Shop now Shop now Shop now  Up to 70% Off Fashion  Shop all Amazon Fashion Cloud Drive Photos Shop now Learn More Shop now Shop now Shop Fire Shop Kindle Shop now Shop now

Customer Reviews

3.6 out of 5 stars
109
3.6 out of 5 stars
Your rating(Clear)Rate this item


There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.

TOP 50 REVIEWERon 27 February 2014
Alain Guiraudie's film is a challenging but memorable experience, and bold in more than one sense. There is the graphic sexual content, which seems to push the boundaries of what can be shown in commercial cinema, but more shocking than this is its Genet-like exploration of a character who seems drawn to danger and gets caught up with someone to whom he feels a very strong attraction to in spite of the very real risk this represents. Commercially, it is also bold in that it has no music from the first frame to the last; in fact there are no opening credits, even. Guiraudie shows the idyllic quality of the lakeside setting in hot weather, with the light varying at different times and acting as a clock in the film; in fact it is the viewer who becomes a sort of sundial - which is quite important in the thriller-like context that is set up. This beauty is set against the world of gay cruising and the electric current of desire, which different characters deal with in different ways - it is like a microcosm of life but shot through this narrow prism, as we never leave the lakeside or surrounding woods, nor are there any female characters. Aside from the main character, Franck, and the object of his obsession, Michel, there is a third main character, Henri, who seems to stand aside from it all, enigmatic, kindly (you sense), and hard to fathom. It is he who gives the film its most memorable aspect, perhaps. Above all, it is a highly interesting piece of filmmaking, very original (although Guiraudie has mined a similar theme in his other film Ce Vieux Reve Qui Bouge, 2001). It is a bit like Chabrol's Le Boucher in its rural setting, theme of a serial killer and slow pacing, crossed perhaps with Cruising, set in a concrete world that is poles apart. There is also something of Genet's moral compass, as said above, and a nod towards another French film from the 80s, Claire Devers Noir et Blanc, about a sado-masochistic relationship, that has never resurfaced on DVD. As happens to a key figure in this film near the beginning ...
0Comment| 31 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 22 February 2014
This film explores the varying intensity of relationships between men who meet up at the lake in Southern France. It is a a quiet spot, a beautiful sunny location and no more than about a dozen men sit far apart on the stoney beach. The entire movie is shot on this lake shore. The nakedness is total and close up but necessary to display the stark reality of these locations which occur throughout the world yet seen by few. Nothing coy here.
The men glance at each other especially when a new one arrives from the car park nearby. Quiet signals of interest (or not) are exchanged and those who want a quick fix walk casually into the nearby wood followed by the camera quite often to engage in physical intimacies.
There are essentially about 5 characters in the film - a young gay man (Franck) in search of lots of sex but much more, another man (Michel) in search of sex at all costs ( and I mean ALL), a straight divorcee (Henri) who spends his days yearning for an escape from his loneliness without being physical about the form the escape takes, there is a young guy (Pachal) who pays the ultimate price for his jealousy and there is a police inspector who is there seeking hopelessly to unravel the mess which slowly unfolds as the story reaches its climax.
Lots of graphic close up gay sex- these parts were performed by doubles. The ending is thrilling - of Hitchcockian dimension. The final battle occurs in the young man (Franck's) mind between intense desire to find Michel again and the risk of death itself in a darkened forest.
0Comment| 32 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 3 July 2014
When I first saw this movie in the cinema I believed it would be dramatically cut in the DVD version due to the graphic adult content, and consequently would suffer the same fate as many other excellent foreign films by having its' story obliterated by the UK censors, but I was surprised to discover that the disc version is absolutely faithful to the original cinema presentation, so full marks for the enlightened response to this excellent French thriller by the BBFC.
0Comment| 11 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 5 March 2016
Nicely acted and directed. Interesting use of the car park to denote time passing. Plenty of tasteful man on man action in the bushes. Shows how easily we could be ruled by our emotions overriding common sense as Franck throws caution to the wind in accepting a sexual relationship with a murderer. It is implied that the murder was committed so that the murderer could be free to gain the love of Franck. A very mysterious ending, not really satisfactory, I wanted a resolution.
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 28 December 2013
Ah, sweet revenge! This movie is payback to every gay man who ever had to sit (and who hasn't?) through 20 minutes of graphic straight sex for every 2 minutes of chaste gay sex in an American movie. There's not a heaving breast anywhere!

