7 of 8 people found the following review helpful
Moving and dramatic - loved it!,
This review is from: My Boy Jack [DVD] (DVD)
My Boy Jack is the moving true story of John 'Jack' Kipling, son of world-famous author Rudyard Kipling. Zealous war supporter Rudyard is eager to see his son go to war and play his part in protecting King and country. Jack is equally keen, and is devasted to be turned away from the Navy and the Army due to his appalling eyesight.
Incensed, his father uses his fame and influence to secure Jack a commission with the Irish Guards and after gruelling training, he is sent to France in charge of a Battalion. Jack is determined to let nothing stand in the way of him fighting, and already had his father write a letter giving him permission to be sent 'over the top' before his eighteenth birthday. However, fate dictates that Jack and his men go to fight the day after his birthday - horrendously outnumbered by German soldiers.
Sadly, Jack's family receive a telegram to say he has gone missing in battle, presumed wounded. Devastated, but never giving up hope, Jack's parents search for him, using all of Rudyard's military contacts, and interviewing returning soldiers. They slowly begin together pieces of the puzzle, and eventually a soldier from Jack's Battalion visits them. Unfortunately, he brings the news that Jack was in fact killed in battle. At eighteen years and one day old, John Kipling lost his life to German soldiers.
The family is thrown into turmoil, and Rudyard now has to question whether his support for the war was worth the life of his only son. Unfortunately it is too late, and the family must learn to cope without Jack.
Many people have questionned Daniel Radcliffe's acting abilities, but I think My Boy Jack will put those wagging tongues to rest. Radcliffe is very convincing in this TV drama, particularly as he is around the same age as the real Jack was when he lost his life. It's great to see him in a completely different role to Harry Potter - and lets hope this will help him avoid being pigeonholed.
Those playing members of Jack's family were also fantastic. David Haig and Kim Cattrall play his grieving parents excellently, and relative newcomer Carey Mulligan does a fine job of playing Jack's sister, Elsie. Overall I felt they were a very believable family, and their reactions during Jack's absence, and on receiving confirmation of his death brought a tear to my eye. Overall, this is a really moving production, and I think even those not really into wartime dramas will enjoy this.
Tracked by 1 customer
Sort: Oldest first | Newest first
Showing 1-4 of 4 posts in this discussion
Initial post: 5 Mar 2008 15:36:55 GMT
Last edited by the author on 5 Mar 2008 15:45:39 GMT
The BigE says:
How about putting a 'This review contains a complete spoiler' at the beginning? I was going to purchase this but don't think I'll bother now seeing as you've just about given a full rundown of the story including the fact that the main character is killed! I bet you're a real hoot at parties! Thanks again! Your title should read "avid reader and complete spoilsport".
In reply to an earlier post on 3 Apr 2008 21:23:57 BDT
Lucy Felthouse says:
You've only got to read the book or know the actual story to know he was killed. It was hardly a big revelation.
In reply to an earlier post on 25 May 2008 22:11:09 BDT
I suppose you don't read biographies either, on the grounds that the main character usually dies in the end?
Posted on 11 Mar 2012 15:25:45 GMT
I would be very surprised indeed if the 18 year old 2nd Lieutenent John Kipling was sent to France in charge of a Batallion - such a command is normally reserved for officers of the rank of lieutenant colonel, who seldom reach that rank below twice John's age - and more often than not closer to 40. Kipling would have neen in command of a platoon at most.
‹ Previous 1 Next ›