What I Believe Audio Cassette – Audiobook, 1 Sep 1995
|New from||Used from|
Audio Cassette, Audiobook
Customers who viewed this item also viewed
What other items do customers buy after viewing this item?
Enter your mobile number or email address below and we'll send you a link to download the free Kindle App. Then you can start reading Kindle books on your smartphone, tablet, or computer - no Kindle device required.
To get the free app, enter your mobile phone number.
'Bertrand Russell wrote the best English prose of any twentieth-century philosopher.' - Anthony Howard, The Times
'Bertrand Russell attributed religion to a primitive terror of the unknown and the desire for a kindly older brother to stand alongside us.' - The Age --This text refers to the Paperback edition.
Top customer reviews
He seems highly inconsistent to me in two different senses of the word. Firstly, his musings are often inconsistent with reality, and secondly with each other. To give a simple example, Russell writes in his booklet What I Believe that scientific knowledge, in the sense of hard facts, is an essential ingredient for a 'good life'. Presumably life is better and better the more scientific facts are known. If we go the other way, it means that the fewer scientific facts are known, the less good life is. So presumably people living before the Enlightenment were condemned to a life of utter misery, seeing as they hadn't a clue about the "laws" of gravity, or quantum electrodynamics! What is clear from some modern studies is that whatever boons science and technology affords us today, we're no happier for it - that is, we're no more fulfilled as individuals or as a society.
Here's another example: "The whole effectiveness of any ethical argument lies in its scientific part, i.e. in the proof that one kind of conduct, rather than some other, is a means to an end which is widely desired."
It is obvious what Russell is getting at: if an action brings about a result that in generally the thing that people desire, then that is good. There are some obvious problems with this. Firstly, what is "widely desired" isn't necessarily "good". (Nazi germany suggests itself as a good example of my counterpoint.) Secondly, that a "scientific" aspect of something is deemed such according to whether or not it complies with what is "widely desired" is an audacious usurpation of the word "science"! Science does not hold public opinion as the arbiter of what is "effective". If we take my criticisms into account and factor them out of Russell's statement accordingly, something still survives, but it is rather useless: he is saying that the effectiveness of any ethical argument boils down to whether it is a good ethical argument or not. Well gee whizz. Who would have thought that!
Such problems continue throughout the book and at the end of it one is satisfied that the the book has explained what Russell believes (which is the claim in the title), but completely diappointed to learn that what he believes is such half-baked tripe.
I don't want to imply that Russell is utterly useless. He has produced some things worth reading. For example, on the topic of his atheism and the reasons for it, see his "Why I Am Not A Christian" book, which offers far more value for money. In fact, there is a sense in which I admire Russell for his stance on the First World War; he resisted it tooth and nail and, like most intellectuals who don't comply with the system, wound up in prison and lost his lectureship at Cambridge. Obviously, Russell is a man of some moral stature, but unfortunately this book does nothing for his reputation in my eyes.
This book is VERY short (about 40 pages), so keep that in mind too before you spend the full price on it.
Most helpful customer reviews on Amazon.com
I don't agree w/ that, as the criminal is guilty & the man w/ the plague is innocent. Personally, I believe that the punishment should fit the crime. However, I do think that Russel has a very interesting POV. What's done is done. The most rational thing to do now is move forward & help each man improve. Russell is all about peace & the greater good of society. Our instinct is to punish the criminal, but we would all benefit more from rehabilitating him.
And that's just one example of how Bertrand Russell makes you THINK.
Look for similar items by category