• RRP: £20.95
  • You Save: £3.34 (16%)
FREE Delivery in the UK.
Only 1 left in stock.
Dispatched from and sold by Amazon. Gift-wrap available.
Hypatia of Alexandria (Re... has been added to your Basket
+ £2.80 UK delivery
Used: Very Good | Details
Condition: Used: Very Good
Comment: PROFESSIONAL SELLER SHIPPING TOP QUALITY BOOKS WITHIN 24 HOURS.100% MONEY BACK GUARANTEE Very well cared for, with minimal signs of use, if any. Shipped from the heart of the British countryside this book will leave our library within a day or two of your order and be with you shortly thereafter.
Have one to sell?
Flip to back Flip to front
Listen Playing... Paused   You're listening to a sample of the Audible audio edition.
Learn more
See all 2 images

Hypatia of Alexandria (Revealing Antiquity) Paperback – 30 Sep 1996

4.0 out of 5 stars 3 customer reviews

See all 6 formats and editions Hide other formats and editions
Amazon Price
New from Used from
Paperback
"Please retry"
£17.61
£14.81 £6.33
Note: This item is eligible for click and collect. Details
Pick up your parcel at a time and place that suits you.
  • Choose from over 13,000 locations across the UK
  • Prime members get unlimited deliveries at no additional cost
How to order to an Amazon Pickup Location?
  1. Find your preferred location and add it to your address book
  2. Dispatch to this address when you check out
Learn more
£17.61 FREE Delivery in the UK. Only 1 left in stock. Dispatched from and sold by Amazon. Gift-wrap available.
click to open popover

Special Offers and Product Promotions


Frequently Bought Together

  • Hypatia of Alexandria (Revealing Antiquity)
  • +
  • Hypatia of Alexandria: Mathematician and Martyr
  • +
  • Agora [DVD] [2009]
Total price: £56.25
Buy the selected items together

Enter your mobile number or email address below and we'll send you a link to download the free Kindle App. Then you can start reading Kindle books on your smartphone, tablet, or computer - no Kindle device required.

  • Apple
  • Android
  • Windows Phone

To get the free app, enter your mobile phone number.



Product details

  • Paperback: 172 pages
  • Publisher: Harvard University Press; New Ed edition (30 Sept. 1996)
  • Language: English
  • ISBN-10: 0674437764
  • ISBN-13: 978-0674437760
  • Product Dimensions: 14 x 1.2 x 20.9 cm
  • Average Customer Review: 4.0 out of 5 stars  See all reviews (3 customer reviews)
  • Amazon Bestsellers Rank: 694,812 in Books (See Top 100 in Books)
  • See Complete Table of Contents

Product Description

Review

ÝA¨ pithy and engaging attempt to state what we actually know about Hypatia. -- Carlin Romano "Philadelphia Inquirer"

Historians and patristic scholars as well as general readers should be grateful to Dzielska for this book which clarifies a dark and interesting spot in Church history.

Dzielska...provides here an exemplary 'retrieval' of the life and achievements of Hypatia of Alexandria (c. 335-415). Dzielska traces in detail the modern literary tradition of Hypatia--from the Enlightenment authors who claimed her as the last of the great pagan neoplatonists, through Victorian novelist Charles Kingsley, to today's feminists...The author portrays the close circle of her students and provides the context for her public lectures; she concludes with 35 sober pages on the 'life and death of Hypatia, ' interpreting her death as a kind of witch-burning in the transition from pagan Empire to Christian state. Dzielska is meticulous in her pursuit of facts from the widely scattered sources...The book as a whole is a model of feminist scholarship in its sorting out of legend from facts.

Hypatia of Alexandria is a clearly written, tightly focused book ... In contrast to a number of earlier writers on Hypatia, Maria Dzielska is meticulous about disentangling fact from speculation; meticulous, too, about documenting her sources and leading her readers, via her footnotes, to a variety of interesting discussions about the various points at issue.

This gem of academic detective work may be the last word on a subject that has fascinated for centuries.--Anthony Gottlieb "New York Times Book Review "

Like Cleopatra, Mary Magdalene, Joan of Arc...Hypatia has been retailored to suit the psychic needs of anybody retrospecting her, rational, romantic, nostalgic, or loony. [In this book] Dzielska demystifies Hypatia, sifting patiently through the original sources, from the "Sud" lexicon to the correspondence of Synesius of Cyrene.--John Leonard "Nation "

Through a subtle reading of the ancient sources, Dzielska reconstructs a powerful and persuasive account of Hypatia's life. She also addresses the difficult task of describing her philosophy...with engagement and finesse.--Wilbur Knorr "Science "

[A] pithy and engaging attempt to state what we actually know about Hypatia.--Carlin Romano "Philadelphia Inquirer "

History fades to myth. Dzielska's aim in this book is to peel away those mythical images of Hypatia to examine the reality beneath. The result is a splendid example of demythologizing scholarship...[It] deserves to be read by anyone studying ancient gender or her time period [and] is a delight to read, in a translation which is light and natural.--Richard Hawley "Classical Review "

Maria Dzielska has finally brought us definitive and sober research into who that grand historic figure really was, the circumstances of her life and scholarship, and the dynamics that led to her death. We shall be permanently indebted to Dzielska for her thorough research and for her highly readable book...If you are a historian, Greco-Roman scholar, Egyptologist, anthropologist, psychologist, theologian or a thoughtful person in any field who likes a good read...buy this book!--J. Harold Ellens "Biblical Archaeology Review "

This book is an important monograph for anyone with an interest in the fourth and fifth century Alexandria, its social life, church history, neo-Platonism and mathematics. The book reads well and for this the translator must be congratulated.--Leonora Jackson, Scholia: Natal Studies in Classical Antiquity

Hypatia, an exceptional philosopher, mathematician and high profile public figure of late fourth and early fifth century Alexandria, ironically owes her fame in history to the violent and politically contentious nature of her death in 415 AD. From the moment she was brutally murdered by a mob of angry Christians, Hypatia became a legend, a figure who has ever since been used and manipulated by artists, writers, poets and feminists. Maria Dzielska in "Hypatia of Alexandria," explores who Hypatia was, what she believed, why she was killed and what she has come to symbolize in the centuries since...Dzielska's discussion of Hypatia has contributed to the understanding of women in late antiquity. Hypatia was an exceptional woman and has been of particular benefit to those interested in Christian and Roman/Hellenic history. The ideas commonly held regarding Hypatia have been strongly influenced and shaped by a tradition which used Hypatia as a symbol for its own attitudes and beliefs. Such details have created a veil over the true figure of Hypatia. This has effectively been removed by Dzielska revealing the historical Hypatia, an extraordinary woman, without the benefit of legend.--P. Murphy "Ancient History "

"Hypatia of Alexandria" is a clearly written, tightly focused bookIn contrast to a number of earlier writers on Hypatia, Maria Dzielska is meticulous about disentangling fact from speculation; meticulous, too, about documenting her sources and leading her readers, via her footnotes, to a variety of interesting discussions about the various points at issue.--J.J. MacIntosh "ISIS ""

From the Back Cover

Hypatia--brilliant mathematician, eloquent Neoplatonist, and a woman renowned for her beauty--was brutally murdered by a mob of Christians in Alexandria in 415. In this engrossing book, the author searches behind the legend to bring us the real story of Hypatia's life and death, and new insight into her colorful world.

See all Product Description

What Other Items Do Customers Buy After Viewing This Item?

Customer Reviews

4.0 out of 5 stars
Share your thoughts with other customers

Top Customer Reviews

Format: Hardcover
Socrates was executed by the state of Athens as a scapegoat for its defeat by the Spartans. His crime was being a free thinker in a short age of turmoil. He was however fondly remembered and documented. Hypatia was first brought to my attention by Carl Sagan in his television series Cosmos. She has often been represented as a pillar of wisdom in an age of growing dogma. Unlike with Socrates we know much less about her life and teachings. She is remembered precisely as a martyr who was sacrificed rather than executed by a literalist Christian mob inspired by "St" Cyril, apparently as she was regarded as a threat to Christendom and theology by certain regio-political figures. Enough material on her survived not least owing to the strong memories evoked at the manner of her despatch which turned her into a historical icon.
This excellent short well sourced book is a biographic scenography in the best sense of the word. It does not sadly cover the destruction of the great library or go into great length about the history and politics of 4th century Alexandria but it blows the cobwebs and embelishments that are associated with this enigmatic figure leaving a strong, uncompromising educated presence who would have been of extreme high standing to have obtained the death she received at the hands of bigots.
The importance of Hypatia is that she represents a phase in history where Greek religion was being destroyed by the then politicised Roman state religion. Hypatia represents a tragic victim of this dark phase when a great deal of knowledge was irrevocably lost (e.g.Gandy and Freke, the Jesus Mysteries etc.,).
To know the real Hypatia, and that phase of history, this is one of the best places to begin.
Comment 32 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you? Yes No Sending feedback...
Thank you for your feedback.
Sorry, we failed to record your vote. Please try again
Report abuse
Format: Paperback Verified Purchase
Very good book. The chapter about het circle is a bit long and we tend to lose sight of Hypatia. Yet this book is a great stepping stone for any readers new to Greek antiquity and the philosophical world it breeded.
1 Comment Was this review helpful to you? Yes No Sending feedback...
Thank you for your feedback.
Sorry, we failed to record your vote. Please try again
Report abuse
Format: Paperback
This book really doesn't say practically nothing about Hypatia but this isn't an obstacle to extract an obvious conclussion that ever repeats itself across history of mankind: you can be different... but these is not very sane. Hypatia was no doubt a very notorious personage but curiously the only well known fact about his life is his death by terrible murder. Other things we can only scarcely suposse: she was a wise woman scientific, wealthy and philosopher, but she confronted with the obscure primitive Christianism that by then wanted to made his way, so many times plenty of blood and by nothing remembering the teachings of Jesus. Summing up, a figth for power between Paganism and Christianism. Furthermore it seems no very risky to say Hypatia, even recognizing his wisdom, commited some capital mistakes. It's said she was plenty of virtue, intelligence... but also that she had a vigorous and stern character and remained virgin all his foggy life rejecting in a harsh mode the love of some men. Too many chastity, too many stiffness sounds like near of too many pride and a loss of common sense. I suposse that, as other famous heroes or historical personages, Hypatia was a respected but at same times fearsome person perceived by many people as strange and dangerous. Such personages not rarely have a bad end. Accusations to be a witch, making evil and so on are easy to do and probably the same could be said about the Christians, in this case, the ominous St Cyril. There are many cases of punished virtue: Socrates, Galileus, the apostles... Mankind ever need wise people, but paradoxalment rarely tolerate they.
3 Comments 2 people found this helpful. Was this review helpful to you? Yes No Sending feedback...
Thank you for your feedback.
Sorry, we failed to record your vote. Please try again
Report abuse

Most Helpful Customer Reviews on Amazon.com (beta)

Amazon.com: 4.4 out of 5 stars 28 reviews
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful
4.0 out of 5 stars Incisive, Clear Treatment Of What We Really Know About Hypatia 1 July 2016
By Charles - Published on Amazon.com
Format: Paperback Verified Purchase
In today’s popular culture, Hypatia, the woman philosopher/mathematician of the Fifth Century A.D., is a caricature with little or no grounding in reality. For example, in the 2009 film “Agora,” she is portrayed as the youthful originator of heliocentrism, killed by ignorant Christians opposed to science, who for good measure burn down the famous Library of Alexandria, of which Hypatia was Librarian. None of this is true in any way, of course, although it fits the modern liberal desire to contemptuously dismiss Christians and Christianity and to assign historical importance based on identity, rather than accomplishment.

As it happens, denigrating Christians by mischaracterizing Hypatia isn’t just a modern liberal desire. The use of a fictional Hypatia in this program began more than two hundred years ago, most notably with Gibbon’s “Decline And Fall,” where a fictional Hypatia is used in service of Gibbon’s theory that Christianity destroyed the strong and thriving Roman Empire. Since then, variations on this theme have been modestly common in Western writers, although the additional use of Hypatia as a pawn in the identity politics wars is new. (There were quite a few women intellectuals, philosophers and writers of some note in the Classical world, Christian and non-Christian, but that is usually ignored by those attempting to impute universal misogyny to our Christian ancestors in service of modern politics.)

Hypatia, though, unlike most exemplars used in identity politics, actually was very accomplished, and recognized as such in her time. Maria Dzielska’s “Hypatia Of Alexandria” is a short academic history, from 1995. It is not an entry in the identity politics wars; it is not a political book at all. It is a technical examination of what is really known about Hypatia, drawing on the handful of contemporaneous resources, and an attempt to harmonize the differences in those sources into a coherent picture of Hypatia’s time, life and death.

Dzielska’s book divides her treatment into three sections. She begins by outlining and rejecting the “literary Hypatia.” She finds no example of any literary treatment of Hypatia in the past two centuries that bears anything but a tenuous, if that, relationship to the truth, to the extent the truth is known. If “Agora” had come out before this book was published, Dzielska would doubtless have cast a jaundiced eye on it, as well. Such literary treatments include Gibbon, Voltaire, and numerous less famous writers, all of whom either created or embellished a story not based on history, revolving around a supposed beautiful young pagan philosopher, the last line of defense of Greek philosophy and thought, hater of Christianity, opposed to Christian irrationality and obscurantism, and murdered by the Christians as a result. All of this is made up out of whole cloth, as Dzielska notes.

In the second section, Dzielska digs deep into the source material to understand the milieu in which Hypatia lived and worked. Alexandria was one of the chief cities of the Roman Empire, sufficient to itself, such that Hypatia (and her also-famous father, Theon) never once left it. Dzielska closely parses the letters of Synesius of Cyrene, a disciple of Hypatia (and later a bishop), with their numerous references to other disciples of Hypatia. She also analyzes and compares the other primary sources, all of whom were somewhat hostile to Hypatia: Damascius, the pagan Neoplatonist philosopher of Athens; Socrates Scholasticus, a Christian writer of a church history that discusses Hypatia; and John of Nikiu, a later Christian writer. The analysis turns on careful reading of each writer in context, made deeper by cross-referencing other known facts that illuminate what is said about Hypatia and her circle. Through this analysis, Dzielska examines and attempts to view as clearly as possible not only Hypatia’s thought, acts and writings, but also the characteristics of her disciples.

Hypatia, and her circle of disciples, were upper-class elitists devoted to the life of the mind and the Platonic contemplation of knowledge. They were not populists and they occupied leading positions in city life. They were heavily involved in patronage networks to obtain advantage for other upper-class acquaintances and friends. They were not theurgists (i.e., interested in ritual magic), even though other philosophers and Hypatia’s father were. (In Classical times, the lines blurred among philosophers, mathematicians, astronomers, astrologers, theurgists and so forth, but each individual tended to focus on one area.) They were not involved in any way in the debates among pagans and Christians; in fact, Hypatia’s students included many Christians, including a deacon, and there does not appear to have been any concern about that. Finally, although Hypatia was heavily involved in mathematics and astronomy, sometimes in conjunction with her father, these were not her prime focus, which was pure philosophy and the attainment of Platonic enlightenment (to which end she and her circle were somewhat secretive of their learning, fearing that it might be sullied if exposed to the uninitiated). She therefore did not create any new advancements in philosophy, mathematics or any other area, but instead taught the teachings of and commented on earlier writers such as Plato, Ptolemy (whose earth-centered universe she wholly endorsed) and Diophantus (the founder of algebra, if there was one specific person who founded it).

Finally, Dzielska discusses the specifics of Hypatia’s life and death. She concludes Hypatia was about 65 when she died, in 415 A.D. She was killed by a mob acting in the perceived interest of Cyril, the recently elected archbishop of Alexandria. Prior to that time, Hypatia had had an excellent relationship with the Church authorities, in the person of Theophilus, the previous archbishop. Cyril, a hard and power-hungry man (though a canonized saint in the Roman Catholic Church), was in a political conflict with Orestes, the recently appointed prefect of Alexandria (i.e., the representative of civilian Imperial power). Hypatia, well-connected to the upper classes throughout the city, was a supporter of Orestes and the upper classes generally in this struggle. Orestes had ostensibly more political power, but Cyril had plenty of allies, many among the lower classes, who saw Hypatia’s alliance with Orestes as an obstacle to getting rid of him.

Therefore, Orestes’s enemies spread rumors that Hypatia was an idolater and sorceress (not a pagan, which everybody knew and nobody cared). These rumors were aided by her (dead) father’s known theurgical tendencies and her close relationship with her father. This whipped up the lower classes against Hypatia, who was already regarded as a member of the elite and no friend of the common people. Then a political assassination of Hypatia was planned and executed, involving a political riot (common in Alexandria) and the dismemberment and burning of Hypatia. The act was probably done by the hired young thugs of the cathedral guard (not by monks—although those had earlier attacked Orestes). The murder was well planned and had its desired political effect: Orestes left, never to be heard from again, and Cyril (who may not have known of the plan at all, but, like Henry II in his struggle with Thomas Becket, probably desired the effect) acceded to the main political power in the city.

Such political assassinations are, of course, common throughout history, up to the present day (just ask Hugo Chavez, if you can find him among the plumes of sulfur, or Vladimir Putin). This was not at all a struggle between pagans and Christians. Both Cyril and Orestes were very much Christian, and Hypatia not only took no part or position in, but was not affected in any way by, Cyril’s earlier suppression of the pagans and their cult center at the Serapheum (which was not the Library—that had likely been destroyed by Julius Caesar, with the destruction completed under Aurelian, both accidentally). In fact, Alexandrian mobs had earlier murdered two separate Christian bishops in a manner similar to how Hypatia was murdered, so there was actually nothing unique about her murder.

Dzielska shows that most accepted facts about Hypatia are wrong. She wasn’t a pagan in the sense of polytheist; philosophers who were pagan in that sense joined the Alexandrian mini-civil war that ended in the sacking of Serapheum, and had already all been killed or exiled. Instead, she was a Platonist philosopher, attempting “to achieve religious experience as the ideal of philosophy,” and not interested at all in religious struggles. Misogyny had little or nothing to do with her death; men also died in similar ways in similar political struggles. Nor did Hypatia’s death mark in any way the passing of the Classical world, as Gibbon would have it. Neoplatonist philosophy continued thereafter, as did paganism. And, of course, Christianity in the Classical world, as later, was not at all opposed to science and philosophy—the vast majority of scientific advances prior to the Industrial Age were made by avowed Christians, in medieval times mostly under the aegis and financial support of the Church.

Hypatia’s death didn’t mean anything at all, really, any more than the death of Archimedes at the hands of Roman soldiers at Syracuse did. All people die; some accomplish more than others before it happens to them. And although it may not be kind to say so, Hypatia created nothing new and did not advance human knowledge, although she undoubtedly was an excellent teacher of the work of others, and her students were devoted to her. Her work was purely derivative of the work of others; she made no advances in any area in which she studied, nor did she invent any scientific instruments, despite laughable claims she invented the astrolabe and the hydrometer. Bluntly, nobody at all would remember her except as an obscure figure, any more than hundreds of other known people of similar accomplishments, had she not been a woman and her manner of death gruesome and endlessly fascinating to later writers. But whatever the reason, we do remember her, such that Hollywood makes major movies about her, and this book is an excellent summation of what we actually know about her, in contradiction to what is normally said about her.
2 of 2 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars Augustine narrowly escaped death by a dedicated mob of religious zealots like the one that lynched Hypatia 19 Mar. 2015
By Stephen Ayala - Published on Amazon.com
Format: Paperback Verified Purchase
One has to doubt the value of any time spent reading a saint or historical figure’s story whose author plays freely between reality and creative fantasy. Maria Dzielska’s HYPATIA OF ALEXANDRIA is thankfully at the opposite end of that spectrum – a serious, readable look at what is actually known and what can be responsibly surmised about this Egyptian scholar/philosopher, her colleagues, friends and compatriots.
Dzielska’s studied account (with F. Lyra's translation) of the North African social and political climate around 400 CE supports the picture of Alexandria’s settings, life and religious conflicts portrayed in the 2009 Spanish film AGORA - THE MISTS OF TIME. And it provides a context that can help us understand similar conflict underway at the same time around the Mediterranean – such as farther west in Hippo, where St. Augustine narrowly escaped death by a dedicated mob of religious zealots like the one that lynched Hypatia.
5.0 out of 5 stars The middle east is worthless from a religious point of view. 17 Oct. 2016
By David - Published on Amazon.com
Format: Hardcover Verified Purchase
It is about time that history has been corrected, The library was the center of the world at Alexandria and Jerusalem was a dump hole loaded with religious factions.
0 of 1 people found the following review helpful
5.0 out of 5 stars Delightful peek into a fascinating piece of history 7 May 2014
By jeanniebear - Published on Amazon.com
Format: Paperback Verified Purchase
Many years ago I experienced a vivid vision of a woman of what seemed like the period of early Greece. She was a spiritual teacher who had a large following, dressed plainly in the Greek philosopher's type garment. During this vision, the woman was addressing her followers in something like a town square. In a flash, she was dragged away and into a building by someone who was wearing chain mail armor. I knew that she was murdered, but my vision did not show me the murder scene. In the vision it seemed to me that the murderer felt jealousy because of her magnetic qualities that he could never have and because she was widely admired and he wanted to be. I never forgot that vision and to this day I can still see it clearly in my mind's eye. I was led to Hypatia recently while reading a book which mentioned her and told her story, briefly. I was stunned and felt a shudder of familiarity when I read this, which was just a paragraph. Was this the woman in my vision?

I had not previously heard of Hypatia, but through subsequent research, I was led to Maria Dzielska's book. One reviewer who disliked the book said that it was boring because of the dialogues between people we don't even know; however, this was one of the reasons I enjoyed the book, given that there appears to be no extant writing by Hypatia. The letters were written between students who were part of Hypatia's inner spiritual circle. The letters reveal not only information about Hypatia, but share insights about the political/social/cultural milieu of the times and particularly its spiritual atmosphere. I found myself wishing I could be part of this circle, with the mystical experiences they shared, and the quenching of the thirst to, "...elevate oneself into another dimension of existence and to direct merging with the One." Here is a lovely quote from the book, as written between two of Hypatia's students, who travel from the city to take part in Hypatia's teachings:

"In the picturesque countryside near Cyrene, the two friends find refuge from the hubbub of the city with its markets and financial operations, which they see as an outrage to the human spirit. They speak of avoiding the struggle for offices, honors, and political careers that gratify only superficial ambitions, and not genuine human values."

Hmmmm, might not many of us today, in the frantic pace of our "modern" world be inclined to say something quite similar?

The study of Hypatia is not about what some suggest as "marauding Christians" attempting to destroy pagans and their beliefs, nor is it about the prejudice of women, as attributed by some feminist writers of today. One of the refreshing aspects of this book is that it does not appear to have an agenda, but only to extract historical truth among shards of scant documents on this interesting woman. Maria Dzielska's reasoned conclusion about Hypatia's ultimate demise comes at the end, in a bit of a surprise ending.

Wonderful book!
1 of 2 people found the following review helpful
3.0 out of 5 stars scholarly work 12 Mar. 2013
By S. Bowyer - Published on Amazon.com
Format: Paperback Verified Purchase
This book is somewhat dry reading of a fascinating subject. Scholarly. Conclusion is a welcome summation. Basic premise seems to be that important historical events are products of political intrigue and fighting, not fundamental ideas. Regardless, is good source for facts about personalities involved and the culture in Alexandria, c. 400. Very striking is the report on how deeply mystical pagan philosophy had become. Recommended!
Were these reviews helpful? Let us know


Feedback