Harold Macmillan Hardcover – 4 Jun 2009
Customers Who Bought This Item Also Bought
Enter your mobile number or email address below and we'll send you a link to download the free Kindle App. Then you can start reading Kindle books on your smartphone, tablet, or computer - no Kindle device required.
To get the free app, enter your mobile phone number.
Charles Williams's thoughtful and well-informed new life... comes as a welcome treat... he captures better than any other writer the tensions between the different facets of Macmillan's personality (SUNDAY TIMES)
Charles Williams' biography is an antidote to nostalgia... a lean compelling narrative with a more detached and critical point of view. (LITERARY REVIEW)
a bright, swift-moving biography, without party-political rancour (DAILY EXPRESS)
[Williams] has produced a biography that... is a model of its kind - diligently researched, gracefully written and never short of absorbing. (Anthony Howard DAILY TELEGRAPH)
a keen eye for personality and drama... this fluid and engaging new biography... give[s] readers a ringside view of the politican in the making. (Frank Trentmann SUNDAY EXPRESS)
a fine achievement, fair in tone and spare in style. This thoroughly absorbing book chronicles the tragic Odyssey of an almost great man. (Kenneth Morgan THE INDEPENDENT)
It is not only well researched and beautifully crafted but also enlivened by the insights of an experienced politician. (Lord Radice HOUSE MAGAZINE)
This new biography... brings the Macmillan era back to life in vivid style. It is a first-class biography... most fascinating of all is the way he describes in great detail, pathos and sympathy the extraordinary emotional tragedy that haunted much of Macmillan's political career (Geoffrey Goodman TRIBUNE)
It is the great contribution of this new biography by a Labour peer to show the role domestic tragedy played in Macmillan's political achievement. (CHURCH OF ENGLAND NEWSPAPER)
In this impressive new biography Charles Williams takes the lid off the figure of Macmillan... This illuminating biography answers many hitherto unanswered questions. (CATHOLIC HERALD)
A masterly biography of a great Conservative Prime Minister (and publisher) - Harold Macmillan (1894-1986).See all Product Description
What Other Items Do Customers Buy After Viewing This Item?
Top Customer Reviews
The content however is were I take issue. I feel he is too harsh with his criticisms of Macmillan particularly dealing with many of his personality 'defects'. The overall tone, particularly towards the end of the book, bordered on being unpleasant. For example, the overall feel I got when reading the (too) concise outline of Macmillan's time as Earl of Stockton was that he was an old man who's time had gone. To be frank, William's appears to, as is customary for post-1979 politicians to do, look down on what Macmillan stood for, one-nation Toryism and consensus politics. I sincerely disagree with many of the conclusions that Williams reaches and I don't feel that he is completely impartial when dealing with Macmillan.
This book is by no means not worth reading, there are anecdotes and insight that are missing from more comprehensive works (even from Alistair Horne's rather comprehensive authorised biography). I don't think Williams has done anywhere near as good a job as Horne did on getting to know the subject, then again, I don't think many people could.
To be honest I am very disappointed with this and am looking forward to D.R. Thorpe's biography. Supermac: The Life of Harold Macmillan
Lucidly written with an abundance of shrewed,penetrating judgments on
people involved and occuring private and political situations.
Simply put,a treat to read, from cover to cover.
Long on Mac's early life and North Africa; short on his political life, with nothing to say on fast chunks of his premiership (eg immigration started big time when Mac was in the Cabinet and PM; surely it deserved a mention?).
Very little analysis of Mac's relationships with his contempories (eg why did he hate RAB so much?).
Also there are chunks that are badly written which I had to read 2 or 3 times to understand what he was saying.
But most of all, it became increasingly clear as I read the book that the author hated his subject. Not a good basis for a biography. Objective analysis is wanted, not unexplained hatred.
Such a shame as the author did such a good job with his biography of de Gaulle.
On the other hand, the balance of the book is odd, for example with only about twice as many pages on the premiership as on his time during the war in North Africa. This means that the lesser areas, such as his early years, that wartime experience, and his years after leaving office, have the space devoted to them to make for an interesting read. The premiership, on the other hand, is handled weakly, with insufficient analysis and reads too much as a simple chronology or globetrotting, golfing holidays and Trollope. Compare this part of the book with, for example, Peter Hennessey's analysis of the distinct phases of the Macmillan premiership: Williams simply doesn't convey any of that depth or understanding. There are too many gaps; the passages on cabinet selection are interesting but there is literally no mention of how either Thorneycroft or Maudling were chosen as Chancellor, which is a pity given the importance of both relationships. The epilogue, which is welcomingly analytical, just can't be supported by the preceeding chapters (and the throw away line that Mrs Thatcher was a Whig is just bizarre).
Where the book really went curiously off the rails is on the chapter on Suez (so at least in good company there I suppose). There is an interesting suggestion that sterling was not in the dire peril that Macmillan at the time suggested, though it is not clear why if he did not want his fingerprints on the dagger he was so keen to have the view propogated that he did make these warnings.Read more ›
In 1894 Maurice Harold Macmillan was born in London. He was taken to his grave at Horsted Keynes in 1986. Over his 92 years he came to a deep Anglo Catholic faith, maintained fidelity within a troublesome marriage, helped bring his country through the dissolution of its Empire and all the while remaining a man of culture and wit. As Williams points out private anguish and ambiguities were masked in a bullish public persona.
African nationalists visit his Sussex grave to this day. They recall his 1960 prophecy of `winds of change' blowing across that continent made in the face of Prime Minister Dr. Hendrik Verwoerd in the South African Parliament. Verwoerd indignantly replied that the white man had rights as well as the black man. Things moved on from there, but Macmillan's pragmatism played a signal role in opening up the post-colonial era.
Harold Macmillan is portrayed as one for centre ground where he could find it. His American ancestry motivated him to steer a pathway for British foreign policy honouring allegiance both to Europe and the United States. In economic policy he was for capitalism but also for intervention, propelling a Conservative Party campaign to build 300,000 houses a year in the 1951 election.Read more ›
Most Recent Customer Reviews
I would not recommend this book. the author set out to do a hatchet job on his subject. most unfair and rather pompously writtenPublished on 8 April 2013 by N G MCCRUM
Must be one of the best books on a politician of that time,cannot say more than than a must read for students of this period.Published on 1 Jan. 2013 by t gates
The detail is fascinating but I suspect the story is somewhat 'spun'. I was unsurpised to discover that the author was a Labour supporter as I seemed to detect a certain zeal to... Read morePublished on 3 Aug. 2012 by Seaweed
Look for similar items by category
- Books > Biography > Historical > 1901 Onwards
- Books > Biography > Historical > Britain > Military
- Books > Biography > Historical > Countries & Regions > Europe
- Books > Biography > Political > Britain
- Books > History > Britain & Ireland > Ireland
- Books > History > Europe > France > French Heads of State
- Books > History > Political History > Politicians