11 of 11 people found the following review helpful
Stuffed full of festive cheer,
This review is from: The Empty Stocking (Paperback)
Twin sisters Charlie and Sam are a little bit worried about Christmas. Sam is a good girl - she works hard at school, she's well behaved and polite. But her sister Charlie isn't always a good girl. She's a bit naughty every now and then, she's cheeky and school, and she's worried that it means that Santa won't bring her any Christmas presents. When the girls are asleep, Santa visits. But what the girls don't know is that this year, Santa is getting tough. Very tough. However, when Charlie wakes up in the middle of night, she realises something's gone horribly wrong. Is Charlie going to be able to make it all okay for her and her sister again?!
As an adult, you can probably guess exactly what's happened, but Harry didn't have a clue about what was coming for poor Sam and Charlie. As the story went on, I could see Harry's face starting to drop as he realised what was going on, and I liked that it draws out the emotions in children, and perhaps makes them think about their own behaviour as well! When we talked it through afterwards, he could explain what had gone on, why it had happened and I can see that Curtis has targeted this book perfectly for its age group. Harry knew that it was Charlie's behaviour that was the consequence of what Santa did, but he also recognised the good in her later actions too, and I think the story has a fantastic moral to it. It also goes to show how we judge too quickly, and even I was surprised at the twist with Charlie at the end.
As I mentioned, the illustrations in the book were perfect for it, and they are just as important to the book as the words, without a doubt. Cobb has really got into the heart of the characters, and they really come to life on the pages. The detail in the pictures is excellent, from the intricate detail on a full page illustration inside Charlie and Sam's house, to the expressions on the girls face, especially Charlie's towards the end of the book are superb, and really convey so much on their own. Father Christmas/Santa looks like a traditional Santa should, and I have to say I did like that the scenery pictures weren't covered in snow... making it a proper British picture book! Cobb's drawing are simply gorgeous, and really complement Curtis' story, they are a joy to study and look at as much as the words are to read.
This has quickly become of one of my favourite Christmas picture books to share with Harry, and we've already read it a few times despite the fact we've only had it a week! I love the morals at the heart of it, the fact that Santa actually does the unthinkable, and that it shows that even naughty girls have hearts of gold too. The lovely Christmassy illustrations work beautifully throughout the book, and I have to say I like that it was a bit longer than a normal picture book too, lots of words in here to enjoy. Harry could confidently read this himself, there aren't any tricky words as such, but it's a nice one for parents to read aloud, and chat about with your children as you're reading too. I cannot recommend 'The Empty Stocking' highly enough, this is Richard Curtis at his best. Simply brilliant.
Sort: Oldest first | Newest first
Showing 1-2 of 2 posts in this discussion
Initial post: 26 Nov 2012 22:41:07 GMT
michael heal says:
You say this book is perfect for the age group. What age group is it targeted at please? Could it be read in one sitting?
In reply to an earlier post on 26 Nov 2012 23:01:29 GMT
I'd say 4 years and over... it's readable in one sitting by an adult to a child.
‹ Previous 1 Next ›