21 of 21 people found the following review helpful
The First of an Almost Perfect Trio,
This review is from: Discipline (Audio CD)I had been talking to a friend, in the early 1980s, about bands and music we liked. He was a big King Crimson fan and recommended Starless and Bible Black and Red which I really liked when I heard them and I started to listen to other KC stuff. Then I read about a new Robert Fripp project with Bill Bruford, Adrian Belew, and Tony Levin. I was really into music that all of these people had been involved with prior to this so I was excited. When I heard that Fripp had decided that this new band represented a new King Crimson I had mixed feelings. On the one hand I thought brilliant a new version of this fantastic music but on the other I was worried that it would not live up to expectations.
I needn't have worried, this was everything I hoped it would be and more. I know that Fripp was a bit concerned that Belew's lyrical stylings and vocal delivery had become a bit too influenced by David Byrne's in places but Belew had been evrywhere from Talking Heads/Tom Tom Clube via Zappa and Bowie around this time so it was unsurprising that he picked up some influences along the way. From the opening bars of Elephant Talk this is just a fantasic rock album, and the people would get all shirty about prog rock should just get out more. The moaning of the punks who still go on and on and on and on........ about how prog rock went on.... (you get the picture) are more boring than the longest of gutar/keyboard noodlings/ drum solos I have every heard.
This album does none of that though it just delivers.
The follow up Beat was equally as good with the third installment, Three of a Perfect Pair, nearly hitting the mark but not quite (a four rather than five star effort)
The next reawakening of the Crimson Dinosaur, Thrak, where the entire KC history is distilled into one album. If you want to hear more after this these are the places to go.
Tracked by 2 customers
Sort: Oldest first | Newest first
Showing 1-2 of 2 posts in this discussion
Initial post: 9 Mar 2013 17:09:13 GMT
Sebastian Palmer says:
'The moaning of the punks who still go on and on and on and on........ about how prog rock went on.... are more boring than the longest of gutar/keyboard noodlings/ drum solos I have every heard.'
Testify! I can only say 'amen, brother McClure'. Well said. Funny, and very true.
Posted on 2 Oct 2013 15:08:22 BDT
Have to agree that this album, when released, was absolutely unique. The assault on the eardrums sublime and extremely powerful, for a true fan of musical innovation as I am. I say 'when released' because of course Beat and Three Of A Perfect Pair have a similar sound being produced by the same line-up. The lyrics, in particular Elephant Talk and Indiscipline, are hilarious and clever, the musicianship faultless. Fripp's effortless technique on Frame By Frame a case in point. I love this album to this day........when four musicians of this calibre are involved it is too much to hope that the result will be better than the sum of its parts - but it is!!!!!! Awesome.
‹ Previous 1 Next ›