Learn more Shop now Shop now Shop now Shop now Shop now Shop now Learn More Shop now Learn more Click Here Shop Kindle Learn More Shop now Shop Women's Shop Men's

There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.

on 19 June 2015
Hide and Seek, also known as The Mystery of Mary Grice, is a very early work by Collins - in fact only the almost unreadable Antonina (set in ancient Rome) and Basil predate it. The plot hinges on a number of coincidences and assumptions that stretch the readers' supsension of disbelief to the limit. The truth is Mary Grice is not a mystery at all, the reader will guess most if not all the resolution at an early stage. Mary Grice herself is not very interesting, and the emotions she stirs up and fascination she generates in her adoptive father strike a modern reader as creepy to say the least. The "hero" Zack is one of those young men who can take nothing seriously and who one longs to slap. There is a patronising and belittling attitude towards most of the women, who are regarded as only a little superior to household pets, it seems (in Darwin's words "better than a dog, anyway"), epitomised by Zack's greeting to the girl known as Madonna (because of her resemblance to a Raphael Madonna) "how is the dearest, sweetest, gentlest love in the world?" (They are not a couple by the way at any point). Any girl who will allow a man to address her thus deserves all she gets in condescension.
Those who, like me, are reading "complete works of..."(Collins is my next author now I've finished Trollope) will press on, the rest should pass on to The Woman in White, or No Name.
0Comment| 2 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 20 April 2008
This novel from 1854, published six years before The Woman in White shows Wilkie Collins still finding his feet. He claims it was written in reaction to reviewers who said he couldn't `do' character; and unfortunately, the book, at this stage in his career at least, proves the critics had a point. Madonna Blyth, the orphaned deaf and dumb girl, whose origins are revealed in the climax to the plot, is boringly virtuous - actually, she's beyond boring: she's excruciating! - and many of the other characters are either implausible or dislikeable.

Originally, the novel was longer than the version available here; Collins cut it considerably for its republication, which is actually an advantage since the first half is really rather dull, not at all a page turner. Of course, there are some promising signs of things to come: for example, an effectively suspenseful scene where Madonna, who is afraid of the dark, is alone at dead of night when an intruder blows out her candle flame. I liked the descriptions of the artistic household of Valentine Blyth; and there are some good comic set-pieces. But also, rather tediously, there is quite a lot of female and familial piety, which Collins assumes will interest and absorb the reader much more than it does.
11 Comment| 8 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 14 July 2009
Warning: this review contains spoilers

'Hide and Seek' is an early novel of Wilkie Collins published in 1854, written before he hit the big time with 'The Woman in White' in 1860.

A painter, Valentine Blyth, visits a circus where he is captivated by one of the performers, a deaf mute girl, whom he adopts. The plot of the novel concerns the girl's parentage and the efforts of one Mat Marksman to discover the whereabouts of the man who abandoned her mother before she was born.

One gets the sense of Collins feeling his way in this early novel and of trying to be different, almost experimental. In the first half, the narrative moves back and forth in time (one wonders whether he was influenced here by 'Wuthering Heights' which had only been published a few years previously) but this only serves to hold up the story. Each of the characters is delineated by an idiosyncrasy: Mr Thorpe the religious zealot, the neurotic Valentine Blyth who seems only to be able to form relationships with women who are in some way disabled (his bedridden wife and the deaf mute girl he adopts), the moody, saturnine Mat Marksman, the ebullient Zack Thorpe.

Certain aspects of the book do stretch credibility. Characters too often happen to be in the right place at the right time, whether it be in a drinking den, a graveyard or near a writing bureau. One of the most intriguing aspects of the book is the relationship between Blyth, his wife and Madonna. Because of the conventions of the time in which he was writing, Collins has to dissemble. Are Blyth and Madonna having a sexual relationship? Is Mrs Blyth aware of this? Or is Blyth asexual?

The strongest parts of this weak novel are the events concerning the discovery of Madonna's parentage. Collins comes into his own here and these sections of the book make for a good read.

Hide and Seek can really only be recommended to Collins' aficionados or to those lovers of the Victorian novel who have read all the top ranking ones and need to move on to those in the second rank.
0Comment| 5 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 12 June 2011
While not in the same class as No Name, this is a well written and moving novel. It shows Collins as against the constraints of religion and the snobbery attached to art criticism. It shows his great humanity.
The characters are well defined and loveable. I cannot share the criticism of the other reviewers - some of the gothic plots in Collins's novels beggar description - this one is fairly down to earth.
As with so many of his works - wait for a winter's afternoon, curl up by the fire and enjoy!
0Comment| One person found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 10 November 2012
The back cover of 'Hide and Seek' promises intrigue, mystery and villians aplenty, but sadly fails to deliver on all counts.

I was so disappointed with 'Hide and Seek' - the story of Valentine Blyth and his mysterious deaf and mute adopted daughter - just didn't strike a chord with me at all. The majority of the portion I managed to wade through (before finally admitting defeat), concentrated more on the minutiae of Valentine's daily life than anything else. There were signs of promise in the back story of Mary (aka Madonna, the adopted daughter) but even this never really got going.

Sadly I just gave up on this one in the end as I couldn't foresee it getting interesting. However, I won't be giving up on Collins just yet. I'm sure there's another of his works out there equal to 'The Woman in White' and I'm determined to find it!!
11 Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 28 November 2009
I shouldn't really be reviewing this novel. In fact there is no way that this is going to be a review because I didn't get very far with it. I am an avid Wilkie Collins fan, having loved all 4 of his well known works and also The Dead Secret. But I found this so turgid and boring that I gave up. I would just like to advise any other Wilkie Collins fans to give this one a miss, and anyone wishing to read one for the first time, to steer clear of this one as it would give the wrong impression of his books.
0Comment| 2 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 27 May 2016
A fab book and a quick service.
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse