- Also check our best rated Biography reviews
Blind Descent: The Quest to Discover the Deepest Place on Earth Hardcover – 15 Jun 2010
|New from||Used from|
|Hardcover, 15 Jun 2010||
Customers who viewed this item also viewed
What other items do customers buy after viewing this item?
Enter your mobile number or email address below and we'll send you a link to download the free Kindle App. Then you can start reading Kindle books on your smartphone, tablet, or computer - no Kindle device required.
To get the free app, enter your mobile phone number.
Heart-stopping and relentlessly gripping. Tabor takes us on an odyssey into unfathomable worlds beneath us, and into the hearts of rare explorers who will do anything to get there first. (Robert Kurson, author of Shadow Divers)
Hair-raising . . . the chronicle of an obsession to reach the deepest, darkest, loneliest, scariest, least survivable pocket of the planet....A big thumping man-book like The Perfect Storm. (Washington Post.)
Using a pulse-pounding narrative, this is tense real-life adventure pitting two master cavers mirroring the cold war with very uncommonly high stakes. (Publishers Weekly, starred review)
Blind Descent is as awe-inspiring as any adventure story above ground. Tabor's claustrophobic and pulse-pounding narrativepulls no punches in describing the many terrifying hazards that cavers face underground. Blind Descent is a captivating summer read for adventure seekers and armchair adrenaline junkies alike. (Amazon.com Best Books of June 2010)
A fascinating and informative introduction to the sport of cave diving, as well as a dramatic portrayal of a significant man-vs.-nature conflict. (Kirkus Reviews) --This text refers to the Paperback edition.
The New York Times bestselling account of a thrilling real-life journey into deepest cave on earth. --This text refers to the Paperback edition.See all Product description
Top customer reviews
The book is a fun read, if a little breathlessly hyperbolic about the lifestyle of a cave explorer. The author writes in fine style and creates very well the feeling of claustrophobia and desperation that must be faced by the caving expedition teams. There's not a terribly deep moral to the stories in the book and there's not much to take away from the book in an intellectual sense, but the author created sufficient enthusiasm in me that I ended up looking at the autobiography of the American team leader. Inspiration to dig deeper (no pun intended) into the subject matter is an indicator of a good read, I think!
The story is worthy of 5 stars, but I have to take at least one star off for the terrible prictures - so small you cannot see them and the total lack of diagrams & maps.
A simple map of the two regions, and some 'pyramid tunnel like' drawing of 3 or 4 of the primary caves mentioned, drawn to scale, annotated with dates and depths, would add tremendously to the book. Shame really, opportunity missed.
Still, Tabor's story is by a non-specialist, for non-specialists, and it captures much of the excitement of intense caving. The description of the six-day trip by Bill Stone and Barbara am Ende to the bottom of Huautla is genuinely thrilling. I recall sitting at the top of a pitch in a deep Pyrenean pothole after 20 hours on the go, hallucinating and hypothermic (but fortunately well clipped on) - and on that occasion I had only been underground for three days. Six days, on the wrong side of a big sump, at great depth is unimaginable.
As has been said, Tabor concentrates unnecessarily on an implicit duel between two very different expedition leaders. The caving expeditions I used to go on never had 'leaders'; they were loose cooperatives, with everything done by consensus and trust, and they worked fine that way. Harder to write about, though.
As the twenty-first century began, we believed with equal certainty that every one of the earth's great discoveries had been made. Almost a century had passed since Peary first trod the North Pole...'
So begins Blind Descent, James M. Tabor's account of deep cave exploration over the last thirty or so years. As you can see, Tabor is not a man to let the facts stand in the way of a bold superlative. (The medieval world knew the earth is spherical; most historians think Peary never reached the North Pole.)
Tabor's habit of trying to vacuum pump the excitement by means of dodgy superlatives is a bad one. Sometimes the superlatives cancel each other out. On page 58 he tells us that 'supercaves are always noisy', comparing the volume to a 747 engine. By page 60 he is telling us that they are so quiet that cavers who have sex underground are inevitably overheard. On page 276 he tells us that he has not personally been in a cave, as he is not full-cave certified and that to go into caves without such training is 'tantamount to suicide'. By page 278 he is telling us that he knows about rigging and rebelays from 'my own caving experience'.
The narrative is structured as an Amundsen v Scott style race, with the goal being 'to discover the deepest place on earth'. Bill Stone leads the charge for America, exploring the Cheve Cave in southern Mexico. Meanwhile, Alexander Klimchouk of the Ukraine oversees the exploration of the Krubera cave in the Republic of Georgia.
In the end, 'the deepest place on earth' turns out to be another one of Tabor's dodgy superlatives. It is not at all clear that either Stone or Klimchouk have found the deepest place: exploration of both caves is ongoing and who is to say there aren't deeper ones elsewhere? There are also quite tricky definitional questions of what 'the deepest place' would mean since (as Tabor shows) a degree of digging and even blasting is accepted practice. How should the line between caving and mining be drawn?
Also irritating are his thumb-nail portraits of the various actors. Particularly cringe-worthy are the hot-or-not descriptions of the women who enter the story. Carol Vesely is a 'petite blonde'; Barbara am Ende has a 'very attractive face'; Beverly Shade is a 'stunning brunette' for heaven sake.
Maximum embarassment is reached when Tabor starts to muse on the obsession that drives explorers:
'Obsession may be part of love, and love part of obsession. What is perfume about, after all, but love, and what is one of the most popular essences d'amour called but Obsession? If more proof of love and obsession's link be needed, consider this: Obsession's elegant bottle resembles nothing so much as the male organ, ready for love. The sharpest marketers on earth, who know a lot, understand that the two conditions are as intertwined as lovers on a bed.'
In short, then, Blind Descent has a number of irritating features. But to be fair, it also has some virtues. As Tabor points out, the literature on caving is tiny compared with the libraries of books on mountaineering and polar exploration, and much of his material is (to this reader anyway) fresh. The description of the development of the techniques and technologies of caving (particularly the use of 'rebreathers') was fascinating. And the account of the exploration of Cheve, which has led to several deaths, was truly gripping.
If you're just looking for an exciting true life adventure story I'd recommend Jon Krakauer's Into Thin Air and Jennifer Niven's The Ice Master. But if you're specifically interested in caving, Blind Descent is worth a look.
Would you like to see more reviews about this item?
Most recent customer reviews
Look for similar items by category