Buy new:
-38% £11.78£11.78
£10.56 delivery Thursday, 26 December
Dispatches from: Amazon Sold by: NorthCOURT Ind
Save with Used - Very Good
£6.80£6.80
£10.56 delivery Thursday, 26 December
Dispatches from: Amazon Sold by: superseller-uk
Download the free Kindle app and start reading Kindle books instantly on your smartphone, tablet or computer – no Kindle device required.
Read instantly on your browser with Kindle for Web.
Using your mobile phone camera - scan the code below and download the Kindle app.
Trans: When Ideology Meets Reality Hardcover – 15 July 2021
Purchase options and add-ons
THE SUNDAY TIMES BESTSELLER and a Times, Spectator and Observer Book of the Year 2021
‘In the first decade of this century, it was unthinkable that a gender-critical book could even be published by a prominent publishing house, let alone become a bestseller.’ Louise Perry, New Statesman
‘Thank goodness for Helen Joyce.’ Christina Patterson, Sunday Times
‘Reasonable, methodical, sane, and utterly unintimidated by extremist orthodoxy, Trans is a riveting read.’ Lionel Shriver
‘A tour de force.’ Evening Standard
Biological sex is no longer accepted as a basic fact of life. It is forbidden to admit that female people sometimes need protection and privacy from male ones. In an analysis that is at once expert, sympathetic and urgent, Helen Joyce offers an antidote to the chaos and cancelling.
- Print length320 pages
- LanguageEnglish
- PublisherOneworld Publications
- Publication date15 July 2021
- Dimensions13.46 x 3.3 x 21.59 cm
- ISBN-100861540492
- ISBN-13978-0861540495
Frequently bought together

What do customers buy after viewing this item?
Highest rated
in this set of productsThis item:
Trans: When Ideology Meets RealityHardcover£10.56 deliveryGet it as soon as Thursday, Dec 26Only 4 left in stock.Lowest Price
in this set of products
Best Selling
in this set of products
Material Girls: Why Reality Matters for FeminismPaperback£9.50 deliveryGet it as soon as Thursday, Dec 26




A liberal, secular society can accommodate many subjective belief systems, even mutually contradictory ones. What it must never do is impose one group’s beliefs on everyone else.Highlighted by 330 Kindle readers
Far more plausible is that puberty blockers, as well as blocking the physical changes that puberty brings, also blocked the developmental process whereby gender dysphoria often resolves.Highlighted by 310 Kindle readers
When women are limitless and formless, they can have no political demands.Highlighted by 282 Kindle readers
From the Publisher
Product description
Review
'A scholarly, compassionate and courageous examination of a subject that’s sparked an unhelpful civil war within the LGBTQ community. Unlike those of her online counterparts, Joyce’s arguments are well researched, soundly made and avoid the toxicity that mars so much conversation on this topic.’
― Observer, Books of the Year‘A frighteningly necessary book: well-written, thoroughly-researched, passionate and very brave.’
-- Richard Dawkins‘A courageous, intelligent and important work, rooted in good science and common sense.’
-- Jenni Murray'I'm off the fence...This rigorous and brave book nails the absurd idea that sex is just a “social construct”'
-- David Aaronovitch, The Times'A superlative critical analysis...With this fact-filled, humane, and brave book, a grown-up has entered the room.'
-- The Telegraph'Reasonable, methodical, sane, and utterly unintimidated by extremist orthodoxy, Trans is also a riveting read.'
-- Lionel Shriver‘Thank goodness for Helen Joyce… Trans is a searing and at times devastating analysis of an ideological shift that has had a profound influence on many institutions in the West… With the rigour of an investigative journalist, she looks at the history of the trans movement over the past century.’
-- Christina Patterson, Sunday Times'A tour de force. With a fine eye for detail, she brings all the elements of gender ideology together with clarity and precision...simply a must-read'
-- Evening Standard‘anyone wanting to understand how transgender rights became such a flashpoint in identity politics – and why a generation of feminists is so determined to stand its ground – should start here with this polemical book by Helen Joyce.’
