- Paperback: 480 pages
- Publisher: Headline; New edition edition (21 Jan. 2002)
- Language: English
- ISBN-10: 0747262500
- ISBN-13: 978-0747262503
- Product Dimensions: 11.1 x 17.5 x 2.9 cm
- Average Customer Review: 4.3 out of 5 stars See all reviews (23 customer reviews)
- Amazon Bestsellers Rank: 604,268 in Books (See Top 100 in Books)
No Good Deed Paperback – 21 Jan 2002
Customers who bought this item also bought
What other items do customers buy after viewing this item?
Enter your mobile number or email address below and we'll send you a link to download the free Kindle App. Then you can start reading Kindle books on your smartphone, tablet, or computer - no Kindle device required.
To get the free app, enter your mobile phone number.
If you are a seller for this product, would you like to suggest updates through seller support?
No Good Deed begins with what most thrillers would have as their climax--undercover cop Orla McLeod talks a young boy into cutting her free to fight back as drugs race catastrophically through her system and a colleague is tortured to death in another room. Orla is a woman who keeps her promises, and she promised the child that she would look after him, forever--and this she does, though Hell stands in her way. In this radical break with the intense, but comparably gentle, detective stories with which she started her career, Manda Scott gives us a full range of thriller experiences--brutal noir as the police try to persuade Glasgow's criminals to give up a torturer gang boss of whom everybody is afraid, Buchanesque wanderings through the snow-covered foothills of a remote mountain district and a sense of growing dread as we struggle to understand what made Tord Svensen the vicious killer he is, what Orla will have to learn to defeat him. No Good Deed is a meditation on vengeance and violence and their costs, and what it means to walk away and make other choices; it is one of the most remarkable thrillers of the year. --Roz Kaveney --This text refers to an alternate Paperback edition.
Gritty, literate, and engaging, NO GOOD DEED is an exceptional achievement. Manda Scott is a fine writer, with a great future (Julia Wallis Martin)
'Uncompromising...brilliantly depicted' Gemma O'Connor
Compulsive reading from page one to the shattering conclusion...Manda Scott's writing is simply beautiful (Denise Mina)
Dark, taut and edgy, Manda Scott's debut thriller exerts an emotional grip that tightens to a twisting stranglehold. There's not a word wasted in this unflinching novel, which still manages to demonstrate the profound power of love. It's a joy to read something so intelligent, so direct and so beautifully crafted (Val McDermid)
Manda Scott picks us up by the scruff of the neck, drags us kicking and bumping along the rough side of life, then makes us fall in love with her characters along the way. Wow, just...wow (Laurie R. King)
`one of Britain's most important crime writers... the prose is sparse but descriptive and the plot is well handled... consistently entertaining' 2/2 (The Times)
delivers humane characters and supercriminals, romance without sentimentality, and adventures without easy answers. Orla McLeod's American debut ensures that she will take her place in the top ranks of fictional female detectives (Publishers Weekly)
Top Customer Reviews
There’s no way to get soft-pedal the sheer horror of the situation, and those of a sensitive nature must prepare themselves for a no-holds-barred read. Orla is touched by the plight of the child, and flees from the gang with another under-cover operative, Murdo. They think they are safe, but all bets are off when another of the team is killed. They hole up in the house of Orla’s mother in the Scottish Highlands, but there is a leak in the information that warns them that the unknown protagonist is still after them.
This thriller ratchets up the suspense to a level where you just cannot stop reading. However, there were, I thought, some implausibilities, such as the nine year-old being involved in the tense and violent denouement. Surely someone from social services would have intervened with such a young child involved? Still, it’s a cracking good read with several twists towards the end.
The storyline is relatively simple - a cop in Glasgow is working undercover in a drugs and prostitution racket to try to ensnare the brutal ringleader when her cover is busted. She avoids execution with the help of an emotionally stunted nine year old boy whose addict/prostitute mother has overdosed and subsequently flees to the highlands with him. A game of cat-and-mouse ensues alongside the emotional recovery of the woman and boy.
As another reviewer has said, this is not a comfortable moral tale and you will have to reconcile yourself to the questionnable morals and behaviours, but I think the complex motivations and emotional responses are part of the strength of the book. The author has in my opinion done a marvellous job with the characterisation of the leading two characters, with some other notable cast members in support. It is perhaps (and necessarily) only the villain who is underdone.
So a very respectable effort all round - well written, involving, engaging and with unexpected depth of character.
A change from Manda Scott's earlier offerings but if you are a fan of her previous ones, don't let this put you off. From page one you are taken on a journey through the scottish underworld with emotion and skill.
The attention to detail is gratifying and a lot of research has obviously gone into this book. In my opinion, this should be trabslated to TV... but then I like the genre!
I hope there is a sequel.
Orla MacLeod is the central character, who has to make choices of various sorts, while taking on the responsibility of nine-year-old Jamie, a child who has seen more than a child should see and whose life as a consequence is in danger.
I am so glad I gave 'No Good Deed' a second chance (I wasn't into it when it was first published), as this time it gave me food for thought, something I always look for in a book
The saving of the whole story is the silent nine-year-old boy Jamie rescued from the criminals' flat by Orla - once he has rescued her. Jamie can't trust anyone but gradually begins to trust the crew of detectives who look after him (not Social Services?) and goes into hiding in the snowy Highlands where he learns to talk a little and absorbs lessons about stalking and tracking. The complete contrast with his early life makes him a very sympathetic character as he begins to blossom.
A tangent involving faking computer records and a master criminal's seizing a hacker and forcing her to hack for him is much less convincing and comes across as padding the story. Perhaps the author couldn't think of another way that the detectives and Jamie would be found.
Some of the writing is excellent and brings scenes and people vividly to life. This book is often compared to Ian Rankin's Rebus series and is a good fit for grittiness but Rankin is a whole lot more realistic about policing.
Most Recent Customer Reviews
An awesome thriller, chock all of plot twists, tension and excitement. Great characters and a novel approach to plot, eschewing the stereotype whodunnit and concentrating instead... Read morePublished 5 months ago by Patrick Navin
I bought this more or less randomly - and really enjoyed it. It is beautifully written. If you want a direct, no nonsense detective story, this probably isn't it, for the writing... Read morePublished 13 months ago by Bertolt
Genuinely, ever-windingly tense, near-unputdownable and astonishingly vivid in the power of its characterisation. 'Remarkable thriller' indeed. Read morePublished 17 months ago by Sandra Davies
This book takes the reader on an emotional roller-coaster. Action, adventure, heart-ache and laughter. A must-read.Published 21 months ago by Mrs Moppit
What a tense read, outstanding book, I knew she was good after the Boudica series but this is brilliantPublished 22 months ago by Ronald Dansey
Really did not like this book. Uneccessarily complex writing style, unclear time lines and a nasty dose of hatred of all things British. Did not understand the ending!Published 22 months ago by Amazon Customer
By chance I came across this earlier work of Manda's. I refuse to lay words on paper that would open this box of delights for a potential reader. It deserves instead to be READ. Read morePublished 23 months ago by Bob Edwards
Excellent. Just the sort of book I love. Intelligent, possibly bit soppy with child involved but really great escapism which is top of my fiction requirementsPublished 23 months ago by ms l m boardman