Buy new:
-24% £8.31£8.31
FREE delivery 25 - 28 January
Dispatches from: Books from Norfolk Sold by: Books from Norfolk
Save with Used - Very Good
£3.57£3.57
FREE delivery 25 - 28 January
Dispatches from: Infinite_Books Sold by: Infinite_Books
Download the free Kindle app and start reading Kindle books instantly on your smartphone, tablet or computer – no Kindle device required.
Read instantly on your browser with Kindle for Web.
Using your mobile phone camera - scan the code below and download the Kindle app.
Quantum: Einstein, Bohr and the Great Debate About the Nature of Reality Paperback – International Edition, 2 April 2009
Purchase options and add-ons
- Print length480 pages
- LanguageEnglish
- PublisherIcon Books
- Publication date2 April 2009
- Dimensions15.29 x 3.05 x 23.39 cm
- ISBN-109781848310353
- ISBN-13978-1848310353
Frequently bought together

More items to explore
Product description
Review
This is about gob-smacking science at the far end of reason... Take it nice and easy and savour the experience of your mind being blown without recourse to hallucinogens -- Nicholas Lezard, Guardian
...the most important popular science book of the year. -- Bookseller
Kumar is an accomplished writer... In Quantum he tells the story of the conflict between two of the most powerful intellects of their day: the hugely famous Einstein and the less well-known but just as brilliant Dane, Niels Bohr. -- Financial Times
An exhaustive and brilliant account of decades of emotionally charged discovery and argument, friendship and rivalry spanning two world wars.' -- Steven Poole, Guardian
...it does provide a fresh perspective on the debate. -- Press Association
A dramatic, powerful and superbly written history. -- Publishing News
This is not an easy read. There are many concepts that... I could not come to terms with, but this is the biography on an idea and as such read much like a thriller. -- Ham & High
Quantum is a fascinating, powerful and brilliantly written book that shows one of the most important theories of modern science in the making and discusses its implications for our ideas about the fundamental nature of the world and human knowledge, while presenting intimate and insightful portraits of people who made the science. Highly recommended. -- Bookbag
'Quantum' is an interesting and informative read. -- Physics World
'That science is a many-splendored, sexy thing is the radiating message that comes out of this fabulous book...a pulsating narrative'. -- Hindustan Times
'Probably the most lucid and detailed intellectual history ever written of a body of theory that makes other scientific revolutions look limp-wristed by comparison'. -- Independent
One of the best guides yet to the central conundrums of modern physics. -- John Banville, The Age, Australia
About the Author
Product details
- ASIN : 1848310358
- Publisher : Icon Books; Reprint edition (2 April 2009)
- Language : English
- Paperback : 480 pages
- ISBN-10 : 9781848310353
- ISBN-13 : 978-1848310353
- Dimensions : 15.29 x 3.05 x 23.39 cm
- Best Sellers Rank: 139,185 in Books (See Top 100 in Books)
- 432 in History of Science (Books)
- 544 in Popular Maths
- 870 in Popular Science Physics
- Customer reviews:
About the author

Discover more of the author’s books, see similar authors, read book recommendations and more.
Customer reviews
Customer Reviews, including Product Star Ratings, help customers to learn more about the product and decide whether it is the right product for them.
To calculate the overall star rating and percentage breakdown by star, we don’t use a simple average. Instead, our system considers things like how recent a review is and if the reviewer bought the item on Amazon. It also analyses reviews to verify trustworthiness.
Learn more how customers reviews work on AmazonCustomers say
Customers find the book provides a coherent account of the history of quantum discoveries and debates. They describe it as an interesting and accessible read that is well-written and easy to understand. The book explores the personalities and collaborations of key scientists, showing them as human beings.
AI-generated from the text of customer reviews
Customers enjoy the book's account of the history of quantum mechanics. They find it coherent and well-written, presenting an engaging narrative with enough detail to understand the debate. The author weaves a compelling narrative that includes the personalities of the scientists involved.
"...This is a fantastic story about the rapidly emerging dangers of scientific progress and unintended consequences, The book reminds us that scientist..." Read more
"...helpful twelve page Timeline, a fourteen page Glossary, thirty three pages of chapter notes and a nine page Bibliography, all of which provide very..." Read more
"...Also the wider social history was well woven into the story, from the exclusion of German scientists from major international meetings after the 1st..." Read more
"...By Howard Jones This is a biographical history of the development of quantum mechanics. All the personalities involved are here it seems...." Read more
Customers find the book engaging and accessible. They describe it as a page-turner that covers interesting topics in an accessible way. Readers praise the writing style as well-crafted and consider it the best book of its length on quantum mechanics.