-- Patrick Maguire ― Times, Books of the Year 2021'An intelligent, thorough rejoinder to an idea that has swept across much of the liberal world seemingly overnight. Even those outraged by Joyce’s positions would benefit from understanding them...Open conversation about such fraught issues is the only realistic path forward.'
-- Jesse Singal, New York Times'A passionate defence'
― Financial Times‘Incisive, compassionate and nuanced…In the first decade of this century, it was unthinkable that a gender-critical book could even be published by a prominent publishing house, let alone become a bestseller.’
-- Louise Perry, New Statesman‘I was knocked out by Trans… Biology vs magical thinking has become such a violent debate that most people involved (myself included) can’t set verbal foot in it without effing and jeffing till the air is blue. But Joyce is always cool, calm and in complete possession of her extensive collection of facts.’
-- Spectator Books of the Year'A sane, humane book.'
-- Daniel Dennett, author of Consciousness Explained‘There are few subjects which need treatment that is at once delicate, thoughtful and brave. Helen Joyce manages all of these things in Trans. Anyone looking to understand this most fraught of issues should start here.’
-- Douglas Murray, author of The Madness of Crowds: Gender, Race, Identity'How do we want to live? How do we want our children to live? Helen Joyce tackles this matter. Buy her book for your teenagers. Give it to your boss. Send it to the head of HR. Place it on a bench at the Royal Academy. Sex matters. Tell everyone.'
-- The Article'Helen Joyce has written a very important, enlightened and powerfully-argued book on one of the most controversial issues of our times. For anyone who wants to understand the spirit of the age, its complexities and challenges, and how to map a truly progressive way forward. Riveting from start to finish.'
-- Matthew d'Ancona, Editor and Partner, Tortoise Media‘A searing analysis of the transgender debate that has dominated much of public discourse in Scotland in recent years, at least among feminists… I urge you to read Helen Joyce’s book… It may well offer you a new perspective on this most troubling of national conversations. It may even change your mind.’
-- Susan Dalgety addressing Nicola Sturgeon in the Scotsman‘This is the book every woman should read. It explains how we’re being erased, how our arguments are being distorted, and the cost of standing up...Brilliant, coruscating, brave.’
-- Joan Smith, author of Misogynies'The author brave enough to take on the trans lobby'
-- Mail Online‘If… you look to grasp the extent to which gender identity ideology, both academic and popular, bears comparison with the worst sort of pseudoscience, then Joyce is your pick… Perhaps because of her use of biology, Joyce’s feminism is disciplined and thoughtful… [a] careful use of science.’
-- CapX'Well-researched, compelling...a deeply compassionate reminder that there are real trade-offs to be made in human rights activism.’
-- Ayaan Hirsi Ali‘[Joyce] is sharp, lucid and brilliant in analysing how the recent surge of sexual ‘transitioning’ and insistence on self-declared ‘gender identity’, has undermined feminism’s achievements.’
― Spiked'The book I wish I’d had the foresight to pitch and the insight to write.'
-- Jo Bartosch, The Critic'An ambitious, wide-ranging, yet incredibly economical book… Trans is an enormously readable and widely accessible book, full of righteous anger and common-sense feminism.'
-- The Radical NotionAbout the Author
Helen Joyce is a senior staff journalist at The Economist, where she has held several positions, including Britain editor, Finance editor and International editor. Before joining The Economist in 2005 she edited Plus, an online magazine about mathematics published by the University of Cambridge. She has a PhD in mathematics from University College London. On Twitter, she is @HJoyceGender.
Product details
- Publisher : Oneworld Publications (15 July 2021)
- Language : English
- Hardcover : 320 pages
- ISBN-10 : 0861540492
- ISBN-13 : 978-0861540495
- Dimensions : 13.46 x 3.3 x 21.59 cm
- Best Sellers Rank: 267,055 in Books (See Top 100 in Books)
- 224 in Psychology & Violence
- 1,941 in Law (Books)
- 33,318 in Social Sciences (Books)
- Customer reviews:
About the author

Discover more of the author’s books, see similar authors, read book recommendations and more.
