Learn more Shop now Shop now Shop now Shop now Learn More Shop now Learn more Shop Fire Shop now Learn More Shop Women's Shop Men's

Customer Reviews

4.3 out of 5 stars
37
4.3 out of 5 stars
Format: VHS Tape|Change
Price:£12.95+ £2.80 shipping
Your rating(Clear)Rate this item


There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.

on 8 March 2016
Traces the lives of three soldiers ,one German ,two American during World War II.Black and white which was a classic of its time ,but has "dated" a little bit.The early scenes have echoes of From Here to Eternity on the American time -line.Brando is good,but mangles his German accent,.Montgomery Clift is intense anddean Martin is ,well ...Dean Martin ...always watchable.
0Comment| One person found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 29 May 2015
Very well written and constructed as a wartime romance epic goes. See Mai Britt in her most ravishing and persuasive role. Film's performance is embraceable because of it's attention to detail not always evident in other late nineteen-fifties films. And I found the dialogue memorially particular for its day. There's not much going on in it that you could regard as just matinee, and as far as presentation goes, it still delivers, so to speak, after all this time.
0Comment| One person found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 1 November 2000
Opening as Germany gears it's population up for war, The Young Lions charts the progress of three very different characters; Clift's Jewish 'Everyman', Martin's callow Broadway star and Brando's increasingly disillusioned Nazi ski instructor. There paths inevitably cross along the way, during the conflict, but that isn't the real story. This is truly, as all the great war films are, a story about the people, not war. We see racism amongst those on the same side, bravery, love... every gambit of the human character is played out by the three leads and those around them. Ok, the *very* final scene may be a little too schmaltzy, but the overall message is so strong that it hardly matters. Well worth watching!
0Comment| 14 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 3 April 2003
An admirable attempt to balance the human motivations on both sides. This film sticks in my memory as being one of the few that offered something of a balanced view - although there is still A LOT left unsaid. At least, we don't get the one-dimensional sadist Nazis and actually are allowed to empathise with real people on both sides. What a change from the unsubtle propoganda that typifies a thousand other "great" war films where every victim of atrocities is a faultless hero.
0Comment| 14 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 3 May 2004
A very deep war-drama that shows real people with their own individual stories on both sides in WW2. Similar to "All Quiet on the Western Front" about WW1, it is surprising to think of German soldiers as distinguishable individuals with their own thoughts, fears and motives. It is a lot more difficult to make a film this way about WW2 than it is about WW1 because it is impossible to sympathise with Germany. This film is based on a deep novel and, needless to say, the acting (esp. Brando's) is perfect. Even though I don't want to see anything good in German soldiers in WW2, they were, afterall, individual people and this movie, like no other, shows it very well and makes the best out of it.
0Comment| 16 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 24 December 2012
Enjoyed it so much didn't realize we were watching a black and white film. The picture quality was remarkable, forget colour and blu ray its the story that matters. The story was good showing the human side of what happened in those dark years. Marlon Brando played a fantastic part as a German officer. Our only small complaint was it went on a bit too long, could have been a little shorter.
0Comment| 2 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
Heavily diluting Irwin Shaw's doorstop novel about two American soldiers and one Nazi whose paths gradually converge over the years from 1939-45 into an expensive but mostly not very good, often surprisingly studiobound CinemaScope soap opera, 1958's The Young Lions delivers a lot less dramatic weight than you'd expect from a film featuring both Marlon Brando and Montgomery Clift.

The two stars only encounter each other in the film's last couple of minutes and don't even share a scene, but there's little doubt that if they did it would have been Brando who would have walked away with it, and not just because he has the most interesting character. Despite looking every inch the blonde Aryan ubermensch, his Christian is a much more sympathetic creation than the character in Shaw's novel, here a somewhat naïve believer in the Nazi Party who is gradually disillusioned and destroyed by the brutality he sees in service that takes him from Paris to North Africa and, ultimately, a near-abandoned concentration camp. In the novel Christian remained an unrepentant Nazi to the end, killing Clift's Jewish soldier before being killed himself, but the novel changes him from bully into victim in what would become the clichéd screen image of `the good German' who doesn't realise what the Nazis really are until it's too late (a change that infuriated Clift). Yet Brando, playing his part softly, manages to convince in a way his co-star never does, especially in his early scene when he tries inarticulately to explain to an American girl why he thinks the Nazi Party is a good thing for Germany.