"...This was a review of the kindle edition, the book is highly recommended and would be a great gift for a young person thinking of a career in..." Read more
"...For anyone interested in the Quantum World, this is an excellent book which provides a detailed, academic history of the Quanum, Despite being..." Read more
"...I would expect interested physicists to find this a good read, but I am not so sure about the non-technical reader...." Read more
"...For what it sets out to do, this is an excellent book...." Read more
Customers find the book readable and engaging. It provides clear explanations of complex concepts without intimidating math. The writing style is easy to understand and the subject matter is presented in a concise yet detailed manner. Readers appreciate the author's skill in telling a fascinating story that is accessible even for those with limited math knowledge.
"...Manjit writes in a clear and easy to understand way...." Read more
"...a nine page Bibliography, all of which provide very useful guidance, clarity and further routes for enquiry. “‘..." Read more
"...The amount of mathematics in the book is trivial, for those who find the subject intimidating...." Read more
"...There is certainly nothing to complain about in the style, which is easy-going and readable...." Read more
Customers enjoy the book's character development. They find the personalities of scientists portrayed in the narrative fascinating and brilliant. The book blends biographical and historical information about many scientists with an explanation of their ambitions and intellectual struggles over decades.
"...The actors are mostly upper class, but not all, mostly men with the exception of Marie Curie a woman who remarkably won the Nobel prize twice...." Read more
"...It shows the egos, the fears, the ambition of these extraordinary people as the story unfolds over decades...." Read more
"This book is as much about a small group of highly talented scientists as the theories they developed, but it is above all a history of the debate..." Read more
"...Kumar takes a character-led approach to the story, using the personalities involved as the hook to lead the reader through the story...." Read more
Customers find the book engaging and entertaining from start to finish. It is well-written in an engaging style with a lively vibe. The account of an exciting period is interesting to them.
"...(I think it was Little Atoms), where he was very interesting and entertaining; and I have to say I was disappointed...." Read more
"...As a history of science it's second to none, but the highly engaging style and sequential unfolding of events adds to an understanding of quantum..." Read more
"...This book was the exception. It is very well written in an engaging style as a historical account of how quantum theory developed from the late..." Read more
"...this book does, so beautifully, is set that world within a play of engaging and diverse characters - Bohr, Planck, Einstein, Heisenberg, Born - all..." Read more
Reviews with images
A biography of quantum theory guaranteed to tele-transport you back to early twentieth century.
Top reviews from United Kingdom
There was a problem filtering reviews right now. Please try again later.
- Reviewed in the United Kingdom on 28 July 2011This book is brilliant. The book details the actors, the stage is Europe and America, The play is called ; "What is reality ?" The actors are mostly upper class, but not all, mostly men with the exception of Marie Curie a woman who remarkably won the Nobel prize twice. Many of the key players are Jewish. the average age of these quantum detectives is just, 24.
I found the Timeline at kindle location 6318, to be very helpful. The timeline is an important guide to the rest of the book. The story starts at the birth of Max Planck. on April 23 1858. Referring back and forth to the timeline. The timeline gives us a brief summary of the people, the events and the discoveries. After reading the timeline I then read in detail the rest of the book. I enjoyed reading about how Max Planck was involved in both the science and the politics of Hitler's Germany.
One gem, Max Planck at the age of 75, on May 16th 1933 attempted to convince Hitler that some Jewish people or scientists would be very useful to the Germany economy, however Hitler rejected the plea.
Before the two World Wars, Europe's top physicists were friends and colleagues. Then war split them into three groups one working for Germany, or working for the Allies and those who remained neutral. The book details how discovery after discovery snow balled the knowledge so much so that this is describe as the Golden age of physics. The discovery of the atom's nucleus and it's empty space by Rutherford and co at Manchester University, UK, with their gold foil experiment is my favourite. The American fission bomb came about as a result of Einstein lobbying the American president.
The letter Einstein sent to president Roosevelt about the new bomb had unintended consequences for Japan and the post war world. The dangerous knowledge about E=Mc2 and the huge amounts of energy that is locked up inside atoms, still hangs over mankind to this day. But if Einstein hadn't sent the letter, Hitler may have obtained nuclear weapons first. This is a fantastic story about the rapidly emerging dangers of scientific progress and unintended consequences, The book reminds us that scientist are often the slaves of tyrants and not saints. The book documents and pulls together information from a verity of sources into one place then debates it. The message, war and science are linked and that reality often forces us to choose between the lesser of two evils.
