It's interesting how you write about grammatical errors, then continue to produce some of your own.
" I gave it as a gift "..if it was a gift what else would you do, sell it, lend it?
" he hasn't started reading it yet"..he being...the milkman, postman, husband, boyfriend, son...??
Surely your comment should start with the letter " I ", As should your last sentence.
If you're going to criticise others...