Top critical review
3 people found this helpful
do the figures add up?
on 7 December 2012
I agree with the previous reviews. This is a great story ,but let down with some strange figures. 10,000 troops fighting on a ships superstructure! Really? Snow 70 foot high! Yes, 70 foot. I would like to see that. Nearly 2 million people cremated in a couple of weeks ( about 1 every 6 seconds on my reckoning).
And, yes, the barbeque's, what is that all about?
Having griped, I will continue to read all the books in the series as,once started, I refuse to let go, but the story could be much tighter as we need to know how the rest of the world copes with the disaster that has befallen.
With the right script, this would make an excellent movie. just a thought.