Japanese Internment Camp

Life and Liberation at Santo Tomás, Manila, in World War II

Rupert Wilkinson (2014) McFarland & Company, Jefferson, N. Carolina

This is an extraordinary book recounting the details of one of the largest concentration camps for civilians that the Japanese established in Manila, Philippines in early 1942. Rupert Wilkinson was interred in this camp as a young boy and has waited 70 years to write this book. Two aspects come through. The first is that the author is a professional historian, and the second is that he has not wasted the 70 years since the camp was liberated – he has been thinking about it!
[Statement of interest: I was also in this camp, but was too young to remember it. I have never met the author]

The historical section of this book treads a familiar path – there have been many books about Santo Tomás, so the overall picture of the camp is well known. However, the author’s main point is not to describe the scene day-by-day but more to ask questions. There are two main ones.

(1) Were all the Japanese brutal savages?

(2) What was the role of the camp “organizers” and was it effective?

Wilkinson clearly does not believe that the Japanese were universally “evil” – they are certainly not now, I have many good Japanese friends. He points out the anti-West propaganda and brutal military training programs that were part of the culture of pre-war Japan had a profound effect on Japanese troops who were seeing foreign lands and people for the first time. This is not an excuse, just a fact. As with Germany in that period, we see a steady decline in moral standards to a state that eventually condones barbaric behavior. It is a slippery slope requiring continual diligence – example Syria of today.

The story of the camp “organisers”, almost always elected (although the Japanese often interfered in such democratic processes), is a complex one. In the early days of Santo Tomás, the Japanese took a very hands-off approach, essentially leaving the organisation of the camp to many different committees. This even extended to the feeding of the prisoners, where, at least at the beginning, internees were actually fed by paying local Filippinos to bring in food from the outside. The Japanese army expected enemy troops to fight to the death, and had apparently not thought they might capture a large number of enemy civilians, and hence had no plans to feed them. By 1944 conditions had changed much for the worse, especially with respect to the supply of food. The Japanese concerns were dominated by what the local guerilla forces knew or planned, so the outside contact steadily decreased as the years continued. The various civilian leaders had to tread a fine line between the Japanese military and their civilian colleagues, who often became upset that the leaders appeared to be agreeing with the Japanese! This “balance” swung back and forth, often depending on the whims of the Japanese commander. In general, the author has high praise for such leaders; their job started from impossible and went downhill from there.

The rescue of the camp in February 1945 after the Linguyan landings, charged to a so-called flying column, by General MacArthur, was a spectacular success (and described very well in the book), but was predicated to some extent on the rumor that the Japanese were planning either to massacre the prisoners or send them by boat to Japan. Of course, the latter fate would have been a massacre also, as by late 1944 the US was sinking any ship approaching Japan. The author finds no evidence that such a massacre was planned. Indeed, the general disorganization of the Japanese by late 1944, surrounded by guerillas on land, and the US forces approaching by sea and air, suggests that their only concern was for their own skin. After the US forces entered the camp, the Japanese took a number of hostages (mostly young boys from one of the dormitories, the author being one of them). The hostages were released on condition the Japanese guard troops had safe passage out of the camp. This deal was done, but it did not include passage through the Philippino guerillas, and most of the Japanese guards never survived that gauntlet.

One interesting aspect is the opinion of the author on a band (~60) US Army & Navy Nurses brought from Corregidor after it fell in May 1942. On p. 113 he calls them arrogant and adds “They did their job professionally but to often they came across as stiff, unsmiling, and defensive.” In the nurses’s account “We Band of Angels” (Norman, 1999, Pocket Books) the incidents recounted by Wilkinson about the nurses have a different “take” – allowing them the pride of a job well done, and to emerge as heroines. Such are the vagaries of history! My money is on the professional historian, but it is far too late for polemic over such a point. In both accounts their leader Maude Davison comes through as one tough lady – perhaps exactly what was needed.

The Santo Tomás story is a fascinating one that Rupert Wilkinson tells with enough detail to give the overall impressions without all the myriad details. His intent is to ask the big questions and he does that with much flair and intelligence. The 70-year wait is not in vain!

He ends by asking the question as to whether it is more evil to slay civilians at close range than to bomb them from great heights. An old discussion but made more relevant today as we see the introduction of drone warfare.

I most heartily recommend this book to anyone who enjoys a good read and likes to have serious questions posed along the way.

