This product is ok. Unlike other reviewers, my product was actually sealed when it arrived. At first it is pretty nice to use. The brush is quite fine (see pictures) which gives a nice even distribution of the mascara. However, after a while, it seems to dry up a little and even with the fine brush becomes quite clumpy / tacky to apply and sticks my lashes together. Water needs adding to thin it out, and even that doesn't work sometimes.