Products related to this item
Customer reviews
Customer Reviews, including Product Star Ratings, help customers to learn more about the product and decide whether it is the right product for them.
To calculate the overall star rating and percentage breakdown by star, we don’t use a simple average. Instead, our system considers things like how recent a review is and if the reviewer bought the item on Amazon. It also analyses reviews to verify trustworthiness.
Learn more how customers reviews work on AmazonCustomers say
Customers find the book easy to read and well-written. They appreciate the thought-provoking content and thoughtful writing style. The book provides a comprehensive overview of trans activism and its current state. Readers describe it as fair, balanced, and supportive of the rights of trans people.
AI-generated from the text of customer reviews
Customers find the book engaging and informative. They appreciate the author's well-informed, compassionate, and analytical voice. The book provides an overview of gender ideology and its impact in the real world. It is a good starting point for those looking to have an open mind.
"...A list of sources is provided to allow follow-up. It would have been nice to have an index...." Read more
"...Nit-picking aside, this is a brilliant book and everyone should read it, even if they're really wary of the whole debate - especially if they are..." Read more
"Everybody should read it. It is what it says, When theory meets reality." Read more
"...it as I write this, and I'm flying through it; it is accessible and informative...." Read more
Customers find the writing clear, concise, and engaging. They appreciate the author's down-to-earth style and well-presented arguments that are accessible to all readers. The book is a pleasure to read with no wasted words.
"...The book is easy to read and reflects the author's background as a journalist. A list of sources is provided to allow follow-up...." Read more
"...She's a very good writer, she explains everything in clear language that keeps you engaged...." Read more
"...Yet Joyce has taken on this job with rigour, clarity and at the same time compassion, to provide the reader with the facts he/she needs to form his/..." Read more
"...I recommend this book very highly. So readable and comprehensive...." Read more
Customers find the book's content thought-provoking and engaging. It provides a well-reasoned argument that brings together philosophical, biological, sociological, and political information. The book offers an excellent starting point for a balanced discussion and provides signposts to other resources. Readers appreciate the sensitive and supportive approach to the issues.
"Helen Joyce has produced a fascinating account of the way in which an activist lobby has largely captured the support of those who are terrified of..." Read more
"...It is absolutely nothing like this. The book is a carefully documented argument against extremism - that’s it...." Read more
"This is an excellent, thoroughly researched and well argued book on the big questions today about transgenderism...." Read more
"...It is fair, unbiased, sensitive and serious - and a gripping read." Read more
Customers find the book's writing style engaging and thoughtful. They describe it as clear, concise, and well-researched. The author writes with compassion and respect, focusing on women's needs.
"...This is where Helen Joyce's book comes in. She's a very good writer, she explains everything in clear language that keeps you engaged...." Read more
"...has taken on this job with rigour, clarity and at the same time compassion, to provide the reader with the facts he/she needs to form his/her own..." Read more
"This book is written by a clearly knowledgeable author with a clear and sensible view point...." Read more
"...Helen Joyce writes thoughtfully, humanely, clearly and courageously about a complex area that ultimately affects us all. Highly recommended." Read more
Customers find the book an excellent summary of the current situation with trans activism. They say it's supportive of the rights of trans people and supportive of debate and discussion. The book is well-researched and balanced, tracking the ideology from its roots to the present. It is written with compassion and respect, describing the current trans phenomena with much needed clarity.
"...word against trans people and over and again reiterates her support for acceptance and equality...." Read more
"...There is no 'transphobia' here. This is a book against transactivism - the specific set of policies and ideology being pushed by various activists..." Read more
"This book is not, I repeat, not transphobic...." Read more
"...to state right from the beginning that this book is not transphobic in any way whatsoever...." Read more
Customers appreciate the book's balance. They find it fair and clear.
"...Thank you Helen Joyce for your well-researched, well-balanced, and professional book...." Read more
"...It is fair, unbiased, sensitive and serious - and a gripping read." Read more
"...It should be read by anyone interested in truth and fairness – not just women’s rights and avoiding harm to children...." Read more
"...Measured, fair and clear." Read more
Customers appreciate the book's pacing. They find it clear and logical, with no emotional outbursts. Some readers describe it as disturbing, alarming, and reassuring, while others find it disturbing and devastating.
