In what was to prove the end of an idyllic period for the leisured English middle classes just before the outbreak of World War One, E. M. Forster captures the tensions and lack of “meeting of minds” between two middle class families with very different roots and attitudes: the Schlegels and the Wilcoxes. The intellectual Schlegels get away with appearing a bit unorthodox since they are half-German, that is “foreigners”. They are idealistic within their cocoon of privilege, living comfortably on inherited money. The much wealthier, pragmatic, materialistic Wilcoxes have built a fortune “in trade” and have no compunction about “keeping the workers in their place”. As Henry Wilcox observes,
“You do admit that, if wealth was divided up equally, in a few years…the hard-working man would come to the top, the wastrel sink to the bottom”.
Through a fateful meeting of the Schlegel siblings with the bookish, music-loving clerk Leonard Bast, Forster portrays the rigid class divide of the early 1900s. Too poor even to afford a decent umbrella, too decent to abandon the ageing, former prostitute lover who has latched on to him, unable to regain a foothold on the ladder of respectability when he loses his job through no fault of his own, it proves too hard for him to win acceptance and pursue his interests.
Howards End seems an unlikely place for the Wilcoxes to live, being a somewhat unfashionable place in the depths of the countryside, based on Forster’s own childhood home, “Rooks Nest House”. It turns out that this belongs to Mrs Wilcox, a rather unsatisfactorily vague, two-dimensional character, dismissed as “uninteresting” by Margaret Schlegel’s chatterati friends. She exerts a calming influence on her family, but is not the woman one would expect Mr. Wilcox to have chosen for a wife. It seems that she is the “guardian” of a house which is the almost mystical symbol of an idealised way of English life that is fast disappearing at the turn of the C19 century. Knowing that she is terminally ill, she appears to hold, but never clearly expresses, the belief that Margaret Schlegel is more suited to own the house than the soulless, capitalist family into which Mrs Wilcox has married. The implications of her decision form an important part of the plot.
It may be surprising that, when widowed, the patriarch Mr. Wilcox falls for Margaret, the plain, serious-minded elder sister who has devoted herself to her orphaned siblings to the point of risking becoming an old maid. It is understandable that she seeks “a real man” in the form of Mr Wilcox, even though the two are clearly fundamentally different in their attitude to life.
The main characters, at least on the “middle class” side, are well developed. Margaret’s younger sister Helen, impetuous with a hint of instability, plays the role of the character prepared to challenge the system, but ill-equipped to cope unaided when “it comes to the crunch”. Brother Tibby provides a further contrast as the hypochondriac, wimpish bookworm cosseted by his sisters, who do not seem to resent the fact that, being the male child, he is the one to go Oxford.
Written at the end of a prolonged period of social stability and convention, but foreshadowing some dramatic changes, this stands out as one of the first “modern” novels, quite radical and original in certain respects. The story proceeds with some unexpectedly humorous moments and a sense of real connection between the characters in the form of conversations to which one can relate. Forster focuses on the relevant scenes, confidently omitting any superfluous “linking” chapters. Perhaps he can be forgiven for drifting occasionally into overblown Victorian-style philosophising.
This is an engaging family drama, with some profound insights which repay rereading. It can be read at two levels: either an Edwardian soap opera, or a quite complex amalgam of Forster’s deep reflections on the nature and future of English society, the differences between people and the ultimate need for tolerance. Although the characters may be a little wiser at the end, the wry truth remains that in any crisis the poor and the underdogs will tend to be the ones who lose out, but hints of the approaching war suggest that the escapist paradise of Howard’s End may not last.
Download the free Kindle app and start reading Kindle books instantly on your smartphone, tablet or computer – no Kindle device required.
Read instantly on your browser with Kindle for Web.
Using your mobile phone camera - scan the code below and download the Kindle app.
Follow the authors
Something went wrong. Please try your request again later.
Frequently bought together
This item: Howards End (Dover Thrift Editions: Classic Novels)
£12.08
Get it 19 – 26 Aug
Only 1 left in stock.
+
+
Total price: $00
To see our price, add these items to your basket.
Choose items to buy together.
What do customers buy after viewing this item?
Page 1 of 1 Start again
Lowest Price
in this set of productsBest Selling | Highest rated
in this set of products
Not a review of the book itself…more a comment about Amazon packaging
Please could Amazon UK reconsider how they package books? As you can see from the photo this is a brand new book which has already been ruined as it was not packed tightly enough. This is the second time this has happened with a Penguin Classic. If this had not been ruined my review would be 5/5 as I absolutely love Forster
Top reviews from United Kingdom
There was a problem filtering reviews. Please reload the page.
- Reviewed in the United Kingdom on 29 October 2023
- Reviewed in the United Kingdom on 9 May 2019
- Reviewed in the United Kingdom on 7 July 2016
- Reviewed in the United Kingdom on 26 June 2015
Top reviews from other countries
- JayeshReviewed in India on 17 June 2025
One of the Greatest Books of Edwardian Era
- Aran Joseph CanesReviewed in the United States on 27 October 2022
A Shift in the Collective Moral Perspective
-
OttoReviewed in Italy on 13 July 2020
Un ritratto delle classi della società inglese dell'inizio del Novecento
Non avevo mai acquistato queste edizioni, ma devo dire che sono rimasta soddisfatta!OttoUn ritratto delle classi della società inglese dell'inizio del Novecento
Reviewed in Italy on 13 July 2020
La copertina è plastificata e le pagine sono di buona qualità anche se non ho apprezzato molto la presenza della linea che separa il titolo del libro dal corpo del testo, ma è un gusto estetico personale. La storia è molto bella, perché racconta dell'incontro tra classi differenti con le loro divergenze e battaglie personali. Consigliatissimo!
Images in this review