It's an all-male cast, and they're nearly always naked - REALLY naked, not the coy, fig-leaf male nakedness 99% of American movies (even the gay movies) dole out as if it were toxic (in contrast to female nakedness, which they shove in our faces all day long). The only problem here is the shaved pubic hair, which is a HUGE turn-off.

I thought the creepy, shaved-pubes look was restricted to gay-for-pay porn stars and West Hollywood gym bunnies, so it makes me really sad to see it even in rural France where this movie is set. The creepy hairless epidemic must be sweeping the whole civilized world. They say circumcision is a crime and then they shave off the pubes! It's crazy.

ANYWAY, there's lots of dick, and lots of sex in this movie, and it's not always simulated. Some will call this porn, but it's not. Some will call it a thriller, but anybody expecting white knuckles will be badly disappointed.

There's a murderer, but there are no big shocks, no frantic chases, nothing out of Hollywood's bag of stock thriller tricks. The movie is as languid and easy as the warm summer days it depicts (but sometimes it does get a little scary in the woods after dark!)

There are no sets, no special effects, and not one note of music. The whole movie takes place outdoors, in and around a beautiful man-made lake (lac de Sainte-Croix) in the foothills of the Alps, on a remote beach where gay guys go to swim, sun their shaved pubes and cruise the wildlife.

Besides all the sex, there's a nice friendship between the main character and an oddball straight man who hangs out there for his own, totally harmless reasons. And there's some really funny dialog about giant catfish that may or may not live in the lake.

Pierre Deladonchamps is fantastic as Franck, the main character, as is Patrick d'Assumçao as Henri the straight guy. Christophe Paou is good as the subtly sinister murderer Michel - and he is identified early, so I'm not spoiling the story for anybody who hates spoilers.

I think I can safely say this is unlike any movie anybody has ever seen before. I liked it a lot.
11 comment| 37 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 15 June 2014
STRANGER BY THE LAKE [2013] [Blu-ray] Utterly Gripping and Absorbing . . . One of the Year’s Best! Beautiful, Sinister, Frightening, Erotic!

Summer time. A cruising spot for gay men seeking nameless sexual encounters is tucked away on the shores of a picturesque secluded lake in rural France. Franck is an attractive young male who falls in love with Michel, a striking, extremely potent but lethally dangerous man. Franck has witnessed this first hand, but his desire for Michel knows no bounds, this is a relationship he must have - at any cost.

‘STRANGER BY THE LAKE’ is a tense thriller set against the secluded back drop of, what becomes inevitably, the most dangerous lake in France.

A provocative and accomplished effort by France's bad boy auteur, ‘STRANGER BY THE LAKE’ is Alain Guiraudie's steamy mix of the comic and the tragic, winning Best Director for Un Certain Regard in addition to the Queer Palm at the 2013 Cannes Film Festival.

FILM FACT: Awards: 2013 Cannes Film Festival: Won: Best Director for Alain Guiraudie. 2014 39th César Awards the film was nominated for eight César Awards and with Pierre Deladonchamps winning the award for Most Promising Actor. The film was filmed using body doubles. Alain Guiraudie and the actors came to the decision that they would be uncomfortable filming the scenes themselves. The film was shot at the Lake of Sainte-Croix in Provence, France in September 2012.

Cast: Pierre Deladonchamps, Christophe Paou, Patrick d'Assumçao, Jérôme Chappatte, Mathieu Vervisch, Gilbert Traina, Emmanuel Daumas, Sébastien Badachaoui, Gilles Guérin, François-Renaud Labarthe, Claude Bellelle, Slawomir Cieminski, Jean-Marie Crémier, Bernard Delavaux, Bernard German, Jean-Michel Giordano, Lucien Lerda, Patrick Marconi, Serge Morgadinho, Eric Piccolotto, Corentin Plas, Renaud Rifflart, Thomas Salles, Nicolas Guimbard, Joël Landaraud and Alain Guiraudie (uncredited)

