Top critical review
22 people found this helpful
Thanksgiving - I am not thanking anyone for this one!
on 21 January 2007
Oh dear, it is alright, but just not a patch on her other books!
The charactures are not very well thought out, lacking in depth, just not up to par, it felt a bit rushed, which is a pity, nothing really new, almost an after thought this book.
What is it about?
A poor american doctor with a snub nose and not alot else going for him a bit on the wet side, his sometimes mentioned rabbit, who starts out with a big part that just vanishes after the 3 or 4th page, a potter (female) not well put together, who is a little bit drippy, bit of baggage that takes to long to explain, an strange father who punches doctor without even having a reason to punch him, a pretty trotted out formula of an ex-fiance turning up. So, really doctor and potter probably deserve each other.....
Not sure why they would even re-do this book, very poor - it almost feels like it was easy money to re-issue.