G. H. Lander (gerry_lander@hotmail.com)
St. Ismier,
May 2014
One person found this helpful
|0Comment|Report abuse
on 17 May 2015
I have not read the book yet BUT I heard a talk about it and expected a book of general memories. In fact, having riffled through it in preparation to reading it this autumn, it appears to be a book of detailed content (and pictures) with pages of references at the end. It is after all a book by someone who not only experienced the dangers and suffering, but grew up to become a professor of American studies. It's remarkable for being the personal experience of someone whose father knew the Pearl Harbour attack was going to take place and passed the info on to Churchill and was then rescued by submarine having to leave behind his wife and children -- and thus the book.
|0Comment|Report abuse
on 5 May 2015
Very insightful study by someone who lived there in his youth and researched the subject in his seniority.
|0Comment|Report abuse
on 6 January 2014
We often forget the human side of war and those whose lives are affected by the posturing of great nations. This book is an insight into the reality of a family caught up in Manila during at the outbreak of the Pacific War in 1942 and whose lives were turned upside down as they were cast out of the `Eden' of their ex-pat existence and incarcerated in Santo Tomas prison camp. Santo Tomas, it must be said, was no a Belsen or Auswitz. It was as the author admits a rather porous prison and one where the internees organized their lives on a thriving communal basis albeit with ever-present hunger, deprivation and threats of execution from their Japanese jailors. It vividly documents highs and lows of camp life and the hoped for liberation that eventually came in 1945. It's a fascinating story and is written with a lightness of touch that keeps one entranced and engaged throughout.
3 people found this helpful
|0Comment|Report abuse
on 1 March 2014
I'm no historian, but I'm fascinated by personal experiences of people during the wars.

What's great about Wilkinson's account is that it's personal - told through his eyes as a young boy (unnusual for an autobiography) when he was taken prisoner - yet not another boring history book.

He zooms in on individuals and groups (including the japanese soldiers - of whom his descriptions are humorous, terrifying & endeering); and deals with subjects which have tended to be overlooked (too taboo? too trivial?) such as sex in shanties: I tried to imagine the lack of privacy & this chapter really illustrates it.

He manages, with his refreshingly simple and relaxed writing style, to make microscopic detail - scavenging for a china cup, where radios were smuggled, nighties used to make shirts - fascinating. Read this book and you'll feel you're experiencing the camp, the heat, the lack of space, the routine.

But - perhaps most important - he doesn't seem to write with a subsequently acquired bias towards any particular group (I think of my father, who fought on destroyers in the Pacific, whose bitterness towards the japanese peppered his descriptions of them whilst the Germans & French - many of whom became his good friends after the war - were forgiven).

Overall a balanced, fun, gripping, insight into life in the camp; the war from a child's perspective; and human nature - the bad & the good. A must read.
|0Comment|Report abuse
on 28 January 2014
Like Rupert Wilkinson, I was a British internee in Santo Tomas. There have been valuable histories of the camp before, but not since the 1960s and nothing as comprehensive as this. He has done a magnificent job and the book will surely become the standard work on the subject. It is hard to see how it can be bettered. I had no idea there was so much literature on the topic, especially memoirs both published and unpublished. Wilkinson has brought all his sources together, and interweaved his own memories, most skilfully. He presents a vivid picture of the history, society and life of Santo Tomas, but he also puts the camp in its wider political, economic and military context in an illuminating way. The drama of liberation, after the long months of waiting and hunger, is excitingly brought to life, and the text is richly illustrated with arresting, well-captioned, photographs and drawings. Not least, in his closing chapter Wilkinson is prepared to address important moral questions of responsibility and guilt - other writers might have avoided them. Former internees, their descendants, and students of the war in the Philippines, will all be in his debt.
2 people found this helpful
|0Comment|Report abuse
on 23 January 2014
This is a well researched and balanced book providing fresh insight into the wartime experiences of not only civilian internees but their captors too. I was particularly interested in the chapter about the Japanese commanders. Wilkinson describes their various character traits and leadership styles - some kind and jovial, others damaged and child-like - and the resulting repercussions for internees and camp life. He writes with the skill of a historian, yet his personal story adds great insight and depth. My six year old is fascinated with not only the brilliantly captioned photographs, but also the accounts of internee children - amongst them Wilkinson- who were the same age as my son is now. A jolly good read.
2 people found this helpful
|0Comment|Report abuse

Need customer service? Click here