Director: Alain Guiraudie

Producers: Benoît Quainon, Gilles Sitbon, Olivier Père and Sylvie Pialat

Screenplay: Alain Guiraudie

Cinematographer: Claire Mathon

Video Resolution: 1080p

Aspect Ratio: 2.35:1

Audio: French: 5.1 DTS-HD Master Audio and French: 2.0 LPCM Stereo Audio

Subtitles: English

Running Time: 100 minutes

Region: Region B/2

Number of discs: 1

Studio: Peccadillo Pictures

Andrew's Blu-ray Review: In ‘STRANGER BY THE LAKE [French: L'Inconnu Du Lac], a suspense thriller from the French director Alain Guiraudie, we get the measure of the lake itself soon enough. It's a wide, chalky basin somewhere in the south of France, with water as hot and blue as a June sky. It's also a gay pick-up spot, where men sunbathe, swim and chat, before disappearing into the surrounding scrub.

This mesmerising feature from French writer-director Alain Guiraudie is a mix of Hitchcockian potboiler and queer-culture study. Our lead is buff Franck [Pierre Deladonchamps], who struts with confidence around the lake that is the film's only location. Franck becomes fast friends with lonely, obese Henri [Patrick d'Assumçao], but his libido is more tickled by '70s-porn-moustache-sporting Michel [Christophe Paou]. Guiraudie has a keen eye for queer conduct: he spends most of the first half hour acclimating us to this Eden where gay men lie around nude and sneak off into the woods for sex, before offering a deeply unsettling exploration of infatuation.

This provocative setting is ideal for Alain Guiraudie's story, which is an exploration of fear and longing, and the ways in which those two seemingly opposing forces often work in deadly unison. The men here are essentially strangers, but at the same time they're hair-raisingly intimate, and their encounters are shown in explicit detail. The BBFC report warns of "strong, real sex" and we aren't disappointed, on either count. The film leans a bit heavily on long takes, but there's a purpose to Alain Guiraudie's rigorous perspective. He's out to unearth the powerful, often terrifying emotions which underlay all explicit acts, sexual or not.

One of the regulars is Franck [Pierre Deladonchamps], a limber youngster, who notes one morning the arrival of a new man, Michel [Christophe Paou], who has a cruel smile, a thick moustache, and the physique of an Olympic swimmer. Franck is intrigued, and lingers in the bushes that evening to spy on him playing in the water with a third man who appears to be a romantic partner. As Franck comes to learn, death and love make consummate bedfellows.

What happens next could be considered a plot-spoiler, so I won't detail it here, although Alain Guiraudie captures it in an unbroken, indelible four-minute shot, where the action moves from the far distance to the foreground while the camera looks on with a paralysed steadiness worthy of Hitchcock.

Franck's response to what he sees is complex: from an earlier conversation about contraception, we already know that sex and risk are closely aligned in his psyche. Two days later, he strikes up a relationship with Michel. The day after that, a police inspector comes to ask questions about what may or may not have happened that night, and the lake's status as a set-apart place, with its own opaque codes of maleness, comes under threat.

Alain Guiraudie's film is acutely brilliant on the funny, scary machinery of desire, and how easily humans can get caught up in its cogwheels. There are no female characters and the camera never leaves the lakeside, but despite the picture's resolute closed-offness, the gist is universal. It's categorically not for the faint-hearted, but the good ones never are.

Blu-ray Video Quality – With its 1080p brilliant encoded transfer, ‘STRANGER BY THE LAKE’ is one of the best-looking discs to come from Peccadillo Pictures. While most of this likely has to do with the fact the the film premiered in 2013, it shouldn't take anything away from how strikingly detailed and consistent the image actually is. Much of the film takes place during bright summer days, and the image captures the essence of the setting with tremendous amounts of detail. One can practically count the rocks on the beach, if they were so inclined. Additionally, facial features and other textures are all on display and though clothing is something of a rarity for this film. Colours are consistently vivid, and manage to capture the bright lushness of the lake's surrounding woods. Contrast remains incredibly high throughout the film producing full-bodied black levels and whites that never look overblown. Certain night scenes do tend to take on an overwhelming inkiness, but that seems to be deliberate on behalf of the filmmaker, as it adds a great deal to the tension of the situation. All in all, this is a fantastic looking disc that rarely has a misstep of any kind. Please Note: Playback Region B/2: This will not play on most Blu-ray players sold in North America, Central America, South America, Japan, North Korea, South Korea, Taiwan, Hong Kong and Southeast Asia. Learn more about Blu-ray region specifications.

