32 of 39 people found the following review helpful
This review is from: The Shamanic Way of the Bee: Ancient Wisdom and Healing Practices of the Bee Masters (Paperback)
Buxton's book was enthusiastically recommended to me by a naive friend who seemed to think it had something to do with authentic British spiritual traditions. I should have trusted my first impulse and never opened it at all, as its sensationalising approach could not be more at odds with the subtle energies of the bees and the deep wisdom they hold for us. At least Lynn Andrews and the author of the fictional Mutant Message Down Under were eventually taken to task by outraged Native Americans and Aborigines, whose teachings they had grossly distorted. But when are the real bee-keepers going to speak out about Buxton's glamourising approach to this potentially soul-nourishing topic?!! Anyone who know a dedicated bee-keeper will realise that their typically gentle and unassuming path of service in cooperation with bees is a world away from the sexualised and narcissistic fantasy that Buxton calls the Path of Pollen(!)
The ancient wisdom associated with the bee undoubtedly deserves more attention at this time, when the creature's very survival is in question because of modern pesticides and our misguided over-exploitation of the bee's skills in pollination and honey collection. But that looming crisis doesn't seem to interest Buxton much at all. There are rumours that the book was ghost-written, and it certainly received a very sceptical review in Shaman's Drum. So try to apply a tad of discernment when approaching the Shamanic Way of the Bee. Just because it's now being exploited yet again, in this publicity-seeking fiction, doesn't mean the bee isn't the guardian of precious spiritual truths. If you are really interested in the spiritual significance of bees, I recommend 9 Lectures on Bees by Rudolf Steiner, or the excellent study of world-wide bee folklore by Hilda M Ransome.
Sort: Oldest first | Newest first
Showing 1-3 of 3 posts in this discussion
Initial post: 9 Jul 2013 18:57:27 BDT
secret writer says:
I have started reading the book and so far I'm loving it to be honest but after reading several negative reviews I feel the need to gain some clarity. I don't wish to be duped and I'm seriously interested in the subject. where can I find these lectures? will I be doing myself/bee shamanism a dis-service by reading/believing this book? or is it ok to enjoy the 'picture-language' ?
In reply to an earlier post on 30 Aug 2013 09:47:32 BDT
Ross Heaven says:
A 'bee maiden' (i.e. a woman who has spent a considerable amount of time and money on Buzzton's 'path of pollen' "initiation" courses) writes to me just today that...
"I'll be as brief as possible. I was drawn to undertake Path of Pollen workshops and trainings having read The Shamanic Way of the Bee and taken it on trust that the book is, as it claims, an authentic account of the author's initiation into the Path of Pollen. What I have recently discovered has shaken that trust considerably and left me wondering if I have been a) duped and b) exploited.
"As you will see, it appears that significant passages in The Shamanic Way of the Bee (TSWOTB), including whole paragraphs, appear to have been lifted virtually word-for-word from the much earlier essays of the late P.L. Travers, who is best known as the author of Mary Poppins but was also a lifelong student of and writer upon myth and fairy tales. Worse still, these key passages are variously presented as either the dialogue between Bridge and Twig in TSWOTB and also the first person narrative. There is no indication that use of the passages in question was authorised by P.L.Travers or her estate and P.L.Travers' work is not acknowledged either in footnotes or the bibliography at the back of TSWOTB.
"Some people may not care whether or not there is any truth in TSWOTB or if it is simply one man's eloquent modern fantasy, but to me at least there is something deeply unethical about passing another's words off as one's own and it raises serious questions about the authenticity of the Path of Pollen as a whole. I present some of the evidence below for you to make up your own minds.
"The P.L Travers work I quote from is "What The Bee Knows - Reflections on Myth Symbol and Story, foreword by David Applebaum, Codhill Press edition 2010
"P.L. Travers, What The Bee Knows (WTBK) (from the essay entitled What The Bee Knows, first published in Parabola magazine, New York 1981) page 81: "For the Bee has at all times and places been the symbol of life - life as immortality. In the Celtic languages, the Cornish 'beu' the Irish 'beo', the Welsh 'byw', can all be translated as 'alive' or 'living'; the Greek 'bios' has been mentioned above and is the French 'abeille' not akin to these? So, the Bee stands for - or is a manifestation of - the fundamental verb 'to be'. 'I am, thou art, he is', it declares, as it goes humming past. ... No wonder then that mythologically the bee is a ritual creature of a host of lordly ones... To anyone capable of suspending for a moment the cavortings of the rational mind, of accepting myth for what it is - not lie but the very veritable truth - it needs no great inward effort to act upon such advice. It's a matter, merely, of listening."
