Davies: God'S Playground Vol 1 (Paper) Paperback – 20 Feb 1984
Customers who viewed this item also viewed
What other items do customers buy after viewing this item?
Enter your mobile number or email address below and we'll send you a link to download the free Kindle App. Then you can start reading Kindle books on your smartphone, tablet, or computer - no Kindle device required.
To get the free app, enter your mobile phone number.
"Davies is the foremost historian of modern Poland. Of his previous books, "God's Playground: A History of Poland" is widely regarded as a landmark account." -- Carlo D'Este, "New York Times Book Review"
About the Author
Norman Davies is chair of the history department, School of Slavonic and East European Studies, at the University of London. --This text refers to an out of print or unavailable edition of this title.
Top customer reviews
For a start, 1918-39 was the one period under consideration when Poland was actually an independent country and hence had an impact on the wider world, and I felt this period deserved more than the one chapter it got in the book. It also struck me that the book often seemed to assume the reader had prior knowledge. Do you know what the BBWR was? OzON? These concepts are introduced well before they are explained. Do you know where Zaolzie is, and that when Davies refers in passing to its occupation, he is referring to the Polish invasion of Czechoslovakia in the aftermath of the Munich agreement in 1938? If the sins of Józef Beck have been "especially exaggerated", it would be useful to know by whom, and roughly what arguments they advanced, before being presented with Davies' counterarguments.
It feels in several places like Davies has an excessively pro-Polish perspective. This is perhaps natural given that he is married to a Pole and apparently lives there at least partly, but is worth keeping in mind. The book seems to have developed a semi-official status in Poland also, which he is proud to tell the reader about from within its own pages.
While he doesn't shy away from criticising individual Poles and Polish society when he feels it appropriate, in foreign affairs he seems to consistently take Poland's side, sometimes on what seem to me rather flimsy grounds. For example, the wars with the short-lived West Ukrainian republic and Lithuania, where in both cases there was a predominantly Polish city (Lwów and Wilno respectively) surrounded by predominantly non-Polish countryside. Rather than take the opportunity to point out the impossibility of drawing a neat border that respected "the self-determination of peoples", and regret the violent means by which these issues were "solved", he criticises the Ukrainians for "demanding their national rights in full and at once" and the Lithuanians for their "sorry obsession with the city of Wilno, in which hardly any Lithuanians were then living", without reflecting that similar criticisms could easily be levelled at Poland also.
He seems very keen to excuse Józef Beck, who largely determined Poland's foreign policy in the run-up to the Second World War. While it may be true that nothing he did would have made any difference, was invading Czechoslovakia and bullying Lithuania really the best thing to spend Poland's energies on in 1938-9? Davies assures us that this was done to "prevent encirclement by the Germans". I have thought for a while about what this could possibly mean, but am still at a loss. It seems to me that it gravely weakened Poland's international reputation, while making no military difference when the Nazi invasion did arrive a few months later.
As a final point, he has special ire reserved for British liberals, such as David Lloyd George, John Maynard Keynes and E.H. Carr, who had a mostly critical stance towards Poland and its deeds in this period. Rather than offering suggestions of why they might have developed such views, he instead chooses to place their statements about Poland alongside those of Hitler and Stalin, and suggests they should have considered "the company they were keeping". It seems you could do the same e.g. with statements by Churchill and Hitler about Bolshevism, and arrive at similar conclusions. I may consider myself thoroughly opposed to someone, but that doesn't mean I have a moral obligation to disagree with them on every single subject!
Not knowing much of poland prior to reading god's playground i found this book to be informative to the highest degree.
With great heros,wars,artists,poets and crazy nobles.
To the horrific brutality of the nazi occupation and holocaust visited on poland.
With a very complex social and idealogical difference to its neighbours poland led the way to a now considerd western libral democracy,stating in one instance europes first commission of national education.
For a country that has been missunderstood for too many years i found this book to be a great account of a complex and sometimes heartbreaking history of poland.
A great history by a great historian.
Rising '44: The Battle for WarsawAnother great book by davies.
Would you like to see more reviews about this item?
Most recent customer reviews
Look for similar items by category