Learn more Download now Browse your favorite restaurants Shop now Shop now Shop now Shop now Shop now Learn more Shop now Shop now Learn more Learn more Shop Kindle Learn More Shop now Shop now Learn more

TOP 100 REVIEWERon 5 April 2015
First published a quarter of a century ago, this relatively short book - some 216 pages of text but with numerous footnotes, a couple of useful appendices and some excellent maps – is a fine and first class piece of scholarship. It has stood the test of time to such an extent that more recent books on the same topic are heavily “inspired” from it, to put it mildly.

Unlike many of these books, and most recently Thomas Asbridge’s book on William Marshal, David Crouch’s volume is a real biography rather than “a life and times” of whatever “great man” happens to be the subject. The meaning here is that it is more tightly focused upon its subject instead on containing numerous digressions and extra pages that add context. In other terms, David Crouch’s book is a piece of scholarship, although written in a clear and simple way, rather than a book targeted at the so-called “general public”.

It is also a seminal book on which many of the more recent publications draw upon, if only because of the author’s major research work in gathering all the charters where William Marshal appear and using these as evidence to supplement and check the contents of the written (and biased) biography of this extraordinarily successful knight. In addition to this, analysing these documents allows David Crouch to reconstitute how and when William Marshall accumulated his landed estates and, perhaps even more importantly, who were his supporters, the knights of his “mesnie” and his friends.

One of the most fascinating features that comes across from this book is not that William Marshall was some kind of “super-hero” and paragon, contrary perhaps to what his (carefully built) reputation makes him out to be but that he was essentially a man of his time. Although much more successful than other knights who were younger sons (“les Jeunes”), he essentially shared their condition, their needs to attach themselves to a powerful patron who could provide for them and give them opportunities to achieve what they were all essentially looking for: land of their own and therefore material security and recognition from their peers.

Obtaining fame and fortune could be achieved through being successful in tournaments with these developing in the twelve century, as is very well shown by the author. The more durable fame and acquiring land was achieved through serving in war as one of the household knights of a powerful master who could grant such land and benefits through marrying the knight off to a rich heiress. William Marshal achieved both kinds of fame. He ultimately had his own household knights and became one of the most powerful magnates of the Kingdom of England.

Another excellent feature of this book is the author’s analysis of his conduct and of what it really meant to be a knight and to conform to what was expecting from one at the time. Here again, the author is very careful to distinguish between the expectations of the time and what we were expect to be part of “chivalric” behaviours. He is also careful when analysing the main written source which is the basis of this book: the biography written about William Marshal shortly after his death, probably commandeered by one of his sons, and based on the reminiscences of his own faithful household knights. William Marshal’s behaviour was, at times, somewhat “borderline”, and bordering on treason.

Some aspects of his career, and, in particular, the major role he played in putting King John on the throne but also, after the loss of Normandy, his attempt to keep his Norman lands by also swearing allegiance to the French King, tend to be (deliberately) underplayed. Some of his attitudes, and in particular the fact that he never lost sight of his own material interests, are also minimised in the written biography but are skilfully reconstituted by the author, showing to what extent he was a man of his times rather than the semi-legendary paragon of knightly virtues that he was made out to be.

Another fascinating theme of this book are the changes in warfare and therefore in the role of a household knight and companion to Kings. This, which the author calls the beginning of “bastard feudalism”, shows that armies were no longer exclusively made up of feudal levies owing limited military service with each magnate bringing his contingent and adding it to the King’s own force. Rather, as the 12th century developed, the hard core of such armies were the household knights and various contingents of professional, i.e. mercenary, troops mostly raised from Flanders, Brabant, Gascony or Poitou, in the case of the Angevin Kings. Also very valuable is that the role of a household knight such as William Marshal was no longer exclusively military. He was also an advisor and a courtier and it is perhaps because he excelled in this role, as much as because of his military prowess that William Marshal was so successful and was remembered as a paragon of knightly virtues.

A further valuable item is the author’s analysis of William Marshal’s role in the last months of King John’s very troubled reign, the regency he exercised, and the role he played in the elaboration of Magna Carta. Interestingly, in the latter case, David Crouch demonstrates that his role was rather limited. It was that of a facilitator and negotiator on behalf of his King. This was despite having been ill-treated by King John and his lands and vassals in Ireland were even attacked on the orders of the King, he does not ever seem to have joined the rebels.

This brings me to what was certainly the most interesting and fascinating component of this very rich book. Through the multiple and dramatic events in which he took part, and thanks to the careful and considered analysis of David Crouch, the character and personality of the man tends to appear. He was far from perfect. Despite his reputation of loyalty which, in some cases at least, seems to have been richly deserved, there were other instances where his choices and decisions happen to suit her personal interests. Above all, he seems and is shown throughout this book as being a man of his times, although one that was more successful that most of his peers, both in accumulating land and in accumulating fame and reputation, and it is in showing this that David Crouch has been so successful.

Five stars.
5 people found this helpful
|22 Comments|Report abuse
on 8 May 2014
If your into your history and are interested in the time of the Plantagenets, this book is very informative on the man people have called The Greatest Knight. William Marshal was quite a man who went from being a son of a low ranked Barron to being The Earl of Pembrook Regent of England. He lived through some very historically interesting times amongst some very historically interesting people.
A good read.
|0Comment|Report abuse
on 17 November 2009
This book is well worth any price you are willing to pay. Obviously, this is not a translation of the original biography written about William Marshall, but rather a well-researched précis of it. The original was written shortly after William Marshall died and, probably because of that, it could be regarded as being completely correct. However, parts of it may well not have been - bearing in mind the original was commissioned by Marshall's sons and would have been sympathetically written. This book questions the original in parts, and gives a more truthful account of what probably occurred - using knowledge the author has gained through extensive research of other documents temp to the time. Consequently, this book is full of unique information which can be trusted - and not only concerning the knight himself. You will find information here about many individuals from the noble families of the era. You will find details of many events occurring throughout William Marshall's comparatively long lifespan (for the violent times in which he lived. Having read and re-read this book, I now intend to keep it alongside me throughout my research into my own family, as a trusted reference. This is the area in which I find the book invaluable.
3 people found this helpful
|0Comment|Report abuse
on 1 February 2015
Very good book for anyone interested in this subject. Well researched, very knowledgeable author and well written. I would highly recommend this book. Well worth the price.
One person found this helpful
|0Comment|Report abuse
on 8 November 2014
Excellent source of historical references, new documentary research and a critical assessment of a major medieval figure. Good balanced account to weigh against popular historical novels.
One person found this helpful
|0Comment|Report abuse
on 23 May 2014
Superb book about a great historical figure. It left me wanting more What a great movie or mini series his life would make.
One person found this helpful
|0Comment|Report abuse
on 15 July 2014
This book was purchased as a gift for someone who admires William Marshal and feels he does not get the recognition he deserves. The recipient says it is well written, informative and correctly factual. In short - he loves it!!
|0Comment|Report abuse
on 18 January 2015
Well written giving an excellent insight to the period and the sub title.Liked the referencing to sources.Liked the portrait of William warts and all.
One person found this helpful
|0Comment|Report abuse
on 30 January 2015
A fascinating true story, wonderfully well written
One person found this helpful
|0Comment|Report abuse
on 8 February 2013
i thought it was great a history book which is well cited and reads like a novel, I cried at the end!
One person found this helpful
|0Comment|Report abuse