"Pp30-31 The Shamanic Way of the Bee (closing paragraphs of Bridge's first knowledge lecture): "The Bee Master knows the bee as the most remarkable of creatures, a social alchemist and truly nature's most astonishing being," he reflected before displaying his discreet passion for language and linguistics. It has at all times and places been the symbol of life - life as immortality. In the Celtic language, the Cornish 'beu' the Irish 'beo' and the Welsh 'byw', can all be translated as 'alive' or 'living'. The Greek word bios should also be mentioned. So, the Bee stands for - or is a manifestation of - the fundamental verb 'to be'. 'I am, thou art, he is', it declares, as it goes humming by.. if we look to myth the bee is the ritual creature of a host of lordly ones. To anyone capable for a moment of suspending the cavortings of the rational mind, of accepting myth for what it is - not a story or a lie or a corruption of the facts, but the very essence of truth - it should need no great inward effort to access their significance." His eyes bore into me, testing to see if I had yet understood. Then he spoke again, very slowly: "It is a matter, merely, of listening."
"P.L. Travers, (WTBK) p86: "When does the old year end?" asks a child. "On the first stroke of midnight", he is told. "And the new year - when does it begin?" "On the last stroke of midnight." " Well then, what happens in between?" The question, once asked, required an answer from those who know what the Druids knew. Long after I had written down this story, I listened to a radio reporter who was describing the ceremonies of an African tribe at the end of their lunar - or solar? -year. At a given moment, it appeared, the chanting and the drumming ceased as the gods invisibly withdrew. For a few seconds - twelve perhaps - absolute silence reigned. Then the drums broke out again in triumph as the gods as the gods invisibly returned with the new year in their arms. 'And' the reporter added 'though I do not ask you to believe it, I can vouch for the fact that my tape recorder, for those few moments of sacred silence, without a touch of my hand, stopped spinning"
"p35-36 TSWOB: "The end of the year falls exactly at the beginning of the first stroke of midnight on December 31, and the new year begins as the last stroke ends. But what happens in between?... ... In answer to Bridge's question, I told him a story I had heard as a child that had stayed with me over the years. A correspondent for the BBC World Service was describing the ceremonies of an African tribal people at the end of their lunar cycle. At a given moment, the chanting and drumming ceased as the gods and deities invisibly withdrew from the world... ... For just a few moments, absolute silence reigned in Africa as the gods withdrew. Then the drums broke out again in triumph as the spirits invisibly returned, cradling the new year in their arms. The reason I had recalled the story was that the reporter, a modern western man, had added that though he did not expect his listeners to believe him, he would vouch that during the few moments of sacred silence, his tape recorder had completely stopped working."
"P.L.Travers WTBK p86: "Anyone used to yoga practice experiences the ritual pause between the outgoing and the indrawn breath. Between one breathtime and the next, between one lifetime and the next, something waits for a moment."
"p37 The Shamanic Way of the Bee "... the Bee Master continued. He reminded me that in meditation working with the breath, there is usually a ritual pause between the outgoing and incoming breath. "Between one breath and the next, between one lifetime and the next, something waits for a moment...."
"P.L Travers WTBK p11: "The homeland of myth, the country which in the old Russian stories is called East of the sun and West of the moon, and for which there is no known map"
"TSWOTB p98 "To my surprise and delight, on this occasion Bridge continued to elaborate: "The Melissae are women who live in a country that is east of the sun and west of the moon for which there is no known map."
"P.L. Travers WTBK P267 From the essay "About The Sleeping Beauty" "The Thirteenth Wise Woman stands as a guardian of the threshold, the paradoxical adversary without whose presence no threshold can be passed."
"p102. TSWOTB "Early next morning, I wandered into the garden and found an austere presence dressed in black, awaiting my arrival before the Gate of Transition. She was as the Thirteenth Wise Woman who stands as guardian of the threshold, the paradoxical adversary without whose presence no threshold may be passed"
.... Hmmm indeed. Or should that be bzzzzzusted?
And it's not just the one email. A few days before the one above, I got this one, which might serve as a cautionary tale if you've aspirations to beecome a 'bee maiden' yourself...
"My name is XXX and it is now around six years or so since I was a shamanic practitioner student under the "tutelage" of Simon Buxton. I am myself trained as a psychotherapist, having specialised in working with abuse and am now writing a Phd on the embodiment of the sacred. Indeed it is partly some of the work on a chapter I am writing at present (exploring in part Gerald Gardner's of Golden Dawn fame own initiatory relationship with the questionably existing muse "Old Dorothy") which prompted me to write to you, as I found myself thinking about what I perceive to be the similarities in the cases of Buxton and Gardener. My own relationship with Simon was difficult, such that at the end of a period of extensive financial and spiritual investment, I found myself having to make a choice between what I experienced as abusive spiritual authority and my own and needing quite simply to walk in the opposite direction to the organisation I had hoped would provide me with a supportive home. I chose my own, amidst considerable confusion and pain..."
Good luck y'all if you choose to buy into the bee cult.
In reply to an earlier post on 11 Nov 2015 19:55:58 GMT
baphomette de medici says:
still waiting for the lawsuit from Travers, Heaven....i sense a bit of bitterness which may or may not be well-founded. the bitterness, that is...
‹ Previous 1 Next ›