- Also check our best rated Children’s Book reviews
Swallows and Amazons Paperback – 16 Jul 2010
|New from||Used from|
Customers who bought this item also bought
Customers who viewed this item also viewed
Enter your mobile number or email address below and we'll send you a link to download the free Kindle App. Then you can start reading Kindle books on your smartphone, tablet, or computer - no Kindle device required.
To get the free app, enter your mobile phone number.
What other items do customers buy after viewing this item?
Top customer reviews
There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.
There is not really a plot. The action is centred on the 'conquest' of Kanchenjunga (the Himalayas were a big focus for expeditions at the time when Ransome wrote this -- 1931), a sprained ankle, hurried meetings between the Swallows and the Amazons and a race at the end after the successful repair of the Swallow.
Along the way, however, we meet a few rustic characters -- the charcoal-burners and some members of the Swainson family. Ransome, while he reproduces the manner in which they speak, in no way paints them as yokels but as sympathetic characters in their own right. And this is one of his many strengths as a writer and as a human being.
I like Ransome's ability to capture what it is like to be young and to portray this in the spectacular scenery of the Lake District. Most of all, I admire his skill, which he has in common with authors such as E Nesbit and Kenneth Grahame, in being able to write for all children between the ages of 7 and 90 without ever once talking down to them.
As for youngsters messing about in boats and 'wild camping': it is a great shame that it cannot happen so freely these days. Mrs Walker and Mrs Blackett would no doubt be prosecuted by the social services, who would not only get hold of the wrong end of the stick, but it would be the wrong stick entirely.
The story tells of the crew of the Swallow, 4 children visiting the Lake District on a summer holiday. In front of them lies a lake to explore and enjoy. The children's father is overseas on a naval trip so the family have boating in their blood. The 4 draw on their knowledge of exciting places far away to name the locations, adding more glamour to their spots on the lake. These places are generally pretty well-known with perhaps the exception being the Peak of Darien which is unlikely to be known by a modern young reader or listener.
Darien is far from the only challenging description in the book. There are so many nautical terms which are all used correctly but which just are not part of common parlance any more. Ransome writes for a readership perhaps more suited to tales of adventure on the high seas where young people might have aspired to glorious sailing expeditions. Nowadays that is a pretty niche area and so nearly 90 years after original publication, the gap between the narrator and the reader has grown tremendously.
Indeed there is a sense that the world of Swallows and Amazons has disappeared somewhat in the intervening period. The prospect of young children being allowed to camp out by themselves on a small island in the middle of a lake harks to a golden era of childhood that few now living will have been part of. Perhaps in a way this is the glory of the tale in that it describes what childhood should be like more than what it actually represents.
The adventures the children have are nicely couched. They are not too scary for a young audience but carry some excitement. The side expedition into a gypsy camp is fascinating and the battle with Captain Flint is wonderful to read as is the exciting way Titty takes on the Amazon.
The Amazons are a surprisingly modern rendition of girls. The two girls who crew the Amazon are just as brave and adventurous as any of the boys in the story, perhaps even more so. The Amazons are a fun foil for the Swallows in that they have similar aspirations and worldviews but have the added advantage of knowing the area much better.
The relationship between the children is heavily hierarchical in that the younger ones follow the orders of the older ones. The gender roles are interesting though because the most assertive characters are probably the Swallows and Titty rather than the boys. Indeed the only characters who are treated as less capable are the baby who does not join the adventure and the youngest boy Roger.
The distinction the characters make between "natives" and the shipmates is excellent even if it has colonial overtones. In a childhood adventure, those who are not part of the group are most definitely the other and that extends to members of the crew's family and friends.
While it is definitely a classic and a great yarn filled with childhood adventure, the writing of Swallows and Amazons is pretty tough going. The actions are detailed intricately. This slows the pace down greatly and means not much happens for long periods of time. Ransome labours heavily through the work with far too many words explaining what are often pretty throwaway things. There are benefits to this approach in teaching some of the theory behind the way things work but that is not the same as being exciting and is not really how children learn best most of the time.
Equally the book is not especially attractive. The cover of the 2012 edition is pretty ugly. The interior sketches are at best skeletal and worst terrible.
Overall, Swallows and Amazons is a dense book that over-describes its detail but at heart holds within it the glory of what childhood is supposed to be. There is a good reason this is considered a classic and it is the kind of gentle adventure a young reader or audience can enjoy without trouble. At over 500 pages of pretty dense text though it is a heavy read and at times not the easiest to get through.
On their first outing of the year, an accident befalls the Swallow, the dinghy adopted by the Walkers, leaving them having to take on the role of shipwreck survivors. Meanwhile the Amazons are beset with family duty. Their great aunt, who brought up their mother and Uncle Jim (better known as Captain Flint) has returned to the family house, and Nancy and Peggy are required to be on their best behaviour which means acting like young ladies rather than running wild and wreaking havoc in their customary tomboy way.
Ransome’s writing is as masterful as ever, combining superb children’s adventure stories, in excellent clear prose, while managing to eulogise the pursuit of an outdoor life without ever sinking into sanctimony. His own imagination was clearly powerful, and he imparts this enthusiasm to his characters, both adults and children. He never patronises the children, either the characters or his readers. Widely read himself as a boy, he clearly expects a similar literary background from his readers.
Like John Buchan’s novels, written at similar times, Ransome’s books are easily parodied now as representing a very middle class, anodyne perspective on life. That is, however, unfair (both to Ransome and to Buchan). They both wrote with effortless lucidity, and understood the nature of adventure. The Walkers are certainly middle class, but the children all interact perfectly politely and naturally with all the ‘natives’ (i.e. locals) whom they meet, including farmers, charcoal burners and loggers. There is never any hint of awareness of any class divide.
Arthur Ransome’s books do hark back to a different world, on that is now long gone, though I suspect that that was true even at the time they were first published, between the World Wars. Like Buchan, he may be invoking a golden or Corinthian age largely of his own imagining, but that does not make the books any less magical. Well over forty years since I first read it, ‘Swallowdale’ remains a delight.
Would you like to see more reviews about this item?
Most recent customer reviews
and i really recomend it to you and it's a amazing for kids . amazing book !!!
written by Anna age 8 years old