LP2, Alan Wake has never really ticked it for me, and this game seems like an OK title but after the dissapointment of GTA IV, I will refrain from buying it, a rental for me, although it does have a potential to be great.
Halo Reach. I never felt Halo after the first two, it set a good, high standard, but then seemed to get stuck in a rut of same-ness to the extent that it starts to feel very much like an original xbox game with snazy graphics.. Maybe because I don't play multiplayer I'm missing the point, but I may rent Reach, I may not. It really depends on if I can be bothered or not.
Starcraft 1 with updated graphics being released under the name of Starcraft 2. Everyone seems to be going crazy about this game but for me it's just a rehash of the old RTS'. Give me Rome Total War with updated graphics though, and I'll go mental. I guess it's just what you're into. Granted this isn't for 360, so to get back on track I'll go with Mafia2, Alan Wake, Lost Planet 2, Splinter Cell, Blur... anything other than RDR and Reach basically.
Halo Reach. Never got the fuss about Halo 3, just seemed like a vaguely repetitive shoot the alien fest...and the multiplayer wasn't brilliant in my opinion either. I don't massively like other hyped games but often I can see why people do enjoy them, just wasn't true of Halo 3. For example, Bioshock, I personally didn't enjoy it that much, but I can see why others would love the whole dystopian feel and the gameplay, where as with Halo? I just don't underestand.