Sadly there's no doubting that the film's biggest liability as far as casting goes is Montgomery Clift, delivering one of the worst and most inappropriately amateurish performances you'll ever see from a great actor. Even allowing for the effects of the accident that left half his face paralysed, he's hopelessly miscast despite the role being reduced to little more than a variation of his From Here to Eternity persona: looking much older and frailer than his years, it's impossible to believe he's the young A-1 soldier other characters talk about. It's hard to tell whether he genuinely improves in the second half of the film or you just get used to the array of clumsy mannerism and inflections he adopts: certainly his last big speech is a painful bit of curiously underpowered overacting. Knowing that Clift felt it was his finest screen work and was certain it would land him an Oscar only makes it seem all the more painful. By contrast, Dean Martin's less prominent role as a Broadway star pulling strings to stay out of the front line who befriends him is much more convincing. Maximilian Schell, sounding curiously like a young Alan Arkin, also makes an impression as Brando's ruthless immediate superior, as does Parley Baer as Christian's bon vivant friend.

George Stevens had tried to make the film years earlier, and he'd probably have done a better job of it than Edward Dmytryk who, post-blacklist, directs like a man who isn't taking any chances and who doesn't want any trouble. It's very much an old-school, rather stolid production for much of the running time, with limited location work in Europe and stock newsreel footage mixing less than convincingly with overfamiliar standing sets on the 20th Century Fox backlot.

There are moments when the picture briefly sputters into life: a sequence of triumphant Nazi soldiers swarming over the steps of the Sacre Coeur in Paris like flies on a sugarlump as they take tourist photos of each other; an uncomfortable walk through a small town as Clift's prospective father-in-law who has never even met a Jew is forced to face his own anti-Semitism; Brando walking through the decimated streets of a blitzed Berlin; and an encounter with a self-justifying concentration camp commander who prides himself on being a good soldier (a scene somewhat compromised by half of his dialogue being dubbed by a French actor and the rest played in his own thick German accent). Certainly there is enough to make the film worth watching despite the not always convincing romantic subplots - Dean Martin and Barbara Rush's being particularly confused and underwhelming - but nowhere near enough to make the film live up to its potential, let alone become the `most revered film of this generation' that the film's laughably hype-heavy trailer promised.

Aside from trailers for other Fox war films (including a bizarre DVD trailer for Tora! Tora! Tora! designed to make it look like Pearl Harbor!) the only extra on the Region 1 NTSC DVD is that over the top original trailer for the film, which spends almost as much time promoting producer Al Lichtman as it does the cast or the film!
0Comment| 3 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 5 June 2011
Saw this film around 1959, aged nine & with my mum in a small cinema in Birch Lane, in Bradford, West Yorks as the main feature after the obligatory 'My Friend Flicka', 'Bugs Bunny' and chewing on a quarter of Midget Gems. Even at that age I was mesmerised by this drama (& terrified of what lay under the bandages of Brando's wounded fellow officer). Some years later I got the same feelings of the helplessness of men (& women) in war when I saw Carl Foreman's 'The Victors'- especially the deserter's execution, the racism to fellow soldiers & the (to me at the time )shooting of the pup. More modern films may have more gritty realism but only certain ones affect one with what I associate personally as a need to leave the cinema in silent, respectful reflection, oblivious to the cacophony of others around me. Others like this have been 'Soldier Blue' 'Saviour' (Dennis Quaid),the disturbing Russian film 'Come & See' & the recent harrowing but true 'City of Life & Death'.

See 'The Young Lions', look beyond the obvious aged method acting & film techniques -just concentrate on the story of these three different charactors. Ignore the schmaltzy 50's Hollywood ending which only exists in the film.

Do what I did - buy this old classic, enjoy it for what it is and then go back to Amazon and order the brilliant original book by Irwin Shaw and get a feeling for American war literature at its best which equals Dalton Trumbo ('Johnny Got His Gun')& James Jones (The Thin Red Line, Whistle, From Here to Eternity).

p.s after the film show which cost my mum 1/3d for her seat & 9d in old money for mine, we'd walk home eating fish & chips for the grand sum of 1/0d (one shilling -=5p) each - great days in which we were poor but went to the pictures twice a week giving me a lifelong love of cinema & Yorkshire Haddock! Can't afford these outings anymore but God Bless Amazon for helping me relive these times with a bottomless choice & excellent service.
regards from darlingbehomesoon
0Comment| 5 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 27 July 2016
Having remembered the film from my youth, apparently my memory was faulty.

Marlon Brando, as an actor and certainly a star was very good, given the limitations of the character he portrayed. Aside from that, the other actors - stars, and the story itself was truly unworthy of them all.

The sequence of events from start to finish was not only illogical and unbelievable, it was uninteresting. Monty Clift was truly miscast, Dean Martin was charmless - and even Brando was put into situations that challenged credibility.

The best thing about the film was the title, even though it had virtually nothing to do with the story. The production of the film had obviously been interfered with far too much. What a shame.
0Comment| 2 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 4 September 2014
This is a very excellent movie about the second world war it last 2 hours and 45 minutes. Several events are located on different places in North Africa and some places in Europe. We have been sitting all the time of the evening with our complete family in the living room to watch this movie on television 40 years ago.
0Comment| 2 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse

Need customer service? Click here

Sponsored Links

  (What is this?)