Hitler stopped the export of Uranium from mines in areas under his control, well before the start of the second world war. This indicated that Hitler knew about the new bomb. The book highlights that Hitler and Max Planck had some worrying links. Hitler was told about the destructive power of nuclear weapons before the second world war. I wonder who explained the fission bomb to Hitler? and I wonder if he
really understood what he was told?
Einstein was odd, with that hair and the trousers that were too short, yet he was one of the most remarkable men to have ever lived. This book is full of little details about his life. Einstein could have been accepted into the army, (he failed the medical) If he had been accepted, that would have changed world history. Franz Ferdinand's driver got lost in the back streets of Sarajevo, one wrong turn by his driver led to Ferdinand's death and that triggered World War one. You keep asking yourself as you read more and more, what is reality ? Quantum reality can at times be surreal like Schrödinger's cat, being both alive and dead, smeared over two states in a superposition of reality . Or like Salvador Dali's persistent reoccurring memory. (The painting with the melting clock).
Manjit writes in a clear and easy to understand way. I am interested in quantum entanglement, where two particles no matter how far they are apart from each other, are able to communicate information from A to B, faster than light speed. The fact that everything we see around us was at one point in time all inside one particle. And very entangled, then bang, all this that we know and see 13.5 billion years later was once inside that one small entangled super particle.
This book must be read in conjunction with other books. My other interest is in quantum computers. I love the book because it shows how the universe is hiding something from us ? We follow the bread crumbs and build machines like CERN then we find that there is more hidden, then even more.
My view after reading the book :
The greatest discovery will be the invention of a quantum computer, and quantum entanglement will be the way the QC computer will input and output data. It's the only way to side step the measurement problem.
A Quantum computer will be able to emulate a human mind. This will lead to "mind uploading". That means digital immortality. We are obviously living inside a giant quantum 3D computer construct now. To quote Dr David Deutsch "The universe is a giant information processing system". And we live inside it and it is inside another universe, Everett's many worlds theory, like those Russian dolls one stacked inside the other. I believe CERN, will decide (one day) that there is a Planck particle at the centre of all hadrons.
I believe that there is a tiny 5D black hole, A Planck particle at the centre of every hadron, it's obvious. It is the gravity particle. It grabs energy in proton to proton collisions, this has been observed at CERN and at Fermi Lab. Some energy disappears in all P to P collisions. Where does it go ? It transfers into another dimension or a new time and a new space, via the 5D, and it's singularity.
The proof that we live in a programmed world or inside a quantum computer universe is self-evident, in my view, look at anti matter and matter. The outer shell of the anti proton "knows" when it encounters a matter proton. It's surface is smart. Look at the energy needed to rip protons apart, atoms can be compressed with billions of tons per square mm and can withstand temperatures of hundreds of millions of degrees C and still remain integral. Yet the soft and gentle encounter with the anti particle and it rips the quarks apart. Why ? What is so powerful that it can un-zip the force that holds the quarks together ? What is the possible mechanism ? How do particles know what they are ? How do protons "know" that they have been observed ? It's a computer programme obviously. That's why Gold and Mercury being chemically only one proton different, have vastly different chemical properties, it's a programme. My opinion from reading this and other books.
Quantum physics makes no sense, if a man leaps over a 50 footwall in Grand theft auto we say it's a video game, it's impossible in the real world. What is the real world ? when an atom can be in two or more places at the same time ? The idea that if a particle act as we would expect, in a logical way, then it's reality is a fallacy. If reality has nothing to do with human logic. then the book's message is clear our logic is flawed. CERN is not looking with reality in it's eye. There is no graviton and no higgs particle.
What we see in the book is not logical, like Schrödinger's cat, (TE) we are programmed to look for false logic. This mental prejudice, that an atom must be in only one place, is common sense. Science discovered that this common sense works well for hunter gathers. Reality, must logically be independent of observation, energy could not have evolved into all that we see today if it were otherwise. The first ever event had no observer. An ultimate truth otherwise you would have a quantum chicken and egg problem ? Everything must have evolved from a first event.
In summary, consider when you place a powerful Trans cranial magnet behind your head your consciousness will fade away, move the magnet away from your head and your consciousness will return. what does that tell you ? Show me in the DNA code where, consciousness is coded? The soul is an electromagnetic ghost. It resides in a quantum computer made of atoms, called the brain, it's the most complex thing in the universe that we know of. Put the atoms in the brain in a blender after death, they can't support the soul or thought in their raw state, why not ? When the data ghost has gone, the soul has gone you cant just call it back. The universe is still hiding a lot from us.
