Top critical review
6 people found this helpful
A Collection of Journalism and Other Peoples Tales
on 20 November 2011
Because of Peter Ackroyd's reputation for fiction as well as non fiction preceding him before I had even read a word I had very high expectations from this book. I wanted a really interesting and eye opening dialogue with Peter about the ghost stories that he had collected all over the UK and why indeed the British Isles seems to be a place where hosts are seen far more than in any other country in the world. I did get this... in the introduction, which I loved.
The problem was that from then on we simply had a collection/anthology of all the ghost stories that Ackroyd had found, and while I happily admit I enjoyed them I did want something more. The more I read the opening words in each tale like `the following letter by...' or `the following report appeared in the `X' newspaper' the more I was thinking `hang on, is this a bit of a cut and paste job. Is this all research and no real revelation or conversation?' It was a conversation with Ackroyd about the ghost stories and the facts and people involved with them that I wanted not really an encyclopaedia.
This makes me sound really ungrateful I know, and I did actually read it in just a few days because it is great to dip in and out of. I should have just thought `wow, what a collection of tales from the infamous Borley Rectory, to smaller unknown stories' (I was excited that the Blue Bell Hill story was included as my Great Aunty Pat told me that tale as a kid as she knew the people involved) and some of the stories are genuinely unnerving (weirdly the more modern ones) as from the witness accounts you know several people saw these events happen and it does make you ponder on what on earth is really out there. I did also really like Ackroyd's retelling of the stories when there were no `official' accounts too, I just wanted more dialogue with him, more banter. There isn't even an afterword or really any note on why he wanted to do this particular paranormal project.
I am aware this is rather a short set of book thoughts, and one I feel I have come away doing Ackroyd a slight disservice in writing. If you want a collection of true life, well it depends on what you believe - but I do, ghost stories then this would be an ideal read for you. If you are looking for a book that tells the tales and discusses why these might have happened or any other subjective thoughts and reasoning's you might want to try elsewhere. I liked `The English Ghost' a lot, I just expected more, so maybe the fault lies with me?