Quilombo dos Palmares: Brazil's Lost Nation of Fugitive Slaves Paperback – 15 Jul 2014
|New from||Used from|
- Choose from over 13,000 locations across the UK
- Prime members get unlimited deliveries at no additional cost
- Find your preferred location and add it to your address book
- Dispatch to this address when you check out
Enter your mobile number or email address below and we'll send you a link to download the free Kindle App. Then you can start reading Kindle books on your smartphone, tablet, or computer - no Kindle device required.
To get the free app, enter your mobile phone number.
About the Author
Glenn Alan Cheney is the author of more than 25 books of fiction and nonfiction, hundreds of articles, and many op-ed essays, short stories, and poems.
Most Helpful Customer Reviews on Amazon.com (beta)
The author knows how to write and how to make history come alive. Very good at synthesis and painting the "big picture;" dry wit abounds. Those Americans who try to claim that African slaves had it good might want to read this to get their minds right. And those Brazilians (Gilberto Freire etc.) who tried to claim that Brazilian slavery was benign should have thought of the story of Quilombo dos Palmares and its inhabitants before expounding their theories.
There were a couple of typos in the first edition but apparently these have been corrected.
Brazil seems to have been the Western Hemisphere center of unusual subcultures tucked away in the jungle or elsewhere in the backlands. Canudos (see Os Sertoes), colonies of Russian immigrants, a "Little America" created by US Southerners after the Civil War, etc. Quilombo dos Palmares is among the most fascinating and tragic.
Very little scholarship has been done on Palmares. Cheney is familiar with what scholarship there is, and additionally has pored over colonial documents of the time—the records of the expeditions and correspondence related to the problem (from the authorities’ point of view) of Palmares. Unfortunately, no Palmarian records remain, and, to date, no archeological evidence.
This is a big problem: Palmares appeals for all kinds of reasons. It’s a powerful, rich symbol. And yet it’s almost impossible to get at its reality. As Cheney points out, the seventeenth-century records he relies on are written with an agenda: to simultaneously vilify the Palmarians, appeal to superiors for funds and support, and paint themselves in as good a light as possible. At times this could mean downplaying Palmarian successes; at other times it could mean exaggerating the threat. It has to have been something of a significant threat, or at least annoyance, because the Portuguese monarch himself sent letters addressing the leader of the Palmarians. But how numerous were the Palmarians, in actuality? Were they a unified state, or not? The expeditionary forces mainly described villages that they came upon after the inhabitants had fled; one vivid description of a flourishing town was written up by someone who’d never been there, with no mention of where the information came from.
For me, the most interesting portions of the book were the portions where Cheney talks about these problems and about the history of Palmares-of-the-imagination, Palmares as inherited through stories passed down for generations, Palmares as alive today in the struggles of the dispossessed. History is written by the conquerors, but a different story may still be told by survivors and their descendants and sympathizers, and in the chapters “Digging for Truth” and “Quilombo Forever,” Cheney reflects on this, and on the rights and merits of different types of histories.
The central portion of the book, chronicling the various unsuccessful campaigns against Palmares, was more frustrating for me than not, despite Cheney’s engaging writing style. So much of it can only be speculation, and the value of the sources themselves, as truthful accounts, is suspect: I think I would have preferred a shorter book that settled for an overview and summary. Cheney’s decision to cover each one is deliberate. In the preface he says,
"In my hope of writing the most comprehensive history of Palmares, I decided to retain this information. It will seem excessive to many, perhaps useful to a few."
Maybe so—but can it count as a comprehensive history when much of it is speculation? And yet, while falling in the camp that found the information excessive, I appreciated, after the fact, that I had ended up with much more sense of colonial dynamics and the various characters and personalities involved than I would have if Cheney had followed the advice of the editors he consulted.
In spite of my dissatisfaction with the central portion, I’d recommend Quilombo dos Palmares to anyone who’s interested in Brazilian history, colonialism, and the problems of historiography.
The early settlement of Peru by the Portuguese brought the enslavement of the native population as well as importation of African slaves. The Portuguese appear to have been barbaric slave masters, and many of their slaves ran away, preferring to take their chances in the jungle. There they build a series of villages and started their own state within a state. Their numbers may have been over 20,000, and they were soon raiding the Portuguese settlements for munitions and food. For almost 100 years they thrived until a particularly brutal commander and his mercenary army finally found their leader's fort and succeeded in routing them, capturing and killing many. This was the end of the end for the Palmeres state, though remnants survive to this day. This book was a fascinating exploration of the history of the early days of New World settlement, and I learned a lot that I had never known before. I highly recommend it.