Blu-ray Audio Quality – The French 5.1 DTS-HD Master Audio mix is also quite good. The mix isn't tasked with doing much other than making sure the dialogue is clean and easily heard which it does with great ease here. The sound is primarily loaded through the front, as dialogue spills through the centre channel while various ambient effects are filtered through the front and rear channels as needed. There's little that is obvious about the mix, so sounds are generally floating between channels, generating an effortless immersive experience that highlights the sounds of the lake, the breeze blowing through the tall grass, and the voices of the eternally present others floating around the background. This is a quiet film that makes pointed use of every bit of dialogue and sound effect, so that they are distinct and purposeful. It's not going to be used as reference for anyone's next demo, but it certainly goes above and beyond in terms of setting the tone of a wonderful film.

Blu-ray Special Features and Extras:

Special Feature: Interview with Alain Guiraudie [Director] [2013] [1080p] [16:32] Alain Guiraudie is recorded at the 2013 Melbourne Film Festival. The director is extremely prepared to chat up "Stranger by the Lake," delving into a sophisticated explanation of his moviemaking approach, with emphasis on theory, form, and inspiration. While more textured anecdotes are more inviting. Alain Guiraudie displays a rich understanding of his work, sharing his creative intent with authority in this passionate conversation that's punctuated with clips from the feature. French Language with English Subtitles.

Special Feature: Interview with Christophe Paou and Pierre Deladonchamps [2013] [1080p] [30:15] Here we get a chance to get an in-depth intimate interview with the two main character actors. We get to hear the actors explaining all aspect of the film and how they went about creating their characters. What was so refreshing is how very frank they were when it came to the sex scenes and held nothing back. What was also really nice and surprising is that they wanted to only speak in English, which is sometimes very rare, but of course they both have very heavy French accents, which were really nice, but most surprising of all, is that both actors are completely straight.

Special Feature: The Cannes Première [2013] [1080p] [16:33] this is a short documentary, showing all aspects of the 2013 Cannes Film Festival event. You get short interviews with different people involved with the film, plus small extracts from the film, with people explaining in depth of what is happening in that particular part of the film. The main part of this short documentary is with everyone on the Cannes Stage and the Director making short speeches, as well as seeing the audience appreciating all the people involved with the film who attended the première. French Language with English Subtitles.

Special Feature: Creating The Poster: Commentary by Roy Genty [Artistic Director] [2013] [1080p] [6:42] Here we get to hear Roy Genty explain how he went about designing the different Film Posters, and how he eventually came to designing the actual poster advertising the film. French Language with English Subtitles.

Special Feature: Les Heros Sont Imortels [Heroes Never Die] [13:28] is a 1990 short film from Director Alain Guiraudie concerning the evening conversation shared between two men as they wait patiently in a town square. French Language with English Subtitles.

Special Feature: Tout Droit Jusqu'au Matin [Straight Ahead Until Morning] [10:14] is a 1994 short film from Director Alain Guiraudie, this time exploring on the philosophical inner monologue of a man touring a city at night. French Language with English Subtitles.

Special Feature: 3 Deleted Scenes [2013] [1080p] [4:19] here we get three additional moments focusing on Franck's adventures around the lake, interacting with Henri and being chased away by other men in the area. The final scene is perhaps most important, spotlighting a discussion of protected sex between Franck and a more attentive conquest that should've remained in the picture. French Language. English Subtitles.

Special Feature: Alternative Ending [2013] [1080p] [9:20] presents two takes that essentially extend the theatrical ending to a more defined resolution, while still preserving needed ambiguity. This is only a subtle change, but it does alter the tone of the climax, gifting the feature a more sombre quality. French Language with English Subtitles.