I love the men and woman in this book who keep asking why? I ask myself : The body after death is no lighter, it weighs the same. Is death just a data event ? Flat bed F-MRI machines will be soon be able to scan the soul, the electromagnet ghost that is us, and upload it into a quantum computer for full emulation. If the universe is a quantum computer one of Everett's many worlds, and Dr David Deutch is right, souls will be recorded in TIME, in the universes reproductive software and that means souls can be resurrected. Can we find where the universe hides her data ? My bet, it is hidden in "other dimensions" or other parallel universes, or "Server farming in Everett's multiverse". A great title for Manjit's next book.
"What is reality"?
This was a review of the kindle edition, the book is highly recommended and would be a great gift for a young person thinking of a career in quantum computers. Anyone out there with a few million to invest in quantum computers ? I am free on weekends.
Paul Kendall (Leeds, UK)
- Reviewed in the United Kingdom on 10 April 2024In the week of Professor Peter Higg’s death (8th April, 2024), I bought this book and am very pleased I did. For anyone interested in the Quantum World, this is an excellent book which provides a detailed, academic history of the Quanum, Despite being published in 2009 with a reprint in 2010, it provides fascinating insights into this world, its events and the scientists involved.
It begins with the unique fifth Solvay Conference, held in Brussels from 24th to 29th October, 1927, a conference attended by twenty-nine of the leading scientists of the time, seventeen of which were Nobel Prize winners. In the case of Marie Curie, a double Nobel for Chemistry and Physics, a twin glass ceiling breaker who sits assuming in the front row conference picture.
Kumar takes the reader through the exciting (and shocking) history of science’s greatest and most puzzling discoveries, puzzling even to the greatest minds as they wrestled with the mathematics and experiments which explains our reality, provided us with a wondrous source of energy and created the world’s most powerful weapon of mass destruction.
Part One: The Quantum
Part Two: Boy Physics
Part Three: Titans scalar Over Reality
Part Four: Does God Play Dice?
There is a very helpful twelve page Timeline, a fourteen page Glossary, thirty three pages of chapter notes and a nine page Bibliography, all of which provide very useful guidance, clarity and further routes for enquiry.
“‘Princeton is a madhouse,’ and ‘Einstein is a complete cuckoo,’ wrote Robert Oppenheimer. It was January 1935 and America’s leading, homegrown scientist was thirty-one … Einstein accepted that his critical attitude towards quantum mechanics ensured that “‘here in Princeton I am considered an old fool.’”
A few letters later, a project in New Mexico and the world changed forever. This period and all the others from 1927 to publication date, 2007, are recorded in minute detail.
‘20?? - A quantum theory of Gravity? A Theory of Everything? A theory beyond the quantum? ‘
Ashtekar variables - the Spin Network. Theory of Everythng - working on it. Beyond Quantum - searching. Perhaps, in a few year’s time, Kumar will write Volume 2. IN the meantime, “Quantum” is a great read.
- Reviewed in the United Kingdom on 19 August 2009This book covers the early years of the development of atomic physics. As a scientist, I am familiar with the 'names' in this field via the equations etc named after them. However, I knew little of the detailed background to their personal contributions to this field, and I found the book absolutely fascinating. Indeed, I found it difficult to put down, as the narrative was so compelling that I was keen to know 'what happened next'. It was also remarkable to read that so many of the big names were making major contributions as graduate students or young researchers. Also the wider social history was well woven into the story, from the exclusion of German scientists from major international meetings after the 1st World War, to the impact of the Nazis on German science in the 1930s.
My main quibble with the book is the title: whilst the Einstein/Bohr differences are covered, the book is about so much more than this.
I would expect interested physicists to find this a good read, but I am not so sure about the non-technical reader. For instance, the independent development of Heisenberg's matrix mechanics and Schrodinger's wave equation, and their eventual correlation, was full of interest for me, but I wonder how compelling the differences between two abstruse theories would be for the reader without a technical background.
Top reviews from other countries
Martin XReviewed in Canada on 19 October 20245.0 out of 5 stars Science explained
Interesting read if you like physics!
Daniel PutmanReviewed in the United States on 8 March 20225.0 out of 5 stars Can the way we understand our world be applied to the quantum level?
