"An incisive, unpretentious, eminently readable commentary on the first seven years of new "Who". The authors' easy but lively discourse makes for a thought-provoking dialectic -- a joyful celebration of fan love. Unofficial episode guides don't come much more engaging than this." --Benjamin Cook, writer for "Doctor Who Magazine, "and co-author "Doctor Who: The Writer's Tale"
"concentrated commentary on the worlds of the BBC's "Doctor Who"." --"Two-Minute Time Lord"
"ECW Press has made some fantastic TV show companion books, and this is a great addition to their line-up." --Craig Byrne, "KSiteTv.com"
"This is one of the finer episode guides I have run across for any show, and highly recommend it for any fan of the ninth, tenth, or eleventh Doctor." --"Book Guys & Book Girls"
"From the most ardent devotees to new-on-the-scene followers, every fan has something to gain from this indispensable handbook ... a thought-provoking and educational supplement to the first six series of the re-launched "Doctor Who"." --Lacie Patterson, "Boomerocity.com"
"Who is the Doctor" is a strong addition to the many volumes written about the new show, and one that, I suspect, will be referred to long after the more cerebral analyses have faded into oblivion." --Paul Simpson, "Sci-Fi Bulletin"
""Who is the Doctor" offers additional depth to the series, partly by picking out the important (and the trivial) things that are done in each episode." --Steven Silver, "Steven Silver's Reviews"