The Restored Finnegans Wake (Penguin Modern Classics) Hardcover – 5 Apr 2012
|New from||Used from|
Customers Who Viewed This Item Also Viewed
Enter your mobile number below and we'll send you a link to download the free Kindle App. Then you can start reading Kindle books on your smartphone, tablet, or computer - no Kindle device required.
Getting the download link through email is temporarily not available. Please check back later.
To get the free app, enter your mobile phone number.
About the Author
Danis Rose is principal editor of the forthcoming critical edition and electronic hypertext of Finnegans Wake. His publications include The James Joyce Archive: Volumes 28-63 (New York, 1977-78; with David Hayman and John O'Hanlon); The Index Manuscript (Colchester, 1978); Understanding Finnegans Wake (New York, 1982, with John O'Hanlon); The Lost Notebook (Edinburgh, 1989; with John O'Hanlon); The Textual Diaries of James Joyce (Dublin, 1995); and Ulysses: A New Reader's Edition (Mousehole, 2004). He was born in Dublin, where he now lives.
John O'Hanlon has collaborated with Danis Rose in most of the Joyce-related projects undertaken by him, in particular in the preparation of the extensive electronic hypertext of Finnegans Wake. His expertise is in mathematics and logic, and he has been primarily responsible for the origin (or adaptation) and coherence of the programs and protocols essential to Rose's hypertext constructions.
What Other Items Do Customers Buy After Viewing This Item?
Top Customer Reviews
1. As so many guides to the book refer to it, it would surely have been better to paginate the book as that of the original Faber edition. It would also have been easier to see just what has been changed. In a book as dense as FW and unless the correction is obvious (as that to 'The Ballad of Persse O.Reilly (pg 35 Faber pg 44)) it is well-nigh impossible to recognise them.
2. The typeface chosen is poor and is very tiring on the eye. With such a dense novel as FW, which is difficult to read anyway, the reader needs a larger, clearer typeface than we are given here. To be fair, when Faber reset the book the print became even smaller and virtually unreadable and that is probably why most readers seek out second hand copies of the earlier editions (which do have an errata at the back).
3. A list of the amendments and page alignments as appendices would have been helpful. Perhaps that is forthcoming as reading this edition means that the guides which refer to the pagination of the early Faber edition are now defunct.
4. As many readers of the Wake annotate their copies (I use the Faber 1959 edition which is covered in notes) it would have been preferable to print on the left hand page only and leave the right hand page free for notes (or vice-versa for left-handed readers).
5. The cynic in me does wonder whether, given that the novel is available on Kindle very cheaply and for £1.99 from Wordsworth Classics, the timing of this issue is a cynical attempt to re-establish copyright through a new text (the composer Stravinsky was rather good at this creating new (reduced- or re- orchestrations) 'versions' of his early music to lengthen copyright).Read more ›
Let me first of all address two points raised by Richard W. Cowdell in his review. Richard asks whether "the timing of this issue is a cynical attempt to re-establish copyright through a new text." As Richard points out, there are far cheaper versions of the text available by now, probably because Joyce died in 1941 and copyright of published works expires after 70 years. Yet I doubt that Rose's edition is likely to represent an organised effort to somehow establish a "new" copyright. Up until the beginning of this year, copyright of "Finnegans Wake" was with the James Joyce Estate, with which Rose has been involved in a lengthy court case over his 1997 edition of "Ulysses" (ultimately forcing him to reverse a number of amendations in the 2004 reprint of that edition). Presumably, to cooperate with Rose would be the last thing the Estate would intend to do if they wished to prolong their influence on the availability of "Finnegans Wake." Similarly, the last thing Rose would want to do would be to have this edition officially acknowledged as a new version in the sense of a new text. (For in that case, the Estate might sue him for basing his emendations on material not contained in the 1939 edition, but only in galley proofs, drafts, and manuscripts, for which copyright has not expired yet.Read more ›
Joyce has thrown all of Mankind's manifest gods/deities/idols into FW, in reading FW like circumambulating the Kaaba's 360 idols, each reader/critic will find their own manifest god and if enlightened move on to the Unmanifest.
Joyce's Ulysses (is the story of a young man) whose framework is Homer's Odyssey: a tale of Modern-day Odysseus' personal existential/sexual quest overcoming his psychological internal travails (not Odysseus' external travails) affirming humanity (the fundamental family unit: the father, mother, son, and daughter). Joyce's FINNEGANS WAKE (is the story of a mature man) whose framework is Giambattista Vico's "La Scienza Nuova's" 4 stages of history (cyclic): theocratic to aristocratic to democratic to chaos (followed by Joyce's God "thunderclap") which ends chaos and restarts the world again with theocracy.
Both FINNEGANS WAKE (FW) and Ulysses are situated in Dublin (Ireland) and though both books were written on the European continent, Joyce memorializes his birth home. FW is Joyce's continuation of Ulysses on a grander scale: Bloom becomes All-Men (HCE) and Dublin becomes the World. Joyce's Ulysses (Bloom) is an energetic man hopping out of bed, plunging into the Dublin day, waging battles real and unreal, exhausted by controversy and rejuvenated by love (Molly). Joyce's FINNEGANS WAKE is man (HCE) ever-living, man of all wisdom, man of all compassion, man of all understanding, man of all time - Joyce's FW protagonist is Finnegan, who (re)incarnates to HCE, who will (re)incarnate to Shem and Shaun.Read more ›
Most Recent Customer Reviews
The book was a gift, and I think the content was okay to the receiver. But I never come to like modern binding trying to look more traditionel than it is: a paperback dressed up as... Read morePublished on 17 May 2013 by Erik Strid
Seamus Dean, in his Introduction states his astonishment that we finally "have a critical edition of Finnegans Wake" yet he later states that we need "to break out of our critical... Read morePublished on 1 Dec. 2012 by Onomacritos
Agree with previous reviews. The Penguin and previous editions of FW had the same pagination. 169 is my favourite chapter in most of Joyce. Read morePublished on 23 April 2012 by Mr. C. Johnson