The history of the development of quantum physics has been told many times, sometimes for the benefit of future physicists and sometimes more for the general public (as in John Gribben’s books). This book covers the same ground with two differences. One is that Manjit Kumar opts for a middle road in describing in more detail the history of the quantum. As in other histories, the same characters from Max Planck to John Bell are here with biographical sketches of each one in the text. But Kumar also presents more (not a lot) of the basic equations and more of the technical aspects of their work. Kumar does a fine job of digging into the details of the quantum revolution and the non-physicist can always gloss over the material he or she is not interested in. But, while the book is being sold as written for the general public and centered on the Bohr-Einstein debate about reality, it has more details than some readers may expect.
The second difference from other histories of the quantum is Kumar’s emphasis (as the title indicates) on the difference between Einstein and Bohr on how to interpret the quantum results. Einstein never denied the reality of the strange results but claimed the theory was “incomplete.” Do cause and effect function at all levels of the universe independent of our observation? Einstein never wavered in the belief that a complete theory of reality could be understood causally (the famous “God does not play dice” quote) and that the weirdness of quantum results would be explained by (or be a subdivision of) that larger more complete picture. Bohr’s claim was that the “quantum world” (he did not like that term) did not function in the same way as our everyday world. Trying to find a theory that encompassed both was pointless because causality as we understand it could not be imposed on the subatomic world. If, as some have claimed, we have to think causally to make sense of our world, then we are in principle incapable of “understanding” the quantum dimensions. What we are left with is the math and the usefulness (and strangeness) of the results of quantum mechanics, from transistors to computers. There is no point trying to subsume electrons or quarks into our classical way of understanding.
This is a fascinating debate and Kumar does an excellent job spelling it out when he gets there but he does not actually get there until two-thirds of the way through the book. When the Great Debate finally arrives, it is profoundly interesting. But the book’s title is somewhat misleading since the actual Bohr-Einstein debate is not sharply defined until Part 3, “Titans Clash Over Reality,” on page 251. Kumar covers a great deal of ground and his research is extensive. So, if the reader is looking for a book not just about the main debate itself but also a book with detailed background leading up to the Bohr-Einstein core disagreement, this book is ideal. I would then recommend it.
-
François PReviewed in France on 4 November 20195.0 out of 5 stars Très bon livre de vulgarisation scientifique
Livre que j'ai lu dans sa traduction française il y a quelques années et que j'ai eu envie de relire en anglais.
Cliente de AmazonReviewed in Mexico on 23 March 20175.0 out of 5 stars One of the best books about the history of Quantum Mechanics!
Very detailed narrative of the accounts of the quantum leap from classical physics to quantum mechanics during the first half of the XX century and beyond. One of the best books on the subject.
d k sarmaReviewed in India on 10 November 20165.0 out of 5 stars engaged the most intelligent and creative minds in the 1920's
This is one of the most absorbing books I have read and re-read.
The stubborn anomalies in theoretical physics that led to the concept of the quantum and the strange world it lives in, engaged the most intelligent and creative minds in the 1920's.The book describes the two protagonists, Albert Einstein and Niels Bohr, their lives and personalities,and of other massive stars in that illustrious galaxy-Rutherford, Heisenberg,Pauli,Scrodinger,Dirac,Born and a host of others who interacted with and influenced them.
The central argument was between Bohr and Einstein, about the model of the hydrogen atom that Bohr had proposed,and the intellectual dilemma that it presented; that some common-sense ground-rules of physics were being violated.Bohr built up an elaborate theory explaining the violations, which satisfied most of the eminent physicsts of the time, but not Einstein, who believed that "science does not work quite like that."The arguments of Einstein, and Bohr's counters themselves threw up numbers of new issues that physicists attached to Bohr's Institute at Copenhagen, and to those at Gottingen University (among others) immediately threw themselves.The resulting body of research resulted in the award of many of the Nobel Prizes for Physics awarded at that time.
To the end of his life Einstein believed that Bohr's theory did not completely capture reality, and to the end of his, Bohr regretted being unable to convince Einstein.
The arguments of and among these great personalities,and of their followers on both sides,their interaction with one another, their friendships,efforts, collaborations, jealousies and intrigues form the captivating material of this book, and must be read if one is to understand how modern physics was formed, evolved, and the personalities behind the great intellectual upsurge.
As expected, the book describes portions of the esoteric subject in terms that the layman can understand.It also pens portraits of the lives of the dozens of scientists involve, their triumphs, failures,accolades, and in many cases, their personal tragedies.Interwoven with this story is the turbulences of the times;the rise of the Third Reich and anti-semitism in Germany,and the First and Second World Wars.The treatment of the dramatis personnae is always sympathetic , the style of narration is lucid,yet gripping.