Special Feature: BFI London Film Festival Gala Q&A [2013] [1080p] [14:14] Here we get to see the 3 main actors and the Director [speaking only in French]. You also have 2 other people on the stage speaking in English. One of them was a woman who had to translate into English what the Director was explaining, especially from specific questions from the audience, which unfortunately you can't quite hear what they are saying.

Trailers: Peccadillo Pictures promotes some of their other Blu-ray releases, which includes: ‘Interior Leather Bar;’ ‘Our Children;’ ‘I Am Devine’ [Infamous American Drag Artist]; ‘North Sea Texas;’ ‘Weekend;’ ‘You and The Night;’ ‘Free Fall;’ ‘In the Name Of’ and ‘Boys on Film 11.’ For more details, check out the Peccadillo Pictures web site.

Finally, although certain elements of ‘STRANGER BY THE LAKE’ suggest it might fit into the subgenre of homoerotic. As to the film itself, is more concerned with the idea of a subgenre itself, or, in this case a small microcosm like the populated by the men gathering at the lake for bouts of passionate, anonymous sex. For the film to also feature a compelling thriller aspect seems to suggest that Alain Guiraudie is also interested in examining what constitutes desire, especially when it becomes unquenchable, reckless, and even illogical. This is very captivating film, that features terrific picture, very good sound, and a host of informative extras that gives a glimpse into the mind of the director. This is a definite high octane tour-de-force gay film, that was so amazingly good, which has a refreshing no holds barred action, and whose characters are fascinating to watch and get into their characters and is definitely for repeat view and I am so pleased to add this to my ever extensive Blu-ray Collection and is also a must buy, if you want to see something really different and keeps you guessing right to the very end, then this is the Blu-ray disc for you. Highly Recommended!

Andrew C. Miller – Your Ultimate No.1 Film Fan
Le Cinema Paradiso
WARE, United Kingdom
0Comment| 2 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 26 June 2014
The film's good and has a cute storyline. There are more than one endings on the bonus stuff - I think they chose the right one for the released film.
Under correction, I got the impression that it may have been marginally censored for the UK market - I look forward to hearing if I am wrong.
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 7 December 2014
When 'straights' make a film about gays, the first thing they do is appear before the cameras months in advance insisting in many ways that of course they are not themselves gay, good heavens no. None of the principals - actors, director, producer etc - are gay and none of them knows anything about the gay scene. As well as being tedious and empty as a film, it is saturated with homophobic clichés. To confirm all this, the dvd has foolishly included a protracted interview with the director, whose banality, self-regard, pretentiousness and limited imagination are all painfully exposed. Avoid.
33 comments| 8 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 5 June 2014
Beautiful film to look at , the panoramic views of the lake and surrounding hills were lovely, but the main core of the film boiled down to what is love? and knowing when it occurs. This aspect of the film I felt went part of the way but fell short trying to decide which way the lead character would react to a specific situation. The sexual interaction may be classed as pornography but in the context they were valid and not gratuitous. A film for perhaps the those who like art house etc.
0Comment| One person found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse
on 21 April 2016
Despite some people's long winded positive reviews with a deep deep meaning to the movie, I think it was the biggest load of rubbish I've watched in a long time. Sex scenes performed by body doubles, sex scenes their for shock factor. They didn't bring anything to the story at all.

I'm gay, I've cruised so not exactly a prude. Just think if you want that you'll watch porn. Not some movie pretending to be something it's not.

Don't get the character and the fact he witnesses a guy murder/drown someone then decides the next day to start a sexual encounter with him. Didn't help or call police, no just decide to have sex. It's not plausible and the inspector is a joke.

Only decent thing was the lake/scenery. Ridiculous ending to movie and after ten minutes of practically black screen. Obviously what some people called atmospheric...

This one's for the ageing queen who wants to sit and get of on a crap soft porn movie with absurd script.

Some people's reviews sound ridiculous, sounds like they are writing a review to a different movie or their review SOUNDS AS PRETENTIOUS AND SELF INDULGENT AS THE MOVIE WAS!!!!!! '
0Comment|Was this review helpful to you?YesNoReport abuse

Customers also viewed these items


Send us feedback

How can we make Amazon Customer Reviews better for you?
Let us know here.

Sponsored Links

  (What is this?)