"This excellent book is a brisk, eloquent, no-nonsense and well researched demolition of the gender identity ideology which has captured public and..." Read more
"...I hope it is widely read. It has brought home to me, without any haranguing, only calm reason, lucid clarity and sharp data analysis, the extent of..." Read more
"...This book is an exploration in a humane, no nonsense way why the current ideological capture and conflating of the concepts of sex and gender must..." Read more
"Interesting and disturbing book. Well researched and written." Read more
Customers find the book brave and inspiring. It gives them the courage to question and challenge themselves.
"...is a very important case which is not over yet and she's an incredibly courageous woman, I was just a bit uncomfortable with the way Joyce left out..." Read more
"Really interesting book, so glad I bought it - really brave woman for speaking up against this poionous ideology" Read more
"...It has given me the courage to question and challenge with the ultimate aim of being considerate and compassionate to all...." Read more
"This is a brave and well written book...." Read more
Reviews with images
Everyone Should be Reading this Book to Understand the Topic
-
Top reviews
Top reviews from United Kingdom
There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.
The book is easy to read and reflects the author's background as a journalist. A list of sources is provided to allow follow-up. It would have been nice to have an index.
There are disturbing accounts of the aggressive treatment meted out to those who even dare to raise these topics. It is disturbing that people seem to feel that no holds need to be barred if the victim can be characterized as a bigot. The response to JK Rowling's measured contributions was appalling. It is an indication of the unfortunate effects of this bullying that there are so many examples of institutions withdrawing invitations and even issuing groveling apologies for imaginary "harm".
Some hardline radical feminists seem to dislike men on principle, and reserve particular animosity for transgendered biological males who they see as trying to invade "womanspace". For example they consistently "misgender" transwomen and refer to them with male pronouns. This book is free of this tendency and anyone claiming it is "transphobic" has not read it carefully.
At least one review on the internet has made much of an insignificant detail. The platypus is considered a mammal and lays eggs rather than producing live young. The lineages producing live young - marsupials (kangaroos) and placental mammals including humans - have been around for about 160 million years. Of course this is entirely irrelevant to the biological fact that reproduction in humans and related animals involves the fusion of a large egg - produced by females - and a small motile sperm produced by males. These are the only two possibilities and claims that "sex is a spectrum" require a redefinition of "sex" to be a synonym of "gender" which is itself considered as a subjective internal feeling which escapes definition except in terms of stereotypes.
.
It takes a certain amount of courage to even begin learning about the different arguments in all this - we are frequently told that even asking questions is transphobic. If you do dip your toe in you can quickly become lost in a fog of queer theory where everyday words have topsy-turvy meanings, and a sea of disinformation and unsupported, extraordinary claims.
This is where Helen Joyce's book comes in. She's a very good writer, she explains everything in clear language that keeps you engaged. She provides evidence to back up all of her arguments.
Two small nit-picky points with this book -
The main one is that she seems to date women's fight-back from Maya Forstater's employment tribunal which first made the news in 2019. Women have been resisting this ideology for much, much longer than that. The earliest reference I can find is Jean O'Leary's 1974 speech at the Christopher Street Parade (precursor to Pride) but I doubt she was the first. Even in recent years there was a lot happening before Forstater, especially around the GRA consulation. Maya's is a very important case which is not over yet and she's an incredibly courageous woman, I was just a bit uncomfortable with the way Joyce left out so much about earlier actions by equally courageous women (mostly lesbians) who do not have the same kind of establishment acceptance as Joyce or Forstater.
The second one, which is REALLY nit-picky, is that she described the retweet that got Harry Miller into trouble as 'doggerel'. It was actually a song lyric and most song lyrics come across as doggerel if taken out of context and read as poetry. It was from a song by Ali Bee - look her up on YT, she's great!
Nit-picking aside, this is a brilliant book and everyone should read it, even if they're really wary of the whole debate - especially if they are wary. Go on, put it on your kindle, your virtue-signalling friends and colleagues won't even know.

