Shop now Shop now Shop now See more Shop all Amazon Fashion Cloud Drive Photos Shop now Learn More Shop now DIYED Shop now Shop Fire Shop Kindle Shop now Shop now Shop now

Customer Reviews

3.6 out of 5 stars
8
3.6 out of 5 stars
Your rating(Clear)Rate this item


There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.

on 24 July 2006
This book, like its main protagonist, contains at least two stories in one. Ostensibly it is about the collapse of the old familair European world and the birth of the historical and political movements that would shape our century. But at its heart is the tale of a wandering Jew and a love story.

Early on in this compelling book Reiss writes of how Lev Nussimbaum (a.k.a Essad Bey, a.k.a. Kurban Said) despairs over the forces of revolutionary change-Bolshevism- began by transforming the human face into a grimace. For a man so obsessed with masks and shifting identites this is a telling comment.

The life and times we are drawn into -brilliantly retold by Reiss- is the story of the escape and exile of the prolific and bizarre writer, Lev Nussimbaum. The world into which he is born into is one that will become hardly recognizable as it is increasingly determined by history and biology (Communism and Fascism), the ideologies of class and race that would devastate the continent. Lev, like all escape artists, seeks to avoid any such fixing of identities or loyalties and this is what makes him such a complex character.

Along this journey from the 'wild west', oil-rich city of Baku to the cabaret of Weimar Germany we are introduced through a series of skethces to a whole host of strange and eccentric characters: Viereck, the writer and Nazi sympathizer, Ernst 'Putzi' , Hitler's Harvard-educated press secretary, Baron Omar-Rolf, Erika Lowendahl, a Jazz-age poetess whom Lev marries, Varian Fry whose mission it is to save two hundred of Europe's top intellectuals and artists from the grip of the Nazis and Italo Balbo, founder of the Italian Air Force who sets up a futurist experiment in the deserts of Libya.

But the real star of the story is, of course, Lev and this is oin no small part due to the fact that his protean , ambiguous nature of his character deeply resonates with our modern sensibilities. Was he a Jew or a Muslim?, a supporter of Mussolini or of the monarchy, a traditionalist or just a hopeless dreamer?

There is no doubt that Lev felt pangs of nostalgia for the old world; this is made clear in some intriguing chapters where his enthusiasm for the 'wild jews' of the Caucasus or his admiration for the silent infinites of the Turkmenistan desert , or his love affair with the lost splendour, the "fallen greatness" of the muslim world are made apparent.

But he was, if anything, a revolutionary conservative whose place was the "radical centre" and not on either 'side' of the 'left'/'right' divide that would tear Europe apart. In the collision of the old and new worlds, East and West, perhaps Lev's charm was in that his real loyalty was to his imagination.

As a Jew Lev must have felt the world closing in on him with the advancement of the totalitarian ideologies. Reiss doesn't cover much new ground here but it is interesting nevertheless. In some sense, Lev's partiality to monarchism was understandable. The Empires-by their sheer persistence over time- came to represent the natural order of things, a relaxed tolerance toward difference (Constantinople here being the best example)and a space where "one could be left alone". If anyhting, it was modern totalitarinaism with its absolute power to define people that was the 'closed world'. Indeed, Lev's nostalgia for the passing world is that for "the best face of Europe which was a raiant, carefree, cultivated countenance..light as a feather."

There a number of parallel stories running through this book and they raise issues that will strike us as of immediate relevance. For example, amongst the array of details that Reiss weaves into the story is the growth of the Freikorps who with their anarchic violence are the precursors to the revolutionary insurgents that we hav ebecome all too accustomed to in this day and age. We also come across Russian emigres and instinctively wonder what would have happened had the 'beautiful souls' won and not the Marxists. The latter represented, in some sense, another victory of the west (materialism) over "the East". Equally troubling is the portrait of the nihilism and aimlessness in German cities. This is apoint that the anthropolgist Hugh Brody and the sociologist Z.Bauman would agree upon: the city-dwellers are the new nomads .

And when we read of the Emerency act of 1919 to counter-act the 'threat from the East' we are immediately drawn to the State of Exception in our own times.

At the centre of this book, then, is the remarkable and captivating story of a person who has deep sympathies-like other Jewish orientalists- with the profound pluralism of the old world (European and Muslim, East and West). Perhaps this is a story for our times. Ina world that is increasingly being driven into exclusivities: 'us OR them' perhaps the story of Lev offers the opportunity of bridging such artifical divides...us AND them perhaps?

But even if we put the politics of it to one side we are left with an account of an attractive style of soul. It is what Reiss calls 'Zweieinsanikeit'- "grace-filled dual solitude".
0Comment| 19 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 30 March 2014
I enjoyed this book. I do not feel however that it proved at all that Lev nussimbaum wrote "ali and nino."

I enjoyed the book for the rambling stories of 20's and 30's Europe and a range of interesting characters
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 30 September 2007
For those who loved 'Ali and Nino' this biography of Lev Nussinbaum is a must. The poor man was always in the wrong place at the wrong time but this makes for a fascinating story. My only quibble would be that Mr Reiss digresses too much. He often abandons his subject to discuss the wider intellectual, political and cultural developments of the period. Only some of this is relevant to Nussinbaum, and even if all of it is very interesting, it often left me feeling frustrated. The material is well-covered by historians of the period, and Reiss would have done better to cut it out. On balance, though, I still think this book is a triumph.
0Comment| 3 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 27 July 2016
Somewhat long-winded, but otherwise fascinating account of a time and place gone forever. Despite the protagonist being a complete fantasist, Reiss somehow makes him a sympathetic character.
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 3 July 2013
An interesting story. A good read, although not sure if it is fact or fiction. Filling in on some history details in an area which has continued to be important in the modern world
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 24 May 2015
What a wonderful research into the life of Lev Nussimbaum (Kurban Said - Essad Bey) I love it
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 3 May 2007
I found this book to have a very interesting beginning but then it tailed off in the second half. I enjoyed hearing about the subject's journey in Central Asia and later from there to Europe in the early 1920's. However the latter part of the book dragged a bit all the more so as I am not overly familiar with Central European cultural figures (writers poets etc)of the 1930's and I feel the author assumes the reader has a certain familiarity with such people. Overall though I am gald to have read the book and compliment the author on the no doubt thorough research that he must have done to write this book.
0Comment| One person found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 20 July 2006
Although he would clearly make a wonderful subject for a book, very little of this book is actually about Lev Nussimbaum. Instead we are served-up endless pages of "background" - and basically anything else the author can dig-up and shoehorn-in on European cultural and political history between about 1917 and the second world war. Despite recognising that Nussimbaum's own autobiographical reminiscences can be highly misleading (a cynic might indeed see strong links with Munchausen) the author then uses his writings uncritically as his main (at time only) source. Impossible to know whether this was from ignorance or laziness. The author clearly conducted a number of interviews - he is only too eager to "drop" the names of the "great and good" with whom he spoke and the bibliography runs to an impressive 27 pages yet whole aspects/years of Nussimbaum's life are skipped-over. As a trivial example despite describing at some length Nussimbaum's first year at school on a German island (the material drawn entirely from his own writings) the author notes that Nussimbaum himself never named the island and leaves matters there. It took me about an hour to identify both the island and presumably the school.

Interestingly the author makes little attempt to quote from Nussimbaum's writings (other than his autobiographical works or the over-rated "Ali and Nino") which are at times both incoherent and rambling.

There are a number of (albeit) small historical errors and considerable political bias. Still, we are told that the heir to the Ottoman Empire (sic) catsat the author's tomcat - and that is clearly what was important.

Thin and disappointing. There was possibly enough material for a magazine article and the author would have been well advised to stop at that point.
0Comment| 8 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse

Customers also viewed these items

£14.95
£0.99

Need customer service? Click here