Hitler, the Germans, and the Final Solution Paperback – 9 Jun 2009
- Choose from over 13,000 locations across the UK
- Prime members get unlimited deliveries at no additional cost
- Find your preferred location and add it to your address book
- Dispatch to this address when you check out
Frequently bought together
Customers who bought this item also bought
Enter your mobile number or email address below and we'll send you a link to download the free Kindle App. Then you can start reading Kindle books on your smartphone, tablet, or computer - no Kindle device required.
To get the free app, enter your mobile phone number.
'This short book goes to the heart of the great debates over Nazism, then examines the progress of the debates themselves... an important contribution to the historiography of the Second World War. Plus it's a page-turner.' Andrew Roberts, The Mail on Sunday. 'An excellent chance to acquire, in a single volume, Kershaw's writings on the Holocaust... The classic essays in the first two sections of the book will remain required reading for students of Nazi Germany and the Holocaust for years to come.' Dan Stone, BBC History Magazine. 'To a field that is increasingly fragmented, faddish and cursed by jargon, Kershaw brings a grounded, unified perspective that is conveyed with precision and clarity. His unflashy style, personal reticence and sheer decency are, sadly, too often absent among 'celebrity historians''. David Cesarini, Literary Review --The Mail on Sunday, BBC History Magazine, Literary Review
"... a compilation of a lifetime's perceptive essays on the Holocaust and related matters."
--This text refers to the Hardcover edition.
What other items do customers buy after viewing this item?
Top customer reviews
Kershaw concentrates on four themes. Hitler and the Final Solution; Popular opinion and the Jews; The Final Solution in Historiography; and the Uniqueness of Nazism. All are inextricably mixed in the observation that "the road to Auschwitz was built by hate, but paved with indifference". Many Germans lacked strong views about the Jews but acquiesced by virtue of latent ant-Semitism which translated into passive complicity in the genocide and moral indifference as to its meaning. In a society in which freedom of opinion was denied the extent of this complicity can only be estimated. It was to undermine this moral insensibility to the Jews' fate that was behind the determination of liberating forces to make local citizens view the product of their complicity when concentration camps were finally reached.
The role of Hitler in the Final Solution lies at the heart of revisionists' attempts to re-cast Hitler as being uninvolved in the policy for which the Nazi regime is most remembered. Kershaw deals extensively with this question, setting it in the context of Hitler's "prophecy" that Germany would go to war against the "Jewish Bolshevik" conspiracy, This "denoted the indelible link in (Hitler's) mind between war and revenge against the Jews" - the revenge being the "stab in the back" inflicted on Germany in 1918. Kershaw convincingly infers Hitler's approval for the Final Solution from a series of unminuted meetings between Hitler and Himmler in mid-July 1941, when the former authorised an extension of the activities of the Einsatzgruppen (killing squads) in the east. The Wanasee meeting of January 1942 was confirmation of what Goebbels called a "barbaric but fully deserved" judgement on the Jews.
Germany had a long tradition of anti-Semitism. This "probably did not go much further than an abstract dislike or distrust of the Jews". However, the appearance of racial anti-Semitism as an element of nationalist thinking became powerful during the late nineteenth century and it is known Hitler read the second edition of Human Hereditary Teaching and Racial Hygiene by Bauer, Fischer and Lenz before he wrote Mein Kamp. Alfred Rosenberg, Nazism's racial theorist, was influenced by the writings of Arthur de Gobineau, Houston Stewart Chamberlain, and Madison Grant. Rosenberg linked racial theories to Darwinism throughEugenics. In many cases opposition to maltreatment of Jews came from those who had an economic interest in their continuing to do business with them. Although some clerics were regular opponents of Nazi racial hatred, many expressed their opposition less vigorously than when the regime tried to Nazify their own churches.
Kershaw deals with the question of whether Nazism was unique. A J P Taylor argued that it was not but, just as the war could be traced directly to the personality of Adolph Hitler, the Nazi state could be traced to the character of the Germanic people. Race was central to Nazism in a way which did not apply to Fascism. Kershaw recognises the centrality of Hitler to an understanding of Nazism. Take away Hitler and there is no Nazism in the sense of a charismatic leader who could represent the process of "national salvation". The one man who might, Ernest Rohm, was despatched without ceremony in 1934. Kershaw concludes the uniqueness of the Nazi leadership cannot be explained by Hitler's personality alone. While latent anti-Semitism could be stirred up amongst the masses it was the lack of opposition in prominent sections of the German elites - civil service, armed forces and industry, which facilitated anti Jewish policies.
Underlying everything was the glorification of violence. Whether from the left with Georges Sorel or the right with Giacomo Marinetti, calls to violence appealed to societies in cultural flux where old values had been destroyed but new ones not yet accepted. Once these ideas were tied up with nationalism it often expressed itself as ethnic violence which, in Kershaw's view, is what makes genocide modern. The impact of nationalism provided states with a universal ideologicial reason for pogroms. "Being a Jew under Hitler, a Kulak under Stalin, an intellectual under Pol Pot, was tantamount to a death warrant." Kershaw hopes this will not be repeated in the future but the inability of human beings in political conflict to seek alternatives to war appear limited, if not impossible. Five stars.
Kershaw has been among the most persistent and intuitive historians writing about the subject of Nazi Germany. This work may be added to his other definitive studies on the phenomenon of and the phenomena surrounding the Third Reich as well as, of course, his aforementioned monumental biography of Hitler. This work is a vast read which pools a number of diverse articles into one volume; it remains unified, however and is, at no point, disparate.
Kershaw is a well-established historian of the socio-political history of the Third Reich, and the causes and subsequent (and much cataloged) consequences of Nazi policy. His views have attracted much attention particularly with respect to the vexed question of how much or how little the attitudes of the German populace influenced or did not influence Nazi policy. This single volume proffers the reader a thorough, well chronicled outline both of the catastrophic damage inflicted by the Nazi leadership, as well as the prevalent views and attitudes of the 'run of the mill' German folk as what started out as the basic segregation of the Jews then hurtled headlong into dire persecution, culminating in an attempt at outright, blanket genocide.
This work is, apparently, the culmination of over thirty years of in-depth historical research on Nazi Germany by one of that era's most acclaimed historians. It also has the merit of collating many characteristic and defining aspects of Ian Kershaw's previous research on the Holocaust for the first time, making it especially useful as a one-off 'drop in' resource for a private or institutional reference library.
The book is are structured in five sections, dealing with
Hitler and the Final Solution
Popular opinion and the Jews in Nazi Germany
The Final Solution in historiography
The Uniqueness of Nazism.
The can be little doubt about the quality of the research or of the 'readability of this book. Much valuable information is crammed into its 400 odd pages. This reviewer, for one, reckons that many if not all of Ian Kershaw's readers and followers will be delighted by this one!
Michael Calum Jacques (author of 1st Century Radical: the shadowy origins of the man who became known as Jesus Christ)
Would you like to see more reviews about this item?